Alex Brown

APB 30001

Alex Brown receiving the leader’s baton from  NoW representative Ron Bacchus

Alex P Brown was born on 9th September 1944, and became one of the best distance runners in Scotland.    It’s maybe not surprising that that was the case – his father Andrew was a good Scottish runner for Motherwell YMCA after the war, and his older brother Andrew Brown was one of the country’s best ever representatives and captained the national cross country team for many years.   They all ran for Motherwell YMCA until Law & District AAC was formed in 1967 when Alex and Andy both switched to what was now their local club.   They are best known for their cross-country and road running exploits but were also classy track runners.   Andy was the older by 12 years and provided Alex a lot of ‘instant experience’.   The family all helped each other – there are stories of their Dad tieing Andy’s shoe laces before a race to make sure they were tight enough; I have two instances of Andy giving good advice to Alex in the race situation.   First, at Beith before the New Year’s Day race, when Alex did some strides from the starting line away from the direction of the race he was called back by big brother and told to do them down in the way the race was to go because, “they’ll start the race if you’re 50 yards behind the line, they’ll not start it if you’re 50 yards in front of the line!”    And then at the last ever Rangers Sports when Alex and I were on the same mark in a crowded Mile handicap race.   We were off 100 yards + and Andy appeared immediately before the start – “Watch the starter,” he told Alex, “and go when you see the smoke: you’ll see that before you hear the gun and can pick up some places.”   I used both myself and passed on the advice to many runners that I coached.   Two miles to go at the end of the first stage of the Edinburgh to Glasgow relay and Andy calls out to Alex to pick up the pace NOW – less than 10 minutes running left.”     Well, maybe for him, but not for too many on the stage that year.    Alex grew up in a running household, he was given advice and help but there were also expectations laid on him – if not by the family, certainly by other athletes.   He responded well.    It’s as a road and cross-country runner that this profile will concentrate but a look at his ability and performances on the track would be worth while.   First his progress and rankings over distances from the Mile to Six Miles are summarised in the following table.

Year Distance Time Ranking
1962 2 Miles 9:19.9 13
1963 1 Mile 4:20.9 33
2 Miles 9:09.4 11
3 Miles 14:04.8 9
1964 2 Miles 9:06.6 12
3 Miles 14:17.2 9
3000m St 9:32.4 9
1965 2 Miles 9:07.4 16
3 Miles 14:00.6 10
3000m St 9:47.8 13
1966 2 Miles 9:20.4 26
3 Miles 14:28.0 28
1967 2 Miles 8:54.8 8
3 Miles 13:56.0 12
6 Miles 28:55.0 5
1968 2 Miles 9:08.0 18
3 Miles 14:06.0 17
1969 3000m 8:26.0 13
5000m 14:43.6 27
1972 3000m 8:42.8 27

The typical summer season for endurance runners in the 1960’s was to run in their county championships, the two miles team races all summer, the championships, any invitation events that came up and a few road races such as the Tom Scott 10 Miles Law to Motherwell.   Alex followed that pattern – one of the differences between then and now was the summer two mile team races in which all the best runners competed head to head.    Shettleston’s Lachie Stewart, Dick Wedlock, Hen ry Summerhill and all would compete against Motherwell’s McCafferty, Brown, McKay and company as well as Victoria Park’s Hugh Barrow, Pat Maclagan and Joe Reilly.   The racing scene was the better for it, in my opinion.   As an example we could look at a typical summer, 1964, when he won his only Scottish track vest.  The list of races is not comprehensive but gives the pattern followed for most years.  He started the summer with sixth place in the Tom Scott road race in 50:50 and along with Andy (2nd) and Bert McKay (4th) was part of the winning team.   On 13th June Motherwell won the Two Miles team race at Shawfield where the Lanarkshire Police Sports was the event.   The team was McKay, Brown and Brown.   The following week the same trio won the Babcock & Wilcox Two Miles although Lachie Stewart won the individual race for the second week in succession.   There were no medals at the SAAA Championships on the last weekend in June, and the Motherwell team did not travel to Kinlochleven for the two miles at that Highland Gathering where Shettleston won easily.  In the SAAA Championships at Edinburgh he was fourth in the Three Miles in 14:17.2.   Then it was Gourock Highland Games in the last week of the month and Shettleston with a very strong team beat a Motherwell team without Ian McCafferty.   His next reported outing was at Ayr, on 8th August, he competed in the Scotland  v  Ireland in the steeplechase where he finished second to team mate Robert Henderson in 9:32. 4.   Henderson ran 9:23.8.     Scotland won by 102 pts to 91.   Motherwell as a team was quiet for several weeks although Bert McKay and Ian McCafferty were active across Scotland and, in McCafferty’s case, south of the border.  On 12th August there was an open meeting at Westerlands in Glasgow where Lachie beat Ian McCafferty by two yards in 9:03 with Alex third in 9:06.6.   Three and a half seconds down on that pair was a very good run – although Alex might have been a bit ambivalent about having brought Ian into the sport in he first place!    At the end of the month there was the Cowal Games at Dunoon where in the invitation two miles, Derek Ibbotson defeated Hugh Barrow and Ian McCafferty: although there was no names for the team event given in the result it is safe to guess that Alex Brown was out in such a big race, held before what was probably the biggest crowd in the country.    It is however as a road and cross-country runner that he is best known.

APB 30002 (1)

Alex in the middle, between Les Meneely (B7) and Tom O’Reilly

As a cross-country runner he was really first noticed in January 1962 when he won the West District Youths Championships at Strathleven, Dumbarton.    Andy won the senior title with team mates Bert McKay and John Lineker in second and third and Alex defeated his friend and team-mate Ian McCafferty by 2 second for the Youths event with Hugh Barrow 15 seconds further back.   He had been fifth in the same age group the previous year and third behind Hugh Barrow and J Grant (Monkland) in the previous year’s Boys race, although it should be noted that he was on the same time as Grant and only 5 seconds behind Barrow.   Already we are seeing one of the reasons for Alex Brown’s lack of appropriate recognition – his contemporaries included luminaries of the Scottish distance running scene as Ian McCafferty, Hugh Barrow, Lachie Stewart and that entire generation of top class athletes.   The Midlands Youths title was his first real championship victory and indicated that he was not just a good boy runner.   On 3rd March, 1962, the cross-country runners all headed for Hamilton for the national championships and it was here that Alex won an even bigger event – the result of the Youths race was 1.   AP Brown 15:18;   2.  I McCafferty 15:23;   3.   WH Barrow  15:23.   Three within five seconds, two on the same time.   It was a tough race but the younger Brown had come through it triumphantly.

Season 1962-63 Alex was out in the McAndrew relay at Scotstoun in the winning Motherwell team.   Taking them from third to first and followed by Andy running the fastest time of the day, his first season racing seniors started well, and he also had the day’s third fastest time.   The following week the team won the Lanarkshire county title and again Brown had the third fastest time.   The YMCA championship was won the following week, he missed the Garscube Harriers races the following week (McCafferty won) and then in the Midland Relay Championships he gave the winning Motherwell team a 130 yards lead at the end of the first lap, to finish the short relay season.   Andy had the fastest time of the day with Alex second quickest over the Stirling trail.   Then it was the big one, the Edinburgh to Glasgow relay and Alex was one of the four from the club who set stage fastest times when he moved the club from third to second on the fifth stage.   His running had earned him a place in the SCCU team to compete against the British Army team on 28th November at Barrachnie, Glasgow,  where he finished eighth.   On 6th December the Motherwell team was out in force at the Lanarkshire championships and the winning squad was made up of McCafferty (1), Andy Brown (2) and Alex (4).   Then came his second representative run in a week – the SCCU team defeated Scottish Universities in a trail from King’s Buildings.   McCafferty won from Andy Brown, with Bill Ewing third, Roger Young fifth, Lachie Stewart fifth, Alex Brown sixth and Hugh Barrow seventh.   Into the new year and Alex’s introduction to the classic road races continued with sixth place in a star studded field for the Nigel Barge Trophy at Maryhill.     Won by Ian McCafferty from Fergus Murray, Andy Brown, Lachie Stewart and Roger Young,  Alex was less than half a minute behind the winner.   There was another top class field battling it out at Strathleven, Dumbarton, the following week for the Midland District championship.   McCafferty won comfortably from Andy Brown, Lachie Stewart, Alex, Jim Johnston and Dick Wedlock.   (Looking at these runners facing each other week in, week out, it provokes the question about why we do not see such sterling battles as regularly now and whether there is a connection between that lack and the decline in standards,   In the National at Hamilton on 27th February, Alex raced in the Junior race where he was third.   Look at the quality in this one, runners in finishing order were Ian McCafferty, Roger Young, Alex Brown, Dick Wedlock, Walter Eadie, Ian Young and Jim Brennan.   The senior leaders were Fergus Murray, Jim Alder, Lachie Stewart, Andy Brown and Donald Macgregor.   The selectors did not select Brown for the international, choosing instead to have him, along with Roger Young, as reserve for the senior team.   The baptism of fire continued as Alex turned out in the Tom Scott Road Race on 3rd April  which was a battle royal between Alder, Andy Brown, Stewart and McCafferty while the second group contained Alastair Wood, Dick Wedlock, Jim Johnston and Henry Summerhill along with young Alex.   McCafferty faded seriously at the end to finish fifteenth with the first  four being Alder (47:34), Andy Brown (47:40), Lachie Stewart (48:45) and Alex (49:07).

1965 was a good year on the track for Alex but the winter would start again in the first week of October with the McAndrew Relay at Scotstoun.   Alex ran on the first stage for the team that won and set a new record for the course although Alex could nly finish three seconds behind Eddie Knox on the first stage.    In the Lnarkshire championship relay the following week Motherwell split their resources with Andy Brown and Bert McKay runningin the second team.   The A team with McCafferty, Alex, Wedlock and McNulty on comfortably enough in the end    A week later, 16th October, Motherwell travelled to Dundee for the Kingsway relay – it was unusual for them to run in this one where the main contenders were usually Shettleston, Victoria Park, Dundee Hawkhill and the university squads.   However the team of Davie Simpson, Alex and Andy Brown and Ian McCafferty won by 9 seconds from an Edinburgh University team of Elson, Gamwell, Blamire and Murray.  The following week was the Scottish YMCA relay championships and again Motherwell switched their teams around with one being made up of older runners (Marshall, McKay, Simpson and Andy Brown) and the other of younger men (Wedlock, Greenshields, Alex Brown and McCafferty.)   Separated by only two seconds at the end of the first lap, McKay opened up more than a minute on Greenshields which made the task facing McCafferty and Brown impossible.   And so it proved with the old’uns beating the young’uns by 36 seconds after McCafferty had started 58 seconds behind Andy Brown.  Nevertheless, McCafferty had the fastest time of the day with Alex third quickest.   They were separated by Andy Brown.   There was no messing about with team selections in the Midland District relays though – the top team of Alex Brown (second on the first stage behind Jim Brennan of Maryhill), Bert McKay, Andy Brown and McCafferty  was on duty and they duly won from Shettleston.   The only runner from the club to tackle the Glasgow University road race at the start of November was Bert McKay who finished second, 15 seconds down on Lachie Stewart.   The SCCU team to face the British Army on 27 November was chosen and it included both Brown brothers, Ian McCafferty, Jim Alder, Craig Douglas, Fergus Murray, Eddie Knox and Lachie Stewart.   The Edinburgh to Glasgow relay came two weeks later and while Motherwell had been carrying all before them in the west, a very good Edinburgh University team was doing at least as well in the East.   The two teams came head-to-head in an eight man a side competition.   Davie Simpson was third on the first stage on which Alistair Blamire was first for the University, Alex Brown pulled the team up to first on the second stage passing Joe Reilly of Victoria Park and Alex Wight of the University team.   But it was back to third for Motherwell on the next stage where Johnny Poulton dropped two places to Pat Maclagan (Victoria Park) and J Rough of Edinburgh Southern with the University back in fifth.   On to the fourth stage and Andy Brown in the fastest time of the day moved up to first while Chris Elson pulled the University into second place, 51 seconds down.   On the undulating and exposed fifth stage, Willie Marshall ran well but still dropped two places to Frank Gamwell (EU 1st) and Calum Laing (VPAAC 2nd).   Ian McCafferty v Fergus Murray on the long sixth stage with Murray having a 29 second advantage.   By the end of a terrific seven miles Murray had increased his lead to 66 seconds with Hugh Barrow in third place for Victoria Park.   John Wight for the University took a further 4 seconds out of Bert McKay with the fastest time on the penultimate stage and Roger Young coming across the line 80 seconds up on Motherwell’s Wedlock with Alistair Johnston of Victoria Park turning in the fastest time and finishing only 15 seconds behind in third for Victoria Park.    Alex’s run on the second stage had been a very good one indeed being one of only two runners inside 29 minutes for the stage.

The following week’s representative match against the Army was a bit of an anti-climax after that but Alex finished fourth in the race behind Stewart, Knox and McKay, McCafferty having been spiked on the starting line by a Scottish team reserve.   The New Year started with the annual Beith races where  Alex was second to Ian McCafferty with Andy in third place   On Monday, 3rd January at half-time in the Celtic v Rangers match at Parkhead, Alex was fourth on the ‘frozen, rutted’ track in 14:28  behind Lachie Stewart, Andy Brown and Jim Brennan.  and then in the Nigel Barge race the following Saturday, he was fourth behind Lachie Stewart, Eddie Knox and brother Andy.   It was a terrific start to the year and the next big race was the Midland District Championship one week later but Alex was side-lined and could not turn out for the club which finished second behind Victoria Park.   The National was held at Hamilton on February 26th that year and Alex was there and finished ninth.   The Motherwell team was without McCafferty who was the winner of the Junior race and Alex’s place was not good enough to get him into the team for the international at Rabat.

That three miles time in January was to remain his best for the year and the only other ranking time was the two miles run at Shotts – again on a difficult dirt track with one straight sloping slightly downhill and one slightly uphill – the time on 3rd September was 9:20.4.   Ranked twenty six in Scotland for two – and twenty eighth for three miles, he went into the first race of winter 1966 – 67.

As usual the winter season started with the short relays and this year the Motherwell team which had won everything the previous year, started with the problem that Ian McCafferty was not available for the first two relays.   This was compounded at the Lanarkshire relay by the absence of the injured Bert McKay.   Well though the Brown brothers ran, the club lost both titles.   McKay was back for the YMCA relay but there was still no sign of McCafferty and Alex had the fastest time of the day.   McCafferty ran for the first time in winter 1966-67 at the Midland Relays at King’s Park in Stirling.   Alex on the first stage handed over a 120 yard lead and McKay, Andy Brown and McCafferty never looked like losing that.   They won by two and a quarter minutes from Victoria Park with Dumbarton AAC third.   Alex was fourth fastest behind McCafferty, Stewart and Brennan.   In the Glasgow University road race at the start of November, Brown was fifth less than a minute behind winner Lachie Stewart who had set a new record for the course.   In the Edinburgh to Glasgow on 17th November, Motherwell was third with Alex running the fastest time on the fourth stage in bringing the club up from fourth to second.   The team to represent the SCCU against the British Army the following Saturday was chosen after the race and both Brown brothers and Ian McCafferty were all in there.   In that match, Alex was sixth and was picked again after that match to represent the Union two weeks later against  Scottish Universities.   Before then however came the Lanarkshire county championships and Motherwell won comfortably with McCafferty and Alex Brown taking first and second spots.   In the Universities match on 10th December, McCaffety was second to John Linaker, losing by only 3 seconds.   McCaffety was running really well at this point and won the Nigel Barge race at the start of January with Alex down in eighth place.

The Midland District championship was held in Bellahouston Park on 20th January, 1967 and high quality race it was.   Look at the first twelve finishers:

  1. I McCafferty 30:00;  2.   L Stewart  31:08;   3.   Alex Brown   31:21;   4.   Andy Brown   31:31;   5.   J Brennan  31:42;   6.   J Myatt  32:03;   7.   E Knox  32:11;   8.   H Barrow   32:13;  9.   R Wedlock  32:20;   10.   I Donald   32:26;   11.   R McKay   32:28;   12.   P Maclagan  32:30.

Apart from McCafferty’s outstanding run on the day, every place was fought for although Motherwell easily won the team race from Victoria Park.   Into the national championships at Hamilton Park and 1967 was the year that the New Zealand team turned out in real force – it was a good run out in preparation for the international to be held at Barry, Glamorgan.   The result was six NZ runners in the first seven places with others not far behind.   Alex was sixth Scot to finish and was selected for the international.   The Scottish team was a creditable fifth in the international, led home by Lachie Stewart, with Alex as last scoring runner in 67th place.

1967 APB

1967 national:   Alex fourth from the left, behind Lachie Stewart.

1967 was the summer when Law and District AAC appeared on the scene.   As might be expected they all performed well in their debut summer season with McCafferty topping several ranking lists and Alex and Andy both being well up in several more.   Alex’s top Two Mile was at Helenvale in Glasgow on 27th June when his time of 8:54.8 in second place placed him eighth in the national rankings at the end of the season and his best Three Miles was on 27th May at Westerlands where he was second in the Wesr District which rated him twelfth.   He also hada good Six Miles to his credit when he ran 28:55.0 finishing third on 23rd June to be fifth at the end of the season.

In the McAndrew  on 7th October the team was ninth with Andy and Alex having third and fourth fastest times of the day.   In the  LAAA county realy, Law was fifth with Alex 2nd fastest, but there was no Law team entered in the Midland Championship.   When the Motherwell club splitr at the formation of Law and District, Bert McKay and a few others of the regular top men stayed where they were and this was to affect team performances.   In November at the University road race, Alex was fourth, and Andy fifth behind Stewart, Knox and Maclagan).   In their first year, the new club was not in the E-G;  On 25th  November, in the SCCU   v Army  Ales was  3rd  behind Bryan-Jones and Blamire.   The first race in December was the Lanarkshire county championships and Alex was third in a race won by McCafferty.   A week later in the race between the SCCU and the Scottish Universities he was seventh and of course a member of the winning team.   Not out in the Nigel Barge road race, Alex was eighth in the Springburn Cup race.   He picked up for the more important Midland District championships at Bellahouston where, with most of the top six or seven runners away at European races, he was third behind Maclagan and Brennan.   A taste of the track tested out his speed when he won the three miles at the Shettleston Harriers open winter meeting at Barrachnie in 14:27.   The gradually escalating races throughout February included the Inter-Counties Championships at Dundonald in Troon where he was second to John Lineker and then the National itself where he was fifth – two places in front of Andy.   Despite McCafferty and Alder missing the race but being added to the international team, both Brown brothers had done well enough to be selected.   In the race held in Tunis, Scotland, following a superb run by the older Brown was fourth with Alex well down the field in 67th.   The Tom Scott was either the last race of the winter or the first of the summer, but in any case Alex was third in 48:44 behind McCafferty (48:39) and Gareth Bryan-Jones (48:49)

In summer ’68 Alex again ran his best Two Miles at Helenvale – 9:08.0, and in the Three Miles he was third in the West Districts in 14:18.8 and second in the Inter-Counties in 14:08.4

Second to Shettleston Harriers in the McAndrew relay and in the Lanarkshire relay too, they won the YMCA relay on the third Saturday of the month.   The Midland relays were on the first Saturday in November and Law was fourth – Strathclyde University surprisingly finishing second to upset the order of things, however Alex Brown was second fastest of the day behind Lachie Stewart.   None of the Law men ran in the Glasgow University road race and the club did not have a team in the Edinburgh to Glasgow relay in 1968 so it was right on to December. where both Alex and Andy faced the British Army on behalf of the SCCU where they were part of the team which won the battle.   In the Midland District championship there was no Alex Brown, indeed there was no team at all from Law and District.   Nor was there any Alex Brown in the National Championships so he missed out on the International as well.

That summer, 1969, Alex recorded 8:26 for 3000m when he won at Airdrie Highland Games at Rawyards Park and 14:43.6 when he finished second in the West District Championships 5000m.

1968-linaker-jls-brown-brown-brennan-macgregor

1968 National: Linaker (399), Stewart (413), Alex Brown, Jim Wright (105), Andy Brown (217), Jim Brennan (223) and Donald Macgregor

In the McAndrew in October 1969 the ‘Glasgow Herald’ said all that had to be said.   “Shettleston Harriers, unable to field their strongest team, had to give best to Law and District in the McAndrew relay at Jordanhill on Saturday.   The Law runners finally won easily but were well outside the record these same four runners set four years ago when running in Motherwell YMCA’s colours.   In the past Law have usually put their weakest runner off first leaving Alex and Andrew Brown and Ian McCafferty to pull in the deficit on the remaining three legs.   On Saturday they reversed the order.   After these three had built up a lead of 65 seconds for David Simpson, their anchor man, there was really very little Bill Scally, Shettleston’s last runner could do about it.”   It should be noted of course that David Simpson had run for Scotland in the International cross-country championship in 1962 so it was really a solid man closing in at the finish for Law.    The following week end Law was second in the county relay with Alex returning the third fastest time.    In the West District championships, Law was second to Shettleston – it was clearly Shettleston’s year with former Motherwell runner Dick Wedlock and Lachie Stewart making a massive contribution to that success.   On 8th November, Alex finished third in the Glasgow University Road Race behind Pat Maclagan and Eddie Knox.    1969 was the year that Law made the Edinburgh to Glasgow relay race but they found it hard going and could only finish ninth with Alex on the long, hard, seven miles of the sixth stage.   He picked up one place, from eighth to seventh, but was not among the fastest times on that stretch.   Alex was picked to run for the SCCU against the British Army and Northern Counties the following week where the Scottish team won comfortably enough.   He ran in neither the Nigel Barge nor the Springburn Cup road races at the start of 1970.   But on 24th January at Lenzie, in the Midland District Championships, Alex was sixth in the event which Ian McCafferty won.   However, came the National and the Brown brothers were well down the field, Andy in 25th and Alex in 30th.

Alex had no international cross-country in 1970 and no ranking times at any distance during the track season.   No Law team took part in the McAndrew or Lanarkshire relays but there was one team entered in the District championships: it finished 17th with no Alex Brown in the team and Andy could only finish 12th on the first stage.   There was a team in the Edinburgh to Glasgow relay in mid-November but it finished 17th with Andy eighth on the first stage, Alex dropping to fourteenth on the seconds, then a drop to sixteenth for the next three stages before David Simpson picked up one place on the long leg with the team slipping back to 17th on the seventh stage and finishing there at the end of the day.   Alex had nineteenth time out of the twenty with twentieth time run by A Brown of East Kilbride.   The Law team finished twelfth in the West District at Stirling but although Andy Brown was the first scoring runner in twenty sixth, Alex was not in the team.   In the National at  Bellahouston Park, Alex was third counter for Law in 105th position.   His running was a shadow of what it had been.

Alex was never a runner that was courted by the Press.   I do not remember ever seeing any interview  with him as there were with Ian McCafferty, brother Andrew, Jim Brennan, Lachie Stewart or any other of his contemporaries.   He was never loud or ostentatious at meetings.   In 1970 when he had virtually retired he was only just over 26 years old.   I have a friend who reckons that 26 is the key age for keeping young seniors in the sport – at that point their careers are starting to take off.   They are probably married with children or about to be so.   It is a time when priorities are being set.   Without any knowledge of Alex’s situation, I would guess that he had decided to concentrate on his career rather than on his athletics.  Whatever the reason, there was a clear lowering of the standard of his performances.

He did not stop running but his results slipped considerably.  In the Edinburgh to Glasgow of November 1971 he ran on the second stage and dropped from fifth to eleventh with fourteenth time of the day: not really bad on this most difficult of stages but not what we’d have expected a few years earlier.    In the National of 1972 he was down in 76th place and third scorer for the Law & District team.   He had a good 3000m the following year but slower than he had run for some time.   In winter 1972-73 he ran the fourth stage for the Law team in the Midland District relay and dropped to third place.   On the sixth stage of the Edinburgh to Glasgow, Alex Brown moved his team up one place from thirteenth to twelfth, overtaking Robert Anderson of Cambuslang with ninth time of the day.   In the Midland championships in January 1973, Law & District finished seventh team but did so without the services of Alex Brown.  He had a good run in the National though when he was 35th – one place behind Eddie Knox.

The Law team for the Midland District relay in 1973-74 was Fairweather, Miller, Thonson, McIver.   There was no place in  the team in the Edinburgh to Glasgow for either of the Browns or McCafferty.   There was no sign of either Andy or Alex in any of the major championship races that year – the Law team was even unlucky enough not to be in the first three in the Lanarkshire relays where for many years they were a ‘banker’ and could afford to switch teams around to get first two places.   Alex’s career was effectively over.

Alex was always a bit overshadowed by big brother Andy who had the advantage of being first to display his talent on the athletics stage.   But Alex was a notable talent in his own right.   Five international cross country vests between 1963 and 1968 (1963, 64, 65, 67, 68).   Twice as a Junior and three times as a senior.   National youth cross-country champion, district champion, medals at SAAA and District level on the track and a Scottish international vest on the track.   Add in the other, slightly lesser triumphs such as fastest time on his stage of the Edinburgh to Glasgow relay and the number of excellent scalps he had taken in head to head races and you have a more than competent athlete the likes of which Scotland desperately needs in the twenty first century.   Remember, this was all done before he was 26 years old – and many authorities reckon that a distance runner doesn’t reack his peak until he is 27!

 

Jim Brown

EE JB 1

If you say “Jim Brown” to any distance running aficionado in Scotland they will immediately say “Cross Country” in response.    There was a lot more to Jim than that – track running and road racing were equally good and when he turned to the marathon then there were good times there as well.    Were we dealing with cross country or all round endurance talent he would have to be well up in the list.   However we are focusing narrowly on the marathon here.   We can inspect his cross country performances, look at his track running and then review his marathon running before reproducing his reply to the Scottish Marathon Club magazine questionnaire.   That being said, his cross country running was masterly and in the early 70’s in particular he was quite outstanding.    He ran seven times for Scotland in the Senior International team and three times for the Junior squad where he was third, then second and then, in 1973, first.   He won the District titles (Junior and Senior simultaneously) in three consecutive years and then won the senior title.   Let’s just lay them out clearly.

  1. Midland District Junior Championship:   Winner in 1971, 1972 and 1973
  2. Midland District Senior Championship:  Winner in 1971, 1972 and 1973
  3. Scottish Junior Championship: Winner in 1972 and 1973
  4. Scottish Senior Championship:   1974.
  5. Junior International Championship:   Third in 1971, second in 1972 and first in 1973.
  6. Senior International Championship:   Seven appearances (position in brackets)

1974 (4th), 1975 (75th), 1976 (24th), 1977 (36th), 1978 (114th), 1980 (31st), 1981 (DNF).

Jim winning the World Junior Cross-Country in 1973

On the roads over the winter season he ran superbly well and maybe his best were reserved for the Edinburgh to Glasgow in 1979 and 1980 when the Clyde Valley team won and Jim had the fastest times on the sixth stage in 1979 (starting in first place and running a faster time than Allister Hutton, Jim Dingwall and Lawrie Spence among others) and the fifth stage (1980).    There were many other fine performances – eg in 1973 he pulled up six places on the second stage including Nat Muir and Alastair Wood.

How about on the track?    Again he was a top talent and is still ranked in the top twenty of all time in the Two Miles (8:33.2 in 1975), 5000 Metres (13:39.0 in 1975) and 10000 metres (fifth with 28:00.62 in 1975).    There were Scottish representative honours on the road and track as well as over the country.

So when he turned to the twenty six miles plus of the marathon there was genuine interest on what would be produced.   In 1979 he raced to 2:22:22 on a fierce course in Aberdeen to be second to Graham Laing (Aberdeen) who was less than a minute ahead with 2:21:40.   His fastest in 1980 was 2:19:03 at Milton Keynes to be ranked fifth in Scotland for that year.   Not ranked in 1981 his best in 1982 was 2:20:38 to be eleventh Scot and he was not ranked on 1983.

Scottish Marathon Club Magazine: June 1986

Profile

Name:   Jim Brown

Club:   Motherwell YMCA Harriers

Date of Birth: 13/9/52

Occupation:   Assistant Facilities Officer – Monklands District Council

Personal Bests:   1500: 3:49           3000: 7:58          5000: 13:39        10000: 28:00.6        10 Miles: 46:22            Marathon: 2:19:03

How Did You Get Involved In The Sport?   It was by accident really, whilst in the Boys Brigade I was more or less volunteered along with four or five others to take part in the Motherwell Battalion cross-country championships at Cleland Estate.   At that time most of my spare time was spent playing football or travelling to watch Motherwell.   I was a pretty ardent ‘steel men’ enthusiast in those days.   I was 15 when I ran at Cleland I remember the race very clearly, we were asked to follow a certain runner who would win anyway. as the course was not marked in any way.   As the race progressed both of us broke clear and eventually I won on the run-in.   I always remember the BB Captain saying he thought I was going to sprint out of Cleland Estate such was my enthusiasm over the last 100 metres.   It was then I met John Waddell who persuaded me to start running with Bellshil YMCA.    This had been my first introduction to cross country running and my attendance was very sporadic but in these early days it was the continuing promptings of John Waddell which introduced me to the sport.   We have been friends ever since and he can still quote my DoB (for entry on the day purposes!)

What Do You Get Out Of The Sport?   From my days as a Junior (17-20) I had built up a tremendous will to win.   I loved the involvement and competition at National and International level, also the travelling and the pre-race atmosphere created  eg San Sebastian.   I always felt I thrived on those conditions.   I’ve also struck up many friendships at home and abroad and met some really interesting characters – competitors and officials alike.

Can You Describe Your General Attitude To The Sport?   Until my years as a Junior I had a really easy going attitude to races.   For those who can recall I was usually the bridesmaid to Ron McDonald.   My attitude was really shattered by Alec Johnstone, an official with the SCCU during my first ever trip to San Sebastian – I finished second to Fava of Italy.   I was reasonably pleased with my afternoon’s work as I thought was Alec.   Whilst chatting to him applause broke out at the finish area, this was for Fava to receive his winning trophy in the stand.   Alec Johnstone casually turned to me and said, “That’s the difference between being first and being second – he’s up there and you’re down here.”   He never added anything else but I’m positive I became a better and more aggressive runner from that moment.

Has Any Individual Or Group had A Marked Effect On Either Your Attitude To The Sport Or On Your Performance?   I think in my early days my first coach Bob Henshaw helped shape my attitude.   He was a professional sprint coach and during my first two years under him he taught me tremendous restraint and patience in training.   I was beginning to handle training workloads and was always looking for longer workouts but he was an advocate of set work loads and never tried to run me into the ground.   In my later days at Borough Road College I was very impressed with Phil Banning who I found was a very organised, systematic and forthright character.   I think we were the same in some respects but we tended to dodge each other in training because when we got together the rest of the team were posted missing as he, like me, wanted to be number one, even in training runs.

What Do You Consider Your Best Performance?   Regards time and ranking 28:00.6 10km run at Crystal Palace when finishing second to Dave Black is looked on as one of my best runs.   I think it ranked me seventh in the world that year, although personally I took as much pleasure at dipping under 3:50 for 1500m for the first time.

And Your Worst?   I think it must have been the 1976 Olympic Trial at Crystal Palace.   Previously I had been ranked third in Britain due to my 10k the previous year.   It was my final year at College, I was due to sit my Physical Education finals and although my training, especially speed work, had been going well, my competitive work outs that year had been terrible.   I went for broke, went through halfway in just over 14 minutes.   I recall the elation of thinking that I was nearly in the team but it was short lived as I tied up and finished the last half running backwards.   I don’t think I have ever been so depressed or disappointed after a race.

What Do You Do Apart From Running To Relax?   I enjoy club nights at Motherwell.   We’re building up a strong squad and there’s nothing better after the Tuesday ‘Steady 10’  than a few beers.   Besides training, my two little girls Sharlene and Deborah tend to take up most of my time, although my wife and I are very partial to Indian food and we tend to do the rounds of the Indian night spots!   I’m first to admit that it doesn’t do a lot for your early morning run!

What Goals Do You Have That Are Still Unachieved?   I’ve had a lot of calf trouble in the last year and my training has been curtailed.  I’d just like to be injury free and enjoy the road racing scene.   I’ve no immediate goals – I’d like to speed up a bit as I enjoy the shorter road races and forget about marathons for a while.

What Has Running Brought You That You Would Not Have Wanted To Miss?   The travelling and meeting people as already mentioned, also the rewards, when winning major events, for the months or years of conditioning.   The involvement at club level and some of the characters one meets, we had our share at Clyde Valley, mentioning no names – I don’t want to start any rumours.

Can You Give Details Of Your Training?   Injury free, I run between 70 and 90 miles a week in winter including one rep session of one and a half or two minute reps, these sessions are usually part of a 7 – 8 mile run with the time of the repetition being the recovery.   The rest of my runs are made up of lunchtime 5 – 6 and easy evening 6 or 7 with a 10 mile club run on Tuesdays and a long run on Sunday, between 15 and 20 miles.   I run most of my sessions at around 6 minute a mile pace.   I’ve tried the pre-breakfast run at various times but I find I’m more sleep walking than perpetual motion, so my first venture out is always around lunchtime.   Although I work at a leisure centre I only have around 45 minutes to fit in a run and I’m usually on call between the three sports centres in the District.   I also work shifts so if I’m on a late shift I generally try to run about a further 7 – 9 miles in the morning.   I like to compete once every three weeks which fits in with my shifts.   In the summer I usually run around 80 miles a week – most runs are made up of 5’s or 6’s.   I run two rep sessions sometimes three a week.   6/8 x 2 minutes, 8 x 1 minute and one track session of 200 or 300 with a short recovery.   My rep sessions are run on grass or cinder paths.

What Changes Would You Like To See In The Sport?   I’d like to see more athletes taking up posts in administration at SAAA and SCCU level.   We’ve had occasions in the past when  officials have been accompanying teams abroad who have no idea how to encourage or motivate an athlete and have the awful habit of saying the wrong thing at the wrong time.  Perhaps it is now time for full time paid officials – with a background in the sport, not someone stipulating that you should be wearing white shorts and a certain style of track suit prior to an event.

On the competitive side I think there are too many half marathons and marathons, we’ve already had a few fatalities.   I feel that 5k and 10k road races should be encouraged  more as too many people are jumping on the marathon kick.   Gradual progression is the key.

Jim’s first run in the Junior Cross-Country International was in 1971 and we will start the rest of this profile in that year when he started racing against Seniors.    The summer of 1971 was one in which Jim and his friend Ron McDonald totally dominated the endurance events in Scottish athletics in the junior age group.   In the 1500m, Ron was top with 3:46.0 (run on the cinders at Rawyards Park, Airdrie) with Jim third with 3:51.5 (at Birmingham)   and they were separated by Frank Clement on 3:48.0.   McDonald topped the 3000m with 8:07.2 at Helenvale, with Brown second with 8:08.4 at Crystal Palace, Brown led the 5000m rankings with McDonald second (14:03.4 at Meadowbank, and 14:24.6 at Scotstoun).   Brown was also second in the 2000m steeplechase (5:50.0 behind Kilpatrick’s 5:41.8) and 3000m steeplechase (9:23.6 behind Kilpatrick’s 9:20.0).    The domination was competitive as well as time based: McDonald won both the SAAA Junior 1500m and SAAA Junior 5000m, while Brown won the Junior 2000m steeplechase and was second in the West District 1500m behind Dave McMeekin.   At Senior level, McDonald won the West District 800m and Brown was third in the SAAA Senior 5000m.   The Scottish Athletics 1972 yearbook commented: “Ron McDonald and Jim Brown successfully challenged the best of Scotland’s seniors in open races and were clearly superior to the rest of the juniors who nevertheless contain some talented performers.   Brown finished second and McDonald third in the AAA Junior championship race, and then tied for first place with Junior multi-record holder Dave Black, when representing Great Britain in a Junior International v West Germany and Sweden.”   So nobody could say that the Seniors hadn’t been warned.

However, many good young Youths come up and make an impression in the Senior Ranks as Juniors – but none had made an impact like Jim did in winter 1971-72, or made it so quickly.    The winter season usually begins with the McAndrew Relays in October and Jim’s McAndrew debut was on 3rd October 1970.   Immediate impact.   The headline in the Glasgow Herald read “FASTEST RUNNER IN McANDREW RELAY DISQUALIFIED” – and it was Jim they were talking about.   No doubts about the quality of the run, he was faster round the course than Don Macgregor, Lachie Stewart, Norman Morrison, Alastair Johnston and all the other top men of the day.   “The  revelation of the day was the run by 18-year-old Jim Brown the former Bellshill YMCA member who has moved to Monkland Harriers.   That change of club however automatically brings a 14-month suspension from team competitions on an individual, and Brown’s time is nowhere near served.   And so, despite leading home a record field of 83 runners on the first leg and unbelievably finishing up the fastest man in the whole race, Brown was rightly discarded from the official results and his team disqualified.   Nevertheless this cannot detract from his great run.”      Jim had gone straight to the front and handed over 30 yards up on Norman Morrison, his final time was two seconds quicker than Don Macgregor who received the award.   Unable to run in the Lanarkshire Relays or the  Kingsway Relays in Dundee, he next raced on 24th October in the Scottish YMCA relay at Bellshill where he had fastest time of the day.   All well and good but the top opposition did not compete in the YMCA event.   They were not to appear again until the Glasgow University road race on 14th November.   This time they were head-to-head  –  Fergus Murray, Alistair McKean, Donald Macgregor, Hugh Barrow and company faced the starter along with Jim Brown.    “Jim Brown, the Monkland teenager who shook all of us six weeks ago by running the fastest time in the McAndrew Relay, came back on Saturday in the Willie Diverty Memorial Road Race with a reminder that his initial claim for attention was no seven-day wonder.   The eight-stone stripling with the broad Lanarkshire accent audaciously forced the pace against the world-travelled schoolmaster from Fettes College, Fergus Murray, ten years his senior, as the pair of them battled over the closing stages they presented a picture of two runners poles apart in  so many departments.   For anyone looking for a fairy-tale ending there was a disappointment.   Murray controlled matters over the last three-quarters of a mile of the five mile course and entered the gates of Westerlands having at last subdued this youngster at his heels.   The Edinburgh man completed one lap of the track finishing in 24 minutes 41 seconds which takes an enormous 35 seconds off Lachie Stewart’s record of three years ago.   Brown was a mere three seconds behind in recording his most satisfying performance since taking up the sport.   Afterwards he said he hadn’t expected to beat his more experienced opponent but was delighted at having come so near.   Murray too was impressed, “I think he has a big future.   He was certainly setting a fast pace – one I was quite content to follow.”    Jim Brown had certainly arrived.   The next test was for a SCCU select in a four-way competition at Durham on 5th December against Northumberland & Durham, Northern Universities and Morpeth Harriers.   One of the main aims of this fixture, and others that season, was to give some of the younger Scottish runners experience outside of their own home area.    How did Jim do this time?   Well he was fourth overall and first SCCU runner home behind Jim Alder, John Caine and Ernie Pomfret,  but  ahead of such as Maurice Benn, Tom Grubb and Willie Day.    A week later, running for the SCCU in their B team match against Scottish Universities at Knightswood Park in Glasgow, Jim was second to his Monkland team mate Ron McDonald, beaten by only four yards.  Third was Alastair Johnston of Victoria Park – 6 seconds down on Jim.   The classic road race start to the New Year was the Nigel Barge race promoted by Maryhill Harriers and in 1971 it was on 5th January.   Almost all the top men were there – along with Jim and his team mate Ronnie McDonald.   This time the winner was Ronnie – the finishing sprint of the top-class miler was enough to give him victory ahead of Dick Wedlock, Gareth Bryan-Jones and Alistair Blamire with Jim Brown sixth.   He lifted a few good scalps here too though.

With the Nigel Barge past, attention was on the Championships and the representative outings.   The first of these was the Midland championship on 23rd January at Stirling University.   The headline and report read as follows:

“BROWN COOL AND CONVINCING MIDLAND TITLE WINNER.   Jim Brown, the 18-tear-old Bellshill Academy schoolboy, ran his way back into the headlines on Saturday with an easy-looking win in the Midland District cross-country championship.   The course, at Stirling University’s playing fields, was as severe as any on the Scottish circuit but the lightweight Brown skimmed over the mud and stones as if he were on a summer track.   He covered the six miles in 30 minutes   04 seconds and finished looking almost as cool as he had at the start.   Coming in over 60 yards behind was Norman Morrison (Shettleston) a 1500m runner in the Commonwealth Games , and about the same distance behind him came Alistair Johnston (Victoria Park).   Those three had dominated the race virtually from the start.   Brown looking almost too young and spare of flesh to be a senior winner flicked the caked mud off his body as he expressed surprise at the way the race had unfolded “I thought the pace was kind of slow.   With only three of us clear of the field after the first lap, I just decided to go to the front and see how things went.   Norman seemed to drop back and I knew the race was mine.”    It should be noted though that none of Lachie Stewart, Ian McCafferty or Dick Wedlock was running.    The following Sunday, Brown was in San Sebastian where he finished second in the international Junior race over 6200m less than eight seconds behind the winner, Fava of Italy.   In Madrid on 13th February, Brown was third in the Junior international won by his Monkland team mate Ron McDonald.   Frank Clement was sixteenth and the team finished second.   McDonald and Brown were lso first and second in the National Junior CC Championships at Bellahouston and were picked for the team to contest the international at Spain in March.   Before then there was the Scottish Schools cross-country championships in which Brown, running for Bellshill Academy beat McDonald (St Patrick’s, Coatbridge) by half a minute.   In the International, Jim was third with the team second – Ian Gilmour was thirteenth and Ron McDonald fourteenth on a muddy course with a heavy wind blowing.   It had been an excellent first season against the seniors with the bronze medal in the international the icing.

Jim had finished summer 1970 ranked in three different events – his best time for the 1500m was 3:57.2 which ranked him 23rd in Scotland, the 3000m 8:39.8 which ranked him 24th and the steeplechase where his 9:24.2 ranked him seventh in Scotland.   Coming off the back of the winter he had just had, it was expected that he would be much quicker in  the summer of 1971.   The Glasgow Corporation Sports were held at Scotstoun on 22nd May and Jim Brown won the steeplechase in 9:23.2 – exactly one second faster than his best of 1970.   Unplaced, if indeed he ran, in the West Districts the following Saturday, he was next in action at the Airdrie HG at Rawyards Park at the start of June where he won the open 5000m in 14:20.8 – a full 25 seconds ahead of second placed Dick Wedlock and a further 10 in front of Paul Bannon in third.   Club mate Ron McDonald was turning in more than a race a week at this point over 800/1500/mile distances and winning them all.   On 19th June it was the Scottish Schools championships and McDonald and Brown both won their respective events – McDonald the 5000m in 14:24.6 and Brown the 2000m steeplechase in 5:55.4, a best championship performance – which set them up nicely for the SAAA Championships the next Satrday.   Brown was third in a very good 5000m behind Ian McCafferty and Adrian Weatherhead in 14:03.4, and McDonald lost the 1500m by 0.2 seconds to Craig Douglas.   It should be remembered that Brown was a fast miler as well as an endurance specialist: on 3rd July, for instance, he ran against Ron McDonald and Frank Clement in a Graded championship meeting at Grangemouth Stadium.    “The event which created the greatest interest was the 1500 metres in which three top-class juniors met – Ronnie McDonald and Jim Brown (both Monkland Harriers) and Frank Clement (Strathclyde University)   Brown led at the end of the first lap and, although McDonald took over  temporarily, Brown stepped up the pace in the second lap, closely pursued by Clement.   The unflappable McDonald was content to stay in the first three.   In the back straight over 300 yards, Brown believing that the only way to beat McDonald was to take him that distance in a buirst of speed, put in all he knew in an effort to shake off his clubmate.   Undaunted, McDonald held on and he and Clement fought out the finish in which McDonald recorded the best championship time of 3:59.2,    Clement was second in 3:49.8 and Brown third in 3:51.5.”

On 17th July Jim suffered a rare defeat in schools athletics when he finished second in the 2000m steeplechase in the schools international at Meadowbank where he was beaten by Ian Kirkpatrick of England.   The trouble seemed to be that the Englishman was a much better hurdler than he was and the reporter felt, probably rightly, that Jim should have been selected for the 5000m.   His time was 5:50, 7.2 seconds down on the winner.   It was though a good summer with Brown racing against his elders as often as he could.   One such race was the 3000m team race at Cowal at the end of the season where he took on Lachie Stewart – “In the 3000 metres team race, Stewart found once again that his chief opponent for individual honours was the younger Jim Brown (Monkland) who tried hard to hold his more experienced opponent over the seven and a half laps of the course.    Brown failed to live with Stewart in finishing tactics, however,  and lost by eight yards.”   By the end of the summer he was ranked in 56 events with every time better than  the year before.   In the 1500m he had run 3:51.5 to be 13th in Scotland, in the 3000m his 8:08.4 ranked him 7th, at 5000m his best of 14:03.4 had him in sixth place and his steeplechase time of 5:50.0 for 2000m and 9:23.6 for 3000m ranked him second and sixth respectively.

Winter started for distance runners on the first Saturday in October at Scotstoun in Glasgow at the McAndrew Relays where Jim Brown had raised more than a few eyebrows the previous year.   This time he was again the fastest over the course.   “Brown, now a legitimate member of Monkland Harriers, was even more spectacular this time.   He took up the challenge on the second leg and fought his way from twelfth to second position behind Shettleston.   En route he always looked menacing and although Lachie Stewart was a mere figure in the distance, Brown must have pulled him back 120 yards by the time he finished.  Anyone doing that to a commonwealth champion is someone to be reckoned with.”

In the Lanarkshire Relay the following week, Jim had by far the fastest time of the day when Monkland finished second to Springburn with Shettleston third.   At the very end of October in the Allan Scally Relay at Shettleston, Jim Brown took over in 27th place and picked off all but four of them, inevitably turning in the day’s fastest time equalling the course record of 22:09 when he ran the second stage – Ronnie McDonald pulled the cub int third on the last stage.   A week later in the Midland Relay at Bellshill, he had the day’s fastest time, 10 seconds faster than Dick Wedlock and 13 seconds better than Lachie Stewart.   Missing the University 5 at Westerlands where Fergus Murray defeated him the previous year, Brown ran in the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay on 20th November.   Running on the fourth stage, he moved Monkland up from twelfth to sixth with the fastest time of the day, a full minute quicker than the next best.    From a great run on the roads to a very good one over the country at Parliament Hill Fields in London, Brown finished fifth and second Scot (Lachie Stewart was fourth) in a race won by David Bedford who was only 14 seconds ahead of the 19-year-old Scot.   As a wee aside, the ‘Glasgow Herald’ pointed out that ‘plucky’   young Jim Brown’s big worry in the race was counting the laps and, near the end, he had to ask Lachie Stewart if they were really on the last lap.   The next major race for him was the Midland Championship at Bellshill where he had a head to head with Ian McCafferty while Lachie Stewart, Dick Wedlock and Ron McDonald were competing at Elgoibar.  The ‘Glasgow Herald’ of 24th January, 1972 read “McCAFFERTY AND BROWN TAKE A STEP NEARER MUNICH.   Jim Brown and Ian McCafferty took a step nearer Munich at the weekend when they plumbed depths of stamina at the weekend that left a huge field in the Midland cross-country championship helpless to respond.   Brown, the 19-year-old Monkland Harrier, retained the title at Bellshill and thus kept his unbeaten record in domestic competitions this winter, but what a challenge McCafferty offered in only his second outing of the season – his previous having also ended in defeat by Brown.   Sporting a Mexican-type moustache and long hair, McCafferty gave the holder the treatment he had been hoping to avoid – a hard punishing contest.   After the race, which Brown won by six seconds, he said “I had been hoping for an easy one here today because of the San Sebastian race next Sunday, but there’s no doubt about it – McCafferty’s fit all right, I thought he ran very well.”    It couldn’t have affected Brown too much because he won the Junior 6000m race in Spain by 17 seconds from England’s Bernie Ford.

The Scottish Junior Cross-Country Championship was on 19th February at Currie   and Jim Brown won from Paul Bannon by 29 seconds and gained selection for the international championships at Cambridge in March.   The date was 18th March and Brown had been third the previous year.   “Jim Brown won the silver medal in the junior race behind Aldo Tomasini (Italy( but until the lats 100 metres he was heading for nothing better than the bronze.   Suddenly Franco Fava, the other leading Italian, who was well clear of the Scot staged a Jim Peters type stagger and, as if in slow motion, the exhausted Fava slumped to the grass.   Brown, revitalised, sprinted 30 or 40 yards, passed the luckless Italian, who to his credit, managed to stagger to his feet and struggle his way over the line for third place.”    Two world junior championships, a third and a second – good going!

That summer (1972) Jim was ranked in four events and won two championship medals.    Third in the 5000m and second in the 10000m his best times for the year were 3:53.2 for the 1500, 8:17.4 for the 3000m, 13:59.8 for the 5000m and 28:57.8 for the 10000m.   In the 10000m championship, he was first in 29:25.13, thirteen seconds in front of Fergus Murray.       This championship was held in the GB v Poland international match at Meadowbank one week before the Scottish Championships and the photo-finish showed his time as 29:25.13.  The SAAA 5000 came the next week and he repeated his bronze medal of 1971 being behind David Black (Small Heath) 13:51.4, and Lachie Stewart (Shettleston) 13:58.8 with his own time being 13:59.8.   This title earned him selection for the GB international against Greece and the Netherlands in Athens the next week again.   He was a replacement for the injured Ricky Wilde and was described by Athletics Weekly as ‘a wobbly and plucky second’ behind Grenville Tuck in 29:47.0.   Clearly in brilliant form, just two weeks later he was seventh in the AAA 10000m at Crystal Palace in 28:58.   On 16th September Jim won an Edinburgh Southern Floodlit Meeting at Meadowbank in 14:00.0

n 7th October 1973, the ‘Glasgow Herald’ ran with the headline and article:.

 “BROWN SMASHES RECORD BUT SHETTLESTON WIN. 

It was hardly surprising that a good many of the runners in Saturday’s McAndrew Relay in Jordanhill, Glasgow, found it hard to swallow the extraordinary time set up by Jim Brown (Monkland Harriers) on the second leg.   Brown makes a habit of drawing attention to himself in this opener to the official cross-country season, a four-man road relay covering a circuit something short of three miles.   Two years ago he was the fastest individual, but was disqualified for competing while serving a 14-month suspension imposed automatically when a runner changes from one club to another. Last year everything was legitimate and he was again individual prize winner.   On Saturday Brown, wearing the now fashionable hairband, resembled some obsessed dervish as he thrashed his way round the course, dragging his club from the thirteenth place they occupied when he took over to an unbelievable second, behind Shettleston Harriers, the eventual winners. Monkland, however, dropped to seventh after the remaining two legs.   The really astonishing feature was Brown’s time – 13 min 2 sec – which smashed Lachie Stewart’s seven-year-old record by 18 seconds, roughly equivalent to a distance of about 120 yards.   After recovering from this early-season effort Brown said he had had to stop training after the AAA championships in July because of a strain in his right calf. It persisted for weeks, but now he is back into a strenuous schedule which for the moment seems to be paying dividends. His major ambition is to impress sufficiently next season over 10,000 metres to put himself in line for the Christchurch Commonwealth Games, just 16 months away.”   The first three teams were:  1 Shettleston H 55.22′ 2 Victoria Park 55.47; 3 ESH 56.17.   Fastest individuals were Fastest: JB 13.02; N Morrison (Shett) 13.20; P Bannon (GU) 13.30; JL Stewart (Shett) 13.32; Colin Youngson (VP) 13.36; D Macgregor (ESH) 13.37.”      The time was outstanding and when you look at the supporting cast of Morrison, Bannon, Stewart and Macgregor, you realise just how good.   The next big race was the Allan Scally Memorial Trophy Relay at Shettleston on October 28th and Jim Brown was fastest again (21.52) with Andy McKean (EAC) 21.58 and Norman Morrison 22.06. in second and third.

Jim was fastest man yet again in the Midland District Relay on 4th November at Lochinch in Glasgow: described this time as “the amazing workhorse of Monkland Harriers” who “thrives on adversity”, he moved from tenth to sixth on the last lap to be 18 seconds faster than Pat Maclagan who was next best runner.   A week later and the runner described this time as “Scotland’s best and most consistent cross-country runner since the season began” suffered “an inexplicable lapse” and finished twenty fifth in an international race in London against the best of English and Kenyan runners.   In the Edinburgh to Glasgow on the 18th November Jim was second fastest on the fourth stage, only 2 seconds behind Alex Wight of Edinburgh AC in the Monkland team that finished tenth.   The next international was the match against Wales, and various English regions at Stafford.    Scotland won from Northern Counties and the first three individuals were all Scots – Lachie Stewart first in 28:25, Jim Brown second in 28:27 and Ian Gilmour third in 28:55.   Missing several races his next outing was in the Midland Championship at Bellshill on 20th January – and it was a third successive win for the Monkland Harriers –   31:36 as against 31:53 by second placed Alan Partidge (Susan’s Dad), and Dave Mc Meekin’s 32:18.   A week later and Jim was in San Sebastian running in the Junior race – his third season as a Junior – where he won the 6.5 km race in 2:17.4 and Norman Morrison was second to Dave Bedford in the Senior race.   The National on 17th February was won by Jim eleven seconds ahead of Lawrie Spence with Ron McDonald third and this gave the selectors a problem.   As Ron Marshall said in the ‘Glasgow Herald’:    “The vexing question over Jim Brown still remains.   He is eligible to run as a Junior in Belgium, but would obviously be a marvellous asset to the Senior team, everyone is well aware of this.   No matter how well our Seniors perform, there will be this nagging feeling that young Brown, had the ability to finish well up the field making a vital contribution to the points total. “    He was selected for the Junior team: how could he not be?   He  had been third in 1971, second in 1972 and still a Junior.

The International championships had previously been held by the ICCU but from 1973 they were to be held by the IAAF, and the first of these was at Waregem in Belgium.   The IAAF had changed the qualifying conditions for Juniors such that “competitors had to be Under 21 years of age on the day of the race.”   Brown was 20 years and 5 months on the day of the race and really went for the title right from the start, he ran away from Leon Schots (Belgium) on the second of three laps, and eventually won by 30 yards from Cianaros Haro (Spain) who was second.   (Haro’s older brother Mariano was second in the Senior race.)   Jim Brown had done it – third, second and now first in the Junior Championship.   The fancied Scottish Seniors could do no better than eighth.

That summer (1973) saw Jim’s racing sabotaged by injury and his only mark of any note was a 5000m run in 14:27 which was almost half a minute slower than his 1972 time, at the Edinburgh Highland Games on 18th August.   With the Commonwealth Games being held in Christchurch, New Zealand, in January, 1974, selections had to be made on form that summer so Jim unfortunately missed out on selection.   He was also a notable non-starter in the early season races such as the McAndrew Relay, the Midlands Relay and the Glasgow University road race, making his first appearance in the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay on 17th November where he moved up from fourth to first on the second stage with the third fastest time of the day.   Monkland finished eighth team and were awarded the medals for the most meritorious unplaced performance.   This was not an indicator that he would run in the County Championships the next weekend – the race was won by Ronnie McDonald but Brown was nowhere to be seen.   It may be of course that the uneven surface and course conditions were a deterrent to one who had missed so much time through injury.   His next appearance was on 5th January on the firmer and mostly safer surface of the roads around Maryhill where he was third in the Nigel Barge Road Race.   Won by his clubmate Ronnie Morrison from Lachie Stewart in a sprint finish, Brown was ahead of Norman Morrison, Jim Wight and Don Macgregor and was obviously in very good condition.   The Herald reporting at this point was not very satisfactory from the road and country running point of view, giving space and apparent precedence to comment, opinion and reporting on the upcoming Commonwealth Games in New Zealand at the expense of basic results eg the only time given for the classic Nigel Barge race was that of the winner, and no places were given below third and the following week the bulk of the space available was given to doping and the Games with the Springburn road race squashed into a bottom corner and not a single time, not even the winner’s, given.   Jim’s comeback was cemented with his selection to run in Elgoibar in Spain on 19th January when he was fifth individual and first Scot in the team which won the international team race, the others being Lawrie Reilly in sixth and Frank Clement ninth over the 9200m trail.

Came the National at Coatbridge on 16th February, 1974, and the reason for Brown’s absence became clear in Ron Marshall’s report on the race: Jim was now studying at London.   The report read:

“FORCEFUL BROWN RUNS McKEAN INTO GROUND

Jim Brown’s Physical Education studies at Borough Road College, London, are at least doing his running no harm.   On Saturday at Coatbridge he became Scottish senior cross-country champion in the most convincing fashion, and yesterday he was an automatic choice by the selectors for the international cross-country championship in Italy next month.   ….  Brown, winner of the Scottish and International Junior titles last year, faces the daunting prospect of stepping up into the big league in Milan but if his forceful attitude on Saturday is an indication of how he intends breaking into senior competition then the rest of the runners are in for a nasty experience.   He and Andy McKean, the defending champion, took little time in breaking away from the field of more than 400 starters and for two of the five laps of Drumpellier Park that made up the seven and a half miles course, they harried each other mercilessly.  Up slippery grass slopes, down greasy grass, they fairly tore at each other.   It was evident that some one had to give way at this relentless pace.   McKean it was who conceded the leading position, but Brown was not content just to slip ahead.   He dug afresh into the turf and mud stretching an astonishing gap between them.   After three laps it was 20 seconds, after four it was half a minute, but some equality was established on the last lap, where McKean lost no more ground.   Brown is in tremendous form, and is intent on building up over the next four weeks for a really serious crack at the senior title.   He runs mostly in Richmond Park these days, covering about 90 miles a week, and has three college commitments in the next three weeks – the Hyde Park Relays, a contest in Madrid and the English Championships.”

In the English National on 2nd March, Jim had a good spell early in the race, challenging the leaders, he even looked a possible winner for six of the nine miles, but slipped back in the latter stages to finish ninth.   But in the International on 14th March, he was back to his best.

“BROWN EXCELS ON A GOOD DAY FOR SCOTS

…  The most important talking point, naturally, was the fourth place attained in the individual race by Jim Brown.    His was a sterling.   Blessed with an endless determination, Brown approaches every competition with the attitude, “Who’s going to be second?”  And Saturday’s 12000m was no exception.    Reputations had little meaning for the slim Monkland Harrier as he forged ahead at what seemed like a reckless speed.    But the close attentions of Erik de Berk (Belgium), Mariano Haro (Spain) and Ray Smedley (England)  indicated that something more punishing than Brown’s pace would be needed at the “killing off” stage.   With half a lap to go the Scot showed signs of how sapping his efforts had been on him.   De Berk and Haro became the principal actors, but as the Scot slipped reluctantly upstage, he could take ample consolation from the strength of his supporting role.   The Belgian won in 35 minutes 24 seconds, a couple of strides in front of Haro.”   Karel Lismont of Belgium was third, only passing Brown in the last few strides.  Jim Brown was only 5 seconds behind the winner.    Four runners within five seconds!   It had been a good winter for him.

Having missed the Commonwealth Games in January, it was into summer 1974 in great shape for the track season.   At Crystal Palace on 2nd June, he won a 3000m in 8:01.2 which placed him second at the end of the year – to Ron McDonald (7:55.2).

10,000m was clearly Jim’s best track distance, and the Yearbook later commented: “Former World Junior cross country champion Jim Brown ran brilliantly at this distance, producing three times under 28 and a half minutes. His fastest performance was just over three seconds behind Ian Stewart’s list-topping 28.17.2, run when he was sixth in the Christchurch Commonwealth Games on 25th January.”

At Meadowbank on the 22nd of June he was second (13.51.2) in the SAAA 5000m, behind Dave Black of England, who won in 13.38.4.   On 12th July the AAA Championship 10,000m took place at Crystal Palace. Athletics In Scotland reported: “Jim Brown excelled himself by improving on his previous best 10,000m time by over half a minute to finish in a very good fourth behind Dave Bedford (27.48.6), Bernie Ford (28.15.8) and Tony Simmons (28.19.4). Jim’s time was 28.20.8, which places him in third place in the Scottish All-Time Rankings and won for him another UK vest, this time against Czechoslovakia at Meadowbank on 26th July.”   Jim remembers that race well and was leading the field with two laps to go, lapping many good quality runners and thinking he’d get well inside his previous best time – maybe even get a 28:30 – when on the back straight with less than two laps to go, he started to fade and eventually dropped to fourth – and recorded well inside the 28:30 that he had been hoping for.   Just one second behind Tony Simmons who was selected for the European championships on the strength of that run.   Result for Simmons?   Second in the Europeans!    Jim’s performance in that high quality, international race was later considered by Colin Shields to be the best performance of the Scottish season.    AIS again: “The most exciting race of the evening (actually closer than the 100 metres) was the 10,000 m, in which Jim Brown did exceptionally well. All four competitors, Jim Brown, Mike Baxter, Stanislav Hoffman and J. Jansky ran together throughout, with Baxter and Brown sharing the lead for most of the way. Hoffman took over at the bell, closely followed by Brown, Baxter, with the other Czech, Jansky, struggling. Jim Brown made a great effort on the back straight and overtook Hoffman to lead round the last bend. He appeared to have gone too early as, entering the home straight, both Hoffman and Baxter overtook him. All appeared lost for Jim with 50 metres to go until he displayed great fighting qualities by getting back on terms with the other two and crossed the line six inches behind Hoffman and just ahead of Baxter. Hoffman and Brown recorded the same time of 28.28.4, with Baxter two tenths of a second away third.” Athletics Weekly  agreed that the 10,000m was the most exciting finish of the evening, and added that the speedy Hoffman had been a   3.39.1   1500m performer back in 1966.    UK won the match overall, with 108 points to Czechoslovakia’s 102.

Then at Crystal Palace on September 25th and 26th, Finland’s Men’s team beat UK by a single point. On the second day of the match, Pekka Paivarinta (Finnish winner of the World Senior Cross Country Championship in 1973) defeated that year’s World Junior Champion, Jim Brown, in the 10,000m. Pekka recorded 28.18.4, and Jim his second-fastest time – 28.23.8, in front of Grenville Tuck (28.25.8) and Rune Holmen (28.48.2). AW reported: “Jim Brown and late replacement (for Dave Bedford) Grenville Tuck gave the 10,000 everything they had and the rewards went to all four runners in the shape of personal bests.” (A mistake by AW as far as Jim was concerned.) “Knowing the vast range of Pekka Paivarinta’s talent, they had no choice but to make the pace as hard as they could and hope he would drop. Brown led through 3k in 8.23.8 and 5k in 14.11.2, with all four runners together. Tuck took over the work and lapped in a steady 69 seconds, which dropped Holmen by 7k but Paivarinta always looked easy with his long relaxed stride. In the closing laps, Tuck and Brown could only manage to quicken the pace by a second or two and it was not enough. Paivarinta hit the front finally with 500 to go, but still the two Britons refused to give in and surprisingly the Finn had not burst away as expected. Brown and Tuck chased until 250m to go, when finally Paivarinta exploded and rocketed around the last 200m to open up a five second gap with a 57.6 last lap.”   It was no disgrace to lose to such a great runner; and Jim Brown must have been proud to look back on such an impressive track season, with a new personal best and three international 10,000 metre races in a British vest.

*

That winter (1974-75) saw the appearance of a new name on the entry lists for Scottish races – the new club of Clyde Valley AC had been formed from four clubs in North Lanarkshire including Monkland.   Jim would be competing henceforth as ‘Clyde Valley’. On 14th September, 1974, he won the Coatbridge 5 Miles Road Race by 19 seconds from Jim Dingwall, and then the following day he went to England and won the Berwick round the walls race.   Two wins in two days.   The new amalgamated club won the Midland Relays and in the ‘Glasgow Herald’ on 2nd November, Ron Marshall spoke of an interesting invitation to Jim.   He wrote: “Jim Brown (Clyde Valley) has been asked to compete in the Canadian Cross-Country Championships in Montreal on Saturday week as part of a British team (the first time any team has competed cross-country under British colours).   Brown’s Canadian trip will not  be universally welcomed.   His club, Clyde Valley, who won the Midland Relay on Saturday at Lochinch, had been nurturing the idea that a third place in the inter-city relay was within their grasp.   With Brown away, their hope had been shattered, but they now intend throwing all their efforts into winning the national relay title the following week.”   In the event, Brown did not go to Canada but ran on the sixth stage of the E-G and held on to third place with second fastest time of the day.   No reason was given in the press for Jim’s absence from the Canadian venture but he also turned out for the club in the District Relays.   Anglo Ian Gilmour could not make the trip to Scotland and Ray Baillie ran on the first stage where he finished eleventh.   Next up for Clyde Valley was Jim Brown who moved from eleventh to first in the course of 10 minutes.   He had fastest time of the day – 10:56 – and gave John Graham a lead of 24 seconds with Andy McKean the man in pursuit.  McKean not only caught his man but gave Jim Wight 7 seconds start on Ron McDonald.   McDonald was in great form all through 1974 and it was difficult to see anyone holding him off in such a position.  McDonald won by 9 seconds with third fastest time of the day, only McKean splitting the two ex-Monkland men.

Absent from the domestic scene for the next few months although running well in the South , he won the race to celebrate the 75th anniversary of Barcelona FC over 8000m in Spain with Scotland winning the team race from England, Belgium and Spain.   Other team members were Andy McKean 4th and Laurie Reilly 5th.   The ‘Glasgow Herald’, remarked that after his ‘rather moderate’ 14th place at San Sebastian, he may concentrate on the SCCU Championships at Coatbridge rather than the English National at Luton.   The prize for a good run was, of course, selection for the international in Morocco.   Jim chose however not to run in the Coatbridge race but was nevertheless selected for the team to go to Morocco on 15th March.   Jim ran but with Mariano Haro second to Scot Ian Stewart, the other Scots all ran poorly and Jim could only finish 75th.  Others were A Hutton 38th, L Reilly 43rd, A McKean 54th, R Ward 81st, I Gilmour 88th, F Clement 89th, J Alder 106.

EE JB 2

Scottish Teams for the International Cross-Country in 1975: Jim sixth from right, beside Lachie Stewart

Picture from Lachie Stewart

 Into summer 1975 – possibly Jim’s best summer season.   By the end of the season his best times ranked him in five events.   He was second in the SAAA 5000m and also second in the AAA’s 10000m.  The 10000m was a new Scottish National record – one which broke Lachie Stewart’s 28:11 from the Commonwealth Games in 1970 and which gave him great pleasure!   It also ranked him third in Britain.

Event Time Ranking
1500m 3:51.1 14th
2 Miles 7:58.0  
3000m 8:08.83  
5000m 13:39.0 2nd
10000m 28:00.62 1st
Steeplechase 9:08.64 12th

He had however started with a brilliant win in a local road race – the Tom Scott Road Race over 10 miles early April.   It is worth reproducing the article in its entirety here since the race was a good one between two real rivals and Jim gets the credit that he was due.   It read:

“JIM BROWN’S RECORD TIME

The capricious nature of sporting form was well illustrated on Saturday when Jim Brown (Clyde Valley) won the Tom Scott Road Race from Law to Motherwell not only by a wide margin but in a record time as well.   Only three weeks ago the same man was languishing in seventy fourth position in the International Cross-Country Championships, a race in which he had been fourth the previous year.   With that weighing on his mind, then Brown had approached the Tom Scott with more than a degree of apprehension.   He is sorely needed a morale booster.   For a long time it looked as if he would be denied satisfaction.   Andy McKean (Edinburgh AC) the national cross-country champion set a fearsome pace over the first four miles dragging what appeared to be a reluctant Jim Brown in his wake, at least 40 yards behind.   Jim Dingwall, going for his third successive win, was already showing signs of distress.  

Through Wishaw’s main street McKean sagged a bit, Brown sensed the lapse and swept past, not gradually but punishingly fast.   Within seconds he had 30 yards on the other and the race was over.    The next three miles to the finish only served to allow Brown to build up an ultimate winning lead of something like 175 yards and he crossed the line in 46 minutes 33 seconds.   This beat Lachie Stewart’s 1967 record by eight seconds.  

The winner had two main concerns after the race.   The first was to retrieve his front plate of teeth from the bus carrying athletes belongings.   He never runs with it fitted, but the demands of a radio interview made it essential.   His second worry was the appearance of some raw blood blisters on both feet.   A compete rest yesterday, he imagined, would be enough to let them subside.   Brown returns this week to his physical education studies at that breeding ground of sporting progress, Borough Road College in London.   His first big race, apart from student fixtures, is on June 11th when he runs over two miles against Brendan Foster and Ian Stewart.   You cannot choose sterner opponents than that.”

Summer 1975 came between Commonwealth, European and Olympic Games but it turned out to be a good year for Jim as can be seen from the table above.     Even if we only take the major races, there is a lot to cover.    In the SAAA Championships, he was second in the 5000m behind Dave Black from Small Heath AAC in Birmingham in 13:39 which was good enough for him to be one of only 10 athletes selected by the SAAA to have their expenses fully paid for the AAA’s Championships on 1st and 2nd of August.   Came the championship and the result in the 10000m was the same as it had been over 5000m at Meadowbank: Black won in 27:54.23 and Brown was second in 28:00.2 which was a new Scottish native record, taking Lachie Stewart’s record from the books and which was also to be Jim’s lifetime best for the distance.    ‘Athletics Weekly’ reported on the race as follows:   “Last year Bernie Ford strove mightily but unsuccessfully to drop Dave Bedford; this time he forced the pace to such effect that he recorded a magnificent persona best of 28:02.4 . . . and finished third.   Dave Black was the winner of his first national senior track title in 27:54.2, fastest by a European this year, while Jim Brown smashed the Scottish record of his hero, Lachie Stewart, with 28:00.6.   A great race all the way through with further personal bests for Bernie Plain and my colleague Jon Wigley among others.   Matthew Batswadi (who improved from 29:20.4 to 28:38.4) and Ford were the men responsible for the excellent times.   The South African led through kilometres of 2:48.2, 5:32.6, 8:23.4 and 11:12.0 and then Ford took over.   His time at halfway was 14:03.4, with Wigley, Batswadi, Black, Brown, Ewald Bonzet and Plain in close attendance.   By 6000m (16:48.6 by Ford) Batswadi and Wigley had dropped back and a lap later, with Brown now in front, the other South African, Bonzet, had begun to lose contact and he dropped out after 7km.   That left four men ahead: Brown, Ford, Black and Plain.   The 7000m mark was reached in 19:38.8 and Ford brought them up to 8000m in 22:29.6.   Plain slipped back on the 22nd lap and then with two and a half to go, Black made his move.   He drove in a crushing 62.9 lap, which carried him 30 metres ahead of Brown and 35 clear of Ford, and was further in front at the finish, having covered the last 1200m in a sparkling 3:07.8.   Note his second 5000m of close to 13:50!   Further down, both Mike Tagg and Trevor Wright enjoyed their best track runs in two years.”   Hard, hard running and it is only right for the leading times to be noted.

Name Club Time
D Black Small Heath 27:54.2
J Brown Clyde Valley 28:00.6
B Ford Aldershot, Farnham and District 28:02.4
B Plain Cardiff 28:15.0
M Tagg Norfolk Gazelles 28:28.6
Gren Tuck Cambridge and Coleridge 28:34.0
J Wigley Invicta 28:35.8
M Batswadi South Africa 28:38.4
R Holt Hercules Wimbledon 28:42.4
R Lunnon Gosforth 28:45.0
T Wright Wolverhampton & Bilston 28:46.2
J Goater Shaftesbury 28:50.8
L Reilly Sale 28:58.8
A Rushmer Tipton 29:13.6

And behind that lot were such well-known and highly respected distance men as Colin Moxsom (Woodford Green), Mike Critchley (Cardiff), Hugh Starkey (Shaftesbury) and many more.    There was another good run in the International Students Meeting in Rome on 30th August where he was third in the 10000m in 29:03.6 behind Fava (28:37.8) and Floroiu (Romania).

There were also two GB selections that year – against Russia over 5000m and Sweden over 10000m    The Russian match was on August 26th and Jim was one of three British representatives in the 5000m, the others being Dave Black and Dave Lowes.   Black was second (13:28.52), Brown fifth (13:43.44) and Lowes sixth (13:48.65).  The UK v Sweden match was three weeks later, on 13th/14th September at Meadowbank.   Britain won by 113 to 99 points and Jim’s contribution was maximum points in the 10,000m.   Run on his 23rd birthday, into a strong wind which he himself reckons cost him up to 2 seconds a lap, he pulled clear just after halfway to win in 28:54.4 with Wales’s Bernie Plain second.

These results also led to a detailed profile in the ‘Athletics Weekly’ of 15th November that year.   Some of the replies make an interesting comparison with that in the SMC Magazine of June 1986 quoted above.  for example:-

In early days was inspired by Lachie Stewart who was then at his best.   Athlete he particularly admires today is “I think Ian Stewart because he’s so tough and serious when he’s on the track.”   Realised he could make international level, “when I ran 28:58 for 10000m at AAA Championships in 1972 – I couldn’t train seriously that summer as I was nursing a calf injury during the year.”

Most pleasing performance: My 3:51.1 in 1971.   Up until then I had just run cross-country and iit proved to me that with the right application I could do something on the track.”   Greatest disappointment was “Missing the Commonwealth Games in Christchurch through injury.”   Target for 1976 is to make the Olympic 10,000m team.”   All-time goal is “to compete and hope to improve.”   What he likes most in athletics is “travelling and meeting people, well organised trips and most of all the atmosphere prior to big meets.”   Dislikes “chaotic travel arrangements and disorganised trips.”

Comment: “This is a great chance to condemn individuals for their running and organisation of the sport.   All I can say is if everyone was as organised as the local council back home where I live there would be no problem in athletics today.  The construction of an eight lane all weather track has just been completed (first of its type in the west of Scotland) – that speaks for itself.   The track is going to be combined with a Sports Centre and schools are going to be encouraged to use it to tap the local talent.   As you can imagine this is going to be more of a long term project.   At present the council fork out the prizes for the Coatbridge 5 (which are among the best in Britain) an the Coatbridge Games (the standard of prizes being similar   with  to the Coatbridge 5).   They have also sponsored the Scottish Cross-Country Championships for the past three years.   So with this new venture of track and sports centre I’d like to wish them all the best of luck as they deserve it and thank them for all they did for me in the summer. If only there were more councils like them who adopted a similar attitude towards sport.”

Training:   Usually trains twice a day – “but at present I’m on teaching practice and can only manage once” – between 9:00 and 10:00 am, 5:00 and 6:00 pm for 30 minutes to two hours.   Trains at College in Osterley Park and Richmond Park and “try to change courses as much as possible.”   Two train journeys lasting just under an hour take him to first class training facilities at Crystal Palace.   He rates having a coach as important.   “I was OK.   I received advice from here and there but it’s when things are going really badly that you need to have someone close to you.   Charles (Elliott) introduced a lot of new ideas into my training and I’m enjoying it.   Variety and enjoyment are Charlie’s magic words.”   Likes and dislikes in training: “There’s a lot I dislike buit I work on my dislikes as that’s usually the best session for you.   I don’t think in terms of likes and dislikes – I do what I have to do without thinking about it or complaining about it.”

Typical week’s training in winter (last year):

Sunday – am 15 miles steady; pm 5-7 miles relaxed;   Monday – (am) 5 miles easy; pm 7 miles steady;   Tuesday:  (am) 5 miles easy;   (pm) 4 x 600m x 250 recovery on grass;   Wednesday: (pm) 10-12 miles steady; Thursday: (am) 5 miles easy; (pm) 6 miles fartlek (200-300);   FGriday: (pm) 6 miles if competing next day otherwise easy run in the morning followed by steady evening run;   Saturday: Compete.   Most of my training is done on grass.

Typical week’s training in  summer (1975):

Sunday (am) 12 miles easy run; (pm) 3 x 6  200m hills (emphasis on style);   Monday: (am) 5 miles easy;   (pm) 5 x 1 mile build-up run;   Tuesday:   (am) 5 miles fartlek (long items); (pm) 5 x 600m x 600m and 5 x 300 x 300 on track;   Wednesday:  (am) 5 miles (short items); (pm) 6 miles including 2 miles build-up;  Thursday: (am) 5 miles easy); (pm) 6 x 300 x 300 and 6 x 150 x 150;   Friday: 5 miles including 4 x 1000m build-up;   (pm) 5 miles relaxed gentle strides.

Training this year compared to previous years is “very different – a lot more varied and interesting.”   Major changes planned for next year: “I’ve only been coached by Charles since AAA’s (1975) so I’m really still getting used to the new schedule and if changes are needed he’ll soon advise them or should I say change them quickly.”   Likes to compete “but not too often, once every three or four weeks but being at College I have to compete most weeks but I enjoy it – they are a great bunch of blokes in the club and we all enjoy travelling and competing for ‘Borough’.   ”

You could have a good time comparing these replies from 1975 with those of  1986.

EE JB 3

In the AAA’s 10000m in 1975: second in a Scottish National record

At the start of winter 1975, Devlin, Graham, Small and McDonald were in the team that was second in the Western District Championships and Jim Brown wasn’t seen until the Edinburgh to Glasgow on 15th November.   John Graham had an uncharacteristically poor run on the first stage and handed over in tenth place to Jim who picked up six places against some of the very best runners in Scotland on the notoriously difficult second leg with the second fastest time, just 18 seconds behind Andy McKean.   Clyde Valley was third, upholding the honour of the West of Scotland behind Edinburgh Southern Harriers and Edinburgh AC.   Two weeks later at Gateshead in an international cross-country fixture Jim raced the top Englishmen including Brendan Foster, Dave Black and Bernie Ford and Belgians led by Jos Hermens and Poland’s Bronislaw Malinowski and ran well to finish eleventh – four down on McKean but one ahead of young Nat Muir.   He was obviously running well because he was spoken of as pretty well certain of selection for the Scottish team for the cross-country international, but all his running was done in England and the results were not in the Scottish press.   The British Universities Championships were held at Stirling University in February and he was runner-up to Ray Smedley and spoke to Ron Marshall afterwards.   “Smedley’s runner-up on Saturday, Jim Brown from Holytown, was more than half a minute behind and had no intention of vying with the Englishman for a 5000m place.   [in the 1976 Olympics].   “It’s the 10000 I’m after, but between now and the final Olympic trial in June I’ll run only one – and that’ll be at the trial,” Brown said after the race.    Was he disappointed at having finished so far behind Smedley?   “A bit, though I’m doing three track sessions a week at Crystal Palace (he finished physical education studies in London in the summer) and I think my track preparations are clashing a wee bit with grass running.   It would have been nice to win because that was my last chance in student competition.”  

Missing the National, he was selected for the international at Chepstow where 24-year-old Brown was twenty ninth – twenty places better than in 1974, as the press report kindly reminded its readers – and first Scot to finish.

Summer 1976 was Olympic year and Jim was running very well indeed.   As he says above, he thinks his most disappointing race must have been the 1976 Olympic Trial at Crystal Palace.   Previously he had been ranked third in Britain due to the fast 10000m the previous year.   It was Jim’s final year at College, he was due to sit the Physical Education finals and although his training, especially speed work, had been going well, the competitive work outs that year had been much less good.   In the race itself, he just went for it and reached halfway in just over 14 minutes.   He says, “I recall the elation of thinking that I was nearly in the team but it was short lived as I tied up and finished the last half running backwards.   I don’t think I have ever been so depressed or disappointed after a race.

His own club’s 5 Miles Road Race was in mid-September and he was second to Jim Dingwall.   Having completed his studies in London, Jim was out in the McAndrew Relay on 2nd October.   Shettleston won but Jim had the fastest time of the day – 13:24 to Andy McKean’s 13:29.   He had also taken up a position as coach at the brand new Coatbridge Outdoor Centre.   Came the District Relay Championship on 6th November at Greenock and again Shettleston won, but this time, although ‘Brown gave a great display of power running as he lifted Clyde Valley eight places to fourth’ he had to be satisfied with second fastest, Nat Muir being two seconds quicker.    The big one in November was always the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay.   Clyde Valley finished fifth with Jim on the long seven mile sixth stage where he moved up from sixth to fifth with third fastest time of the afternoon.  When it came to the Scottish championships,   Jim for probably the first time ever, dropped out of a race, the National on a snow covered trail at Glenrothes, but suffering from the after-effects of ‘flu he might not normally have run at all.   The selectors understood and he was picked anyway for the international.    The event was held in Dusseldorf over a 7.5 mile trail round a racecourse.   Probably too short for most of the Scottish team which was led home by Allister Hutton in 14th with Jim 36th, Laurie Reilly 41st, Andy McKean 49th, Rees Ward 62nd, Paul Kenny 68th, John Graham 80th, John Robson 94th.

On 9th May, 1977, Jim was third in the Lanarkshire 1500m championship behind John Graham and Nat Muir in 4:03.3 – Graham’s time was 4:02.2 and Muir’s 4:02.8,   Seven days later at Gourock, he was again third.   This time it was in the 3000m at the Highland Games behind Lawrie Spence and John Graham.   “Brown, who was not all that happy about the soggy, rutted nature of the track (“they should add it to the cross-country calendar,” he observed) now turns his attention to a classy 5000m field at in Wednesday’s Phillips Electrical meeting at Crystal Palace.”  The race spoken of was a 5000m on 18th May at Crystal Palace against Africans and some of the very best Europeans.   Eventually it was won by S Nyambui of Tanzania in 13:34..6.   Jim hung on for as long as he could but fell away t finish 17th but ahead of such good men as Grenville Tuck, Jon Wigley, Steve Kenyon, Gerry Hannon and Merv Brameld.    On 5th June, in an international between Scotland and Greece at Meadowbank, Jim won the 10000m easily in 29:18.04 in a match the Scotland lost –   99 points to Greece’s 112.   By the end of the summer 1977 his best marks were 3:49.8 for 1500m (16th), 8:06.6 for 3000m (8th); 13:48.0 for 5000 (4th) and 29:18 for 10000m (6th).

The winter of 1977-78 started minus Brown, McDonald and company in the McAndrew Relay but the following week they defeated the winners of that race, Shettleston Harriers) in the Lanarkshire relays at Motherwell with Brown on the third stage running second fastest time behind Nat Muir.   On the country in the District relay championships on 5th November Clyde Valley was sixth with John Graham being second fastest on the day and Jim being fourth fastest.   In the Edinburgh to Glasgow on 19th November, he was on the second stage of the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay and picked up two places, from fourth to second, with the third fastest of the day, only Nat Muir and Andy McKean being faster.   On 8th December at Bellshill, Jim won the County championship on a course so bad that several refused to run on it: this was not just a problem for Lanarkshire, however, as Andy McKean was criticising the course at Stirling used for the inter-area race on the same day.   On 10th December he ran in an international race at Crystal Palace but finished down the order for a Scottish team that finished fourth.   Missing from the early 1978 races such as the Nigel Barge Road Race and the Spanish invitations, it was said at the District Championships late in January that Jim had some important races coming up.    In the National championships at Bellahouston Park in Glasgow, Jim Brown was fourth behind Hutton, Ward and McKean, on the same time as Phil Dolan and in front of Ian Gilmour, Frank Clement and John Myatt.   Selected for the international later that month, Jim had a real off-day and finished outside the first hundred.

That summer Jim began with a fast 5000 at Carluke in the Lanarkshire championships where he won in 14:02.0.   On 14th May he ran in a Scottish team in Athens against Greece, Wales and Luxembourg and justified his selection with first place in the 10000m in 28:36.4 from Allister Hutton in second on 28:37.1.   The SAAA 10000m championship was held at Grangemouth two weeks later on 27th May and Jim was second to Allister Hutton.   The report read: “Hutton must wait a fortnight to find out if his winning time, 29:07.8, taken into account with other performances this year, finds approval with selectors.   Both Hutton and Jim Brown, his runner-up nearly half a minute behind, have run much faster (28:36 and 28:37 in Athens), and Hutton was third in last year’s British championships.   I have the feeling that our respectable traditions in middle-distance running might just win the day for Hutton with an outside chance for Brown.”   When the team was announced on 11th June, 1978, there was no place for Jim Brown.  This was despite the fact that there was only one second between them and the run at Grangemouth had cost him his place.  He was not alone in his disappointment – there were several others, such as Graham Williamson, with good claims to selection who were left off the list.   The most egregious was the omission and selection on the same day of high jumper Brian Burgess, SAAA Champion!   Not selected for the team which was announced on the Sunday morning, he leapt 7’2″ that afternoon and was selected before bedtime.   That didn’t help Jim at all who missed another Games.    Nevertheless by the end of summer 1978 he was ranked fifth in the 5000m with 14:02.0, and topped the 10,000m list with 28:36.37 ahead of Allister Hutton (28:37.08 and Jim Dingwall (28:45.25) with the next man outside 30 minutes.

EE JB 4

Jim (black vest, running second) in Glasgow Marathon, 1985

A Graham MacIndoe picture

At the start of winter 1978-79, Jim ran a very good leg of the McAndrew relay lifting Clyde Valley from sixteenth to first on the second stage and running the fastest time of the day (three seconds faster than Nat Muir) – team mates Brian McSloy (fastest Junior) and Willie Marshall (fastest over 50) also took individual honours although the team could only finish fifth.   A week later, another relay and Jim again beat Nat for fastest time – this was in the  Lanarkshire relay and Clyde Valley were second this time.    Nat beat him to it in the District relay at Bearsden seven days later with Clyde Valley third.   The rivalry continued into November and the Allan Scally Relay at Barrachnie on the fourth of the month, organised by Nat’s club, Shettleston Harriers.   The headline on the report read:

“BROWN IS FASTEST AFTER RE-SCRUTINY

One runner had reason to feel aggrieved on Saturday after the results of the Allan Scally Relay had been worked out and the prizes awarded.   Jim Brown had looked fast but the results sheet thought not.   After a third-stage run round a course of nearly five miles at Baillieston, Brown pushed Clyde Valley from seventh to third place and was given a time of 22 min 42 sec.   The award to the fastest individual eventually went to Nat Muir (Shettleston) whose last leg of 22 min 23 sec looked invincible.   Brown was confident enough to query the decision, knowing that four or five others separated him from Muir according to the paper calculations and such has been Brown’s level of performance this season, that he was shocked to learn how far back he was listed.   All was put right yesterday (Sunday) however after a re-scrutiny revealed a 20 second error in Brown’s favour, so he actually pips Muir for fastest award by just one second.”   Edinburgh Southern Harriers won the race from Shettleston and Spango Valley.   Jim chose to miss the Glasgow University Road Race on 11th November, won by Nat Muir for the third successive year, but ran an outstanding second leg of the Edinburgh to Glasgow where he pulled the club from twelfth to second in the fastest time of the afternoon, then on the last Saturday of the month finished twentieth in the international races at Gateshead.   |Having been racing almost without respite, Jim won the Lanarkshire Six Miles Cross-Country Championship on 2nd December yet again but missed the Nigel Barge at Maryhill and the Western District Championships, held in driving sleet and rain in Bellahouston Park in mid January.   The Scottish championships were held at Livingston an frozen, rock hard, traditional cross-country trail where the mud had been frozen into ridges and rocks cemented into the ground.   Nat Muir was the winner with Lawrie Spence second, Half a minute down, and Jim Brown third, a further 23 seconds back with Jim Dingwall fourth.   The team for the international cross-country in Limerick two weeks later was not announced till 4th March and Jim was in for the sixth successive year – as were Allister Hutton and Laurie Reilly.

Summer 1979 was the year that Jim started on his marathon running career – obviously not to the exclusion of  track running – by the end of that season he had best times of 8:13.4 for 3000m, 14:00.5 for 5000, 28:58.0 for 10000 and 2:22:22 for the marathon.   They ranked him 8th, 8th, 1st and 11th in Scotland.  He started the season with his second win in the Tom Scott 10 Miles Road Race in April.  The report this time was short – he had beaten Graham Laing of Aberdeen in a field of 72 runners in 48 minutes 04 seconds with Laing on 49 minutes 19 seconds and Martin Craven third.   He then won the 3000m at Carluke on 2nd June in 8:48.4 and the following week had an interesting double at the East Kilbride Games – he won the 6 miles road race despite taking a wrong turning at one point and then won the 3000m on the track just ten minutes later.   In the SAAA Championships on 16th June, Jim was third in the 5000m behind Nat Muir and Allister Hutton where the winner ran 13:57.4.         It was not until 16th September though that Jim made his marathon debut – running in the Norco Aberdeen Marathon he finished second to another marathon debutant – local boy and future SAAA marathon champion Graham Laing, who won in 2:21:40 with Colin Youngson third in 2:27:44 and a whole host of experienced marathon men behind him, eg Willie Day, Doug Gunstone, Colin Martin, Evan Cameron and Alastair Wood.   When asked why he had taken up the marathon, and whether anyone had advised him or suggested to him that he do so, he replied that he just decided to do it – it was of course a time when the event had a very high profile world wide and many, many other runners were taking the same line and ‘giving it a try’.   Very few had his success in the event though.

That winter, 1979/80, he started his campaign with third fastest time of the day in the McAndrew Relay when Clyde Valley was second to Shettleston in the team race.   He then missed the Lanarkshire and West District relay championships but came out in the National event on 27th October when the club won with Brown himself turning in the fastest time of the day.   Into November and Clyde Valley won the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay by two minutes from Edinburgh AC with Edinburgh Southern seconds.   It was a very good team – Farquharson, Graham, Agnew, McSloy, Devlin, Brown, Marshall and Fox – with Graham, McSloy and Brown running the fastest times on their respective stages.   Brown held and extended the lead given to him by Eddie Devlin giving David Marshall a three minute cushion over the EAC runner.   On 1st December, Jim won the Lanarkshire Cross-Country title, and ran the following week in an international match at Crystal Palace in which he was unplaced.   On 5th January, 1980, Jim and Gordon Rimmer of Cambuslang were contesting the lead when they took the wrong turning at Canniesburn Toll, going 100 yards off course, and let Jim Dingwall get past.  By the end Rimmer won from Dingwall but Jim was off with Rimmer and Graham Clark of Spango Valley the next week to Elgoibar.   Jim was third in the Spanish classic, only six seconds behind the winner John Wild of England.   A week later he travelled back to Spain with a small Scottish squad led by Nat Muir to race in San Sebastian.   Muir was an excellent third with Jim Brown fifth and Lawrie Spence 15th to give Scotland second place in the team race.

Jim was eighth in the National with Clyde Valley finishing second team and on 16th February, 1980, the headline read “BROWN WILL CAPTAIN WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP SCOTS”.   A headline that most Scots, whatever their sport, would give their eye teeth for.   Jim had been announced as the team captain for the world cross-country championships to be held in March.   It went on : “Scotland’s team for the World Championships next month in Paris followed predictable lines when the selection was made yesterday in Grangemouth.   The selectors held their final trial for the Junior team just before lunchtime and as brief a conclave to find the nine seniors and six juniors as has been held in recent times came up with no surprises.   Jim Brown, long-toothed at this level of competition, captains the seniors of whom Nat Muir, the National champion, will be expected to set an example to the others at Longchamps racecourse on March 9th.   The other seniors selected – Graham Clark (Spango Valley), John Graham (Clyde Valley), Allister Hutton (Edinburgh Southern), Brian McSloy (Clyde Valley), Gordon Rimmer (Cambuslang), John Robson (Edinburgh Southern), Lawrie Spence (Shettleston).”    

In the International itself, the team did not run up to expectations, Jim finishing 31st, with Nat Muir tenth and John Robson in fifty second.   The next race is always the important one, and Jim headed for the summer, 1980, track and road racing.

EE JB 5

Jim with Alex Robertson: Tom Scott Road Race 1985

Graham MacIndoe

The second running of the National Six-Stage Road Race was held at the end of March, 1980, and Jim almost fell out with the club selectors when he requested a short stage rather than one of the six-mile legs – because he wanted to race at Berwick the next day.   He ran Stage Five, producing the day’s fastest time of 18:15 opening a gap of 46 seconds over the second club.   By the end of the race, Clyde Valley was second to Edinburgh Southern Harriers and 8 seconds ahead of Falkirk Victoria.  Jim ran the next day in a 10 mile race at Barrow-in-Furness – and won from a strong English field in 46:55.

On April 14th 1980, the headline and article read:

“LEG WORK PAYS OFF FOR BROWN

Jim Brown (Clyde Valley) retained his title in the Tom Scott Memorial Road Race from Law to Motherwell on Saturday.   He was in excellent form, just failing to break his own record by one second and finished 400 yards ahead of Allister Hutton (Edinburgh Southern Harriers) who was running over the ten miles distance for the first time.   Brown, whose winning time was 46 minutes 34 seconds, has been doing high mileage training of 120 miles per week preparing for the AAA’s marathon championship at Milton Keynes in three weeks times.   This heavy schedule is paying off for Brown as he looked and felt very fit.   He said after the race that he had intended waiting until the seven mile mark before making his effort, but he felt so good that he decided to go at three miles after he had been in the leading bunch with Hutton, Dingwall, Martin Craven (Edinburgh Southern) and Colin Farquharson (Clyde Valley).”

Although not placed at Milton Keynes, by the end of the summer Jim was ranked in four events – the 3000m, the 5000m, the 10000m and the marathon with the 10,000m again being his best event going by the rankings.   Times and places were 8:14.9 (10th), 14:09.8 (5th), 29:27.9 (2nd) and 2:19:03 (5th).

In the McAndrew on 4th October, 1980,  Clyde Valley won the race very comfortably and Jim only had to run round the course to ensure a Clyde Valley victory over Edinburgh Southern Harriers and Shettleston.   In the District Relays there was no Clyde Valley team but they made up for it in the National Relays when Jim Ran on the second leg for the team which finished second.  In the Edinburgh to Glasgow on 16th November 1980, Clyde Valley were taken into a lead on the long sixth stage which they never lost and they took home the gold medals.   Jim ran the fastest time of the day on the stage 47 seconds up on second fastest runner, Eddie Stewart of Cambuslang.  When it came to cross-country running in 1980-81, Jim was in great form.  He won the West District Championships in January and the ‘Glasgow Herald’ made the most of it with the headline of “BROWN RECOVERS AND MAKES IT LOOK EASY”   above an article pointing out that he had been slightly adrift at the end of the first lap of Bellahouston Park buut when he went in front on the next lap, the issue was never in doubt.   In the National Cross-Country Championship in 1981, Jim was second – only two seconds down – to Nat Muir.   In dreadful snowy conditions they were both clear by 4 miles and just raced it out all the way to the finishing line.    The International Cross-Country Championships were held in Madrid but almost all of the Scottish party were stricken with a mystery illness and four runners – Fraser Clyne Graham Williamson and Jim Brown all had to drop out of the race.    In the National 6 stage relay in March, Edinburgh Southern were the victors with a weakened Clyde Valley (Jim on the anchor leg) finished fifth.

That summer he ran his best 5000m on 20th June at Meadowbank in the SAAA Championships where he could only finish fourth in 14:18.46 which ranked him seventh in the country at the end of the summer. He was undoubtedly running well and on 2nd August at Meadowbank  in the  International against Denmark and Eire he won the 10000m in 29:40.54 – his best for the summer and it ranked him third in the country at the end of the season.

At the start of winter 1981-82, Jim did not run in either the McAndrew Relay, the Lanarkshire Relay Championships the West District or even the National relays but did run in the Edinburgh to Glasgow in late November.   Jim ran, unusually for him on the shortest stage in the race, the third, and wasn’t even in the top four times on what was generally regarded as the ‘easiest’ stage (although ‘easy’ is a relative term, there were no easy runs in the E-G!).   Bearing in mind that Jim never gave less than 100% effort, he was clearly injured.   He was nevertheless back in action in the New Year when, after passing up on the Beith and Nigel Barge races, He turned out on 23rd January in the West District Championships, where he was second to Lawrie Spence, only two seconds down on the Greenock man.   In the National a month later he was sixth (two places behind Clyde Valley team mate Ron McDonald) .    So he’d be in the team for the international?  No, he wasn’t and the ‘Glasgow Herald’ correspondent explained that Jim wanted to concentrate on training for the marathon.     In April 1982 it was back to the Tom Scott 10 Miles Road Race – it was a race that he liked with three victories over the years.   This time he was second to Allister Hutton: Hutton ran a course record of 46:05 but Jim was also inside the previous best with 46:27 – 6 seconds inside his own old record.

In 1982 with the assistance of team mate John Graham who had won in an exceptionally fast time the year before, Jim ran a marathon in Rotterdam, and it was in general quite a good year for him.   There was the Scottish International against South Belgium and Luxembourg in Luxembourg) on 12th June in which Jim and Lawrie Spence both.  ran in the 1000m where Lawrie won in 29:04.22 and Jim was fourth in 30:38.33.   This was his best and only track ranking time of the year and placed him 13th.   His best marathon time was in Glasgow on 17th October when he was timed at 2:20:38.   That placed him fourth in the race and eleventh in Scotland.   Doug Gillon reported on the race.

“Forster (Glenn Forster from England who won the race) was always in the leading group but he gambled shortly before the halfway mark when the American Emil Magallanes attempted to break the field.   “Magallanes took a lead of nearly 100 yards but I decided not to go with him,” said Forster.   It was the top runner in the three-man Scottish team, Jim Brown of Clyde Valley, who set out in pursuit with Fleming.   Gradually they pulled in Magallanes whose break had proved indecisive.   Forster caught the two Scots and the three together finally nailed down the flagging American from Oakland by the 14 mile mark.

Brown and Fleming had a nine second lead over Forster at  15 miles, reached in 71 minutes 01 second.   By that stage Magallanes had drifted 16 seconds down on the two Scots and gradually drifted backwards through the field.   Fleming, running through Ibrox, his home area, was cheered from the windows, “You’re having a great race, Peter,” said Brown, aware that the 21-year-old was running only his second marathon, was well on schedule to smash his best time.   “I can’t slow down here, not in front of the neighbours,” came the reply.   By 20 miles reached in 1:44:19 Forster was back up with the two Scots, Bark having been 23 seconds off the pace at 15 miles, had closed to just 12 seconds down, mounting his challenge over the last six miles.  

“It was at 22 miles that I finally cracked,” said Brown, who had looked for long as though he could give Scotland a home victory, despite being bitten by a Doberman Pinscher on his final winding down training run on Wednesday.   “I wondered why you sprinted every time a dog barked,” cracked his team mate Evan Cameron who finished ninth.   Brown goes for a tetanus injection today.   His muscles would have been liable to stiffen up had the inoculation been given before he started the run.   But 30 year old Brown could not raise any steam when Forster began took up the running. “

The leading runners and times were 1.   G Forster  2:17:16;   2.   C Bark   2:18:36;   3.  P Fleming   2:19:40;   4.   J Brown   2:20:38;   5.   N McCarron   2:21:26;   6.   T Jordan   2:21:34;   7.   A Daly   2:24:41   8.  M Crowell   2:21:54;   9.   E Cameron   2:21:58;   10.   D Macgregor   2:22:06.

EE JB 6

Jim the club runner: Six Stage Road Relay, 1986

Graham MacIndoe

The winter season in Britain usually starts in October and the marathon being run on the 17th October affected training and racing patterns for many athletes.   The West District Relays were on the day before the marathon and all teams were rather thin.   Jim missed all the relays up to the Edinburgh to Glasgow where he ran on the first stage, finishing third behind Nigel Jones (Edinburgh AC) and Don Macgregor (Fife AC) – 10 second down on Jones and 2 down on Macgregor in a Clyde Valley team that finished twelfth.   Other than that, Jim Brown was not seen in any of the major races over the winter of 1982-83.   Next summer he was not ranked in any event between 3000m and the marathon inclusive.    Injury was a constant problem for him at this point. and he was absent from all his favourite events such as the Tom Scott which he really loved racing in and in which, up to that point, he had three firsts and four seconds.   He did not appear in any of the major races that season and at the start of winter 1983-84 there was little sign of Clyde Valley AC never mind Jim Brown in the opening relays.   There were no club teams in the National relay at all but all the top men were out in the Edinburgh to Glasgow.   Jim again ran the first stage finishing sixth this time to be followed by Ron McDonald who picked up to fourth and the team went up and down the top four or five teams until the finally crossed the finishing line in bronze medal position.   Jim was clearly not in his usual form.  He continued to miss races – he did not figure in either the District and National Championships.  In the course of his career Jim had been plagued with injury – he had injuries to his calf and both Achilles tendons had surgery performed on them.   At this point in his career these injuries, as well as the growing business and family commitments, led to a restriction on his racing programme.   One race that was on the schedule however was at the end of September.   He was out again in the Glasgow Marathon on 30th September and finished eleventh in 2:19:08.   The race was won by England’s David Lowes in 2:15:31 with Annan’s Mike Carroll finishing in 2:16:24.   That time ranked  Jim 15th for the event at the season’s end.

By now Jim was racing only infrequently for the reasons quoted – injuries, career and family responsibilities – and in winter 1984-85 his first race was in the Edinburgh to Glasgow on 18th November when he ran on the fourth stage where his time was eighth fastest on the day and he maintained the club’s 19th position.  This was his only race that winter but he started 1985’s road season with second to Alan Puckrin in the Tom Scott, his time of 50:49, almost a minute and a half down on Puckrin but six seconds clear of Alex Robertson after outsprinting him in to the finish.   Clyde Valley won the team race with 28 points to Dumbarton’s 38.   He finished the summer with another sub 2:20 marathon when he turned out in Glasgow on 22nd September, finished twelfth and ran 2:19:59 – Mike Carroll was first Scot to finish (sixth) in 2:18:24 – on a day when the race was dominated by the English.

EE JB 7

Start of Glasgow Marathon 1985

By October 1985, Jim was racing very infrequently and, almost as important, Clyde Valley AAC (originally an amalgamation of five local clubs) had disbanded and the runners returned to their local groups.   Jim was now running for Motherwell.    He didn’t turn out in the short relays, nor in the Edinburgh to Glasgow but did race in the Six Stage Road Relay in March 1986.   He ran on the fourth stage and pulled the team up two places from ninth to seventh.    And this is his last major appearance.

Unlike many other top runners, Jim did not gradually fade away, falling slowly – or not so slowly – down the field and down the ratings in slower and slower times.    He had a good job with the local council, he had a satisfying domestic life and he just stopped with that good run.     He had had a very good career indeed – he ran for Scottish Schools, Scottish Under 20’s, Scottish seniors and British Seniors; he won championship titles at Schools, Scottish and British level and was for some time among the very best in Britain and, indeed, in Europe.   Scottish athletics lost a lot when Jim Brown hung up his spikes.

 

Andrew Brown

EE AB 1

Motherwell YMCA Harriers – who had had many good athletes all through their existence – went through a real ‘purple patch in the 1960’s.    They won the Edinburgh to Glasgow in 1962, 1963, 1964,  second in 1965 and third in 1961 and 1966.   They won the National Cross Country Championships in 1961 and were third in 1963 and won the West District Cross Country Championship in 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967 – seven times in all.    I haven’t mentioned any of the relays either but it was a quite remarkable spell.   They had many good or first class athletes and names like Bert MacKay, John Linaker, Ian McCafferty, Alex Brown (AP Brown)  and many others are very well known to all followers of the sport.    But the common opinion is that Andy Brown had more than most to do with it.    A natural leader he was also captain of the Scottish Cross Country team and was highly regarded by all in the sport whether officials or, especially, by other runners.   In this first section we can look at his rise to prominence up to early 1956.

Born on 11th December 1932, he was known on the programmes as AH Brown to distinguish him from his brother Alex.    So he was not the first A Brown to run for Motherwell – his father was a good class road and marathon runner and this was picked up by Emmet Farrell  in ‘The Scots Athlete’ of August 1952 as follows: “Father and Son Rivalry”   There’s a very interesting and friendly rivalry between the two A Browns, Junior and Senior of Motherwell YMCA H.   The son is a fairly prolific prize-winner on the track.   But his wiry, 47 year old father is not far behind him.   He has had several notable wins and places in road races and at Dunoon even managed to gain the scratch award.   Even though most of the notable road runners were absent it is still a remarkable feat to beat runners some nearly half his age.   That year he had run two marathons and finished in the middle of the field and at the Victoria Park Relays in October they both ran in the same team with Tom Scott and Bryce McRoberts making up the team with Andrew Junior being second fastest, 21 seconds slower than McRoberts.   The club had a team in the Edinburgh to Glasgow that year  but only one A Brown was in it and I’m assuming that it was Senior who ran the fifth stage but on the Midland  Cross-Country Championships it was AH Brown who led the club home with his twenty first place.   He was still a Junior though and in the National Junior Cross-Country Championships at Hamilton in 1953 he finished eleventh with his Dad being exactly 100th in the Senior race.   Later that year it was AH Brown who turned out for the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay on the second stage and after taking over from Tom Scott in 17th place he handed over in 15th with the final team position being 18th.   He did however run the same time to the second as CD Robertson running for Dundee Hawkhill and they were equal seventh fastest.   For an Under 20 runner to do that running so far down the field is indeed commendable.   In the National at Hamilton in 1954 he finished third, having been eighth in the Midlands Championship, behind John McLaren (Shotts) who won in 32:42 and Adrian Jackson, a star English runner running for Edinburgh University, in 32:46.   Andy’s time was 33:01 and Emmet Farrell had this to say: Surely the best race of the day was on the Junior Championship over 6 miles.   The race between McLaren of Shotts and Jackson of Edinburgh was a classic.   With incredible grit and courage, McLaren fought off his renowned adversary to win with little to spare.   This race was an exhilarating spectacle and while McLaren deserved the spoils of victory – great credit is due to Jackson who moved up to the from from about tenth place.   AH Brown of Motherwell YMCA also had a grand race and actually assumed the lead with two miles to go.”

A year later and he was ninth in the 1955 National Cross Country Championships and had his first run for Scotland in the International Cross Country Championships.   Colin Shields in the official history of Scottish Cross Country remarked “In the early days of 1955 Andrew Brown won the Beith race having earlier been just nine seconds slower than Bannon in the Midlands Relays.   He was showing the benefit of the extra training he received during his National Service in the Royal Air Force and was beginning to display the form which was to gain him twelve international vests in the next fourteen years.   An interesting feature of this National was that the Irishman Cyril O’Boyle of Clydesdale Harriers finished in sixth place and the selectors debated whether to include him in the Scottish team.   The vote went against him with one of those opposed to O’Boyle’s selection being the Clydesdale Harrier on the selection committee!   In the International that year the Scots team disappointed but Andy Brown was fifty second and a counting runner in the event.   This was just a year after being third in the Junior Championship.

In the list of Scottish Best performances printed in the ‘Scots Athlete’ in June 1955, he was ranked third in the Three Miles with 14:40.4, a time run in Withdean in May that year.   the significance was that although these Best Performance Lists were published every summer every month this was his first appearance in the rankings as published in the ‘Scots Athlete’.   By the time new lists were published in August he was second to Ian Binnie with 14:12.6.   Before they came to the actual results of the SAAA’s Championships, Emmet Farrell commented – “A Brown Surprise: Ian Binnie retained his 3 and 6 miles titles creditably though not up to the best Binnie standards but Motherwell’s Andy Brown by his second place in both events revealed himself one of the most improved runners in the country.   In the 6 miles in particular he gave Binnie some anxious moments till the latter’s extra class prevailed and his time of 30:03 was excellent.”   Farrell went on in the same Commentary to report on the AAA’s of England Championships and had this to say: Brilliant too were the 4th places won by Don Gorrie in the 880 yards and Andy Brown in the 6 miles.   Gorrie’s time, unofficially assessed at 1:52 compares favourably with the winning time of 1:52.2, as does Brown’s grand 29:35.2 with Norris’s 29:06 in the battle of the heatwave.”     The results of the two races at the SAAA were Binnie first in both with 14:18.9 and 29:40.4 and Brown second in 14:31.1 and 30:03.

Came the cross-country season and the ‘Running Commentary’ in the ‘Scots Athlete’ said:    “Rise of Andrew Brown.   Motherwell’s Andy Brown is surely the most  promising and improved runner in Scotland.   Starting with his two seconds to Binnie in the Scottish 3 and 6 miles he ran the race of his life in the AAA 6 miles to finish fourth in 29:35.2.   He had other great races at various distances subsequently winning several mile handicaps in fast time.”

In the first two races of the winter 1955/56 season he had second fastest time in the Victoria Park Relays of 15:03 – only one solitary second behind Eddie Bannon of Shettleston; he followed this up with fastest time in the Lanarkshire Relays ahead of all the Shettleston runners who filled the first two team places.      The picture below is from the Scots Athlete of the time and shows Brown in the RAF running vest.

EE AB 2

In the ‘Scots Athlete’ for December 1955 Emmet Farrell was saying that if there were an award not for the best runners of the year but for the most improved in the fashion of the E-G’s most meritorious award, he would have to choose between three runners of whom Brown was one.   In the Midlands District Championship that season Brown was second, six seconds behind John McLaren and thirteen ahead of Bannon.   In his annual preview of the National for 1956, Emmet Farrell predicted the first three as John McLaren, Andy Brown and then Eddie Bannon.   He reckoned that Brown seemed to be reaching his peak at the right time and might even start as a slight favourite before talking about the amazing advance  the ‘little Motherwell runner’ had made.   (the references to the ‘little’ Motherwell runner seem odd – I don’t remember him as particularly wee: that was Dunky Wright and Harry Fenion!)   As for the forecast – well he got one right!   The result was a victory for Eddie Bannon with Andy second and Tom Stevenson of Wellpark third.    In the International match that followed, Andy Brown finished fiftieth and out of the counting six for the team which was fourth, one point in front of Portugal.

Into the summer of ’56 the Scottish Best Performances at 3rd June had Andy fourth in the Two Miles with 9:23.4 and he had his usual good season culminating in victory in the Scottish Six Miles Championship in 29:47.6 and then being second in the Three Miles the following afternoon in 14:40.6.   The second athlete in the six was Pat Moy of the Vale of Leven in 31:10.2 so it was a convincing enough win over a Scottish cross country internationalist.  As usual Emmet had something to say in his review of the championships: “Much improved Andy Brown also deserves commendation for his grand Six Miles in the Championships on his versatility.”  

Winter 1956/57 began with Andy running 14:56 and picking up eight places on the third stage of the Victoria Park Relays and setting a new course record of 14:56, one second faster than Graham Everett of Shettleston only to see Ian Binnie take it away from him with 14:53 on the final stage!   In the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay in November he ran the sixth stage and pulled his club from fourteenth to twelfth.  The final list of Best Performances for 1956 was in the January 1957 issue of the magazine and Andy was second in the Three Miles with 13:56 run at Pitreavie and first on the Six with 29:10.0 run at the White City in July.    According to the results as printed he did not run in the National Championships in 1957.   But a year later he recorded his only win in the event.

Colin Shields wrote of the Championships in 1958: “Andy Brown (Motherwell YMCA) won his first and only National title over a tough test of strength and stamina in which the course was extended to include the rough countryside between the Hamilton Racecourse and the River Clyde.   Brown finished three seconds in front of Graham Everett with newcomer Alastair Wood finishing in third position.”   This of course earned selection for the International Cross Country Championship in Wales and Colin reported on it.   “The 1958 International Championships, held at Portcanna Field, Cardiff, resulted in the now expected poor performances from Scottish runners.   Scottish National Champion Andrew Brown and John McLaren failed even to make the counting six for their country.”   (Andy when he won, but Andrew when he failed to count!)   In the 1958/59 season the report is from Colin Shields again.   “Andy Brown won the Nigel Barge Road Race in 23:02 but met his match in the Midland Championship when miler Graham Everett won the first of three consecutive titles.   Everett went into the lead at half distance and went on to win by 80 yards from Brown.”   In the National Alastair Wood won from John McLaren and Bertie Irving of Bellahouston.    (Bertie was said to have run only three races every season for four years – the E-G, the National and the International.   The records show that this was only the case in 1959, 1960 and 1962!)   “The feature of this race was the poor form shown by the previous year’s international team with six of the internationalists – Andy Brown, Des Dickson, Harry Fenion, Andy Fleming, Pat Moy and John Russell – all finishing outside the first dozen.”  

Regardless of the standard of running in the National and missing out on the International Andy had a good summer wiping Ian Binnie’s Three Miles record from the books by three and a half seconds with a time of 13:47.6.    Despite his relentlessly high standard of running and victory in the the Six Miles Championship no fewer than three times (1956 with 29:54.6, 1957 with 29>54.8 and 1963 with 29:53.8) he never won a national title at the distance.

Although by definition it takes more than one man to win a team title, one man is often a catalyst for great deeds done by a team and we can all think of men that we know who were in this category.   To everybody who ran in Scotland in the 60’s, Andy Brown was Motherwell, and this is not to decry the outstanding efforts of many members of their teams.   A natural leader He led his club to three consecutive victories in the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay in 1962, 1963 and 1964, second in 1965 and third in 1961 and 1966.   There were also no fewer than seven Midland District titles, the National Cross Country Championship once – 1963, two National Junior Championships – Ian McCafferty in 1965 and 1966, five Midlands District individual titles – Andy Brown in 1962 and 1963 and Ian McCafferty in 1964, 1965 and 1970, Midland District Relay titles in 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966 and 1967 and many International runners over the same period:

AH Brown: 12 representative appearances; AP Brown 3 (1965, 67 and 68), John Linaker 3  (1963, 66, 68), I McCafferty 7 (1965, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70 and 72), B McKay 1 (1963), D Simpson 1 (1962).

Although they had had several internationalists over the years (Somerville, Fleming, Nelson and others) there had never been a flowering to match this before or since.    There were many other very good athletes turning out for Motherwell at this time such as long time member Johnny Poulton and Jim Johnston who joined from Monkland but the key figure was Andy Brown.   he was always involved – I was once at the two miles to go point on the Edinburgh to Glasgow relay when Andy appeared shouting to brother Alex – “Two miles to go, less than ten minutes running!”    Doug Gillon reported on Andy in the middle of Airdrie in the same race shouting at a woman to get her pram off the road to let Ian McCafferty through.    At the last Ibrox Sports I was on the same handicap as Alex (about 100 yards) in the Mile when Andy came across and told him to watch the starter and go on the puff of smoke and not wait for the sound of the gun: I used the advice as well.   At a New Year’s Day race at Beith I saw Andy telling the Motherwell runner not to do strides away from the start line – “they’ll start the race if you’re 30 yards behind the line; do your strides up the course, they won’t start the race if you’re 30 yards up on the rest!”    He was everywhere and that was as well as doing his own running.   Alex as very lucky to have such a brother and every club could do with and Andy!   Note that the 1968 International team had four from the club there – Andy, Alex, John Linaker and Ian McCafferty.   His own running was of such a consistently high standard – Colin Youngson has pointed out that his four runs on the fourth stage between 1962 and 1965 were quite outstanding – fastest time every time out by margins of 37, 70, 5 and 57 seconds and his record of 27:37 from 1965 was quite superb and lasted until the stage was altered.   His brother Alex had the fastest time on the same stage in 1966 – just a coincidence?

In the Edinburgh to Glasgow, Andy ran in 1956, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65 and 66.   From 1959 to 1966 they produced 20 fastest stage times and two stage records with 1964 being the most prolific with 5 fastest times of the eight stages and a stage record by Bert McKay on the seventh stage.   For those who say it was not all down to Andy, the reply is that there is never a single cause and there were a lot of good guys out there but three years after his last race they were out of the E-G for a few years and never produced anything like it again.  So what happened in 1967 that the team dropped so quickly from the E-G and Scottish Championships?   Well, in 1967 the new club of Law and District appeared on the scene and many of the Motherwell runners moved there with another small group going to the new amalgamation of clubs, the short-lived Clyde Valley AAC.    For Motherwell YMCA, I and many others would take a lot of convincing that Scotland’s cross country captain had not done a great job with a team composed almost entirely of local lads.

EE AB 3

John Linaker to Bert McKay for Motherwell  in 1962 at the end of the sixth stage

In the 1959-60 cross-country season, Andy was second to Graham Everett in the Midland Championship and then won the Inter-District at Hamilton over 9 miles finishing ten seconds clear of Joe Connolly, only to be defeated surprisingly by team-mate John Linaker in the Scottish YMCA Championships by over 600 yards.   The National in 1960 is always remembered for the ferocious and sustained race between two Shettleston Harriers – Graham Everett and  Alastair Wood, but third place was Andy Brown a quarter of a mile back but back in the team for the International.   In the international Alistair Wood led the team to fifth place – a team which included Englishman Bruce Tulloh making the first of two appearances for Scotland  – with Andy in 34th..   Came 1960/61 and the first real trial was the Nigel Barge race at Maryhill.    Graham Everett triumphed, and in the Midland Championship he again won over Brown and Connolly.   When it came to the National Cross-Country Championship at Hamilton he was again third behind winner Connolly and second placed Everett.   In the International race at Nantes, Scotland was sixth with Brown 28th.

Colin Shields reckons that the next season was definitely Andy’s best of his career.   He says: Although Andrew Brown had won the National in 1958, season 1961-62 was definitely the Motherwell harrier’s finest year in his long and distinguished career in Scottish and International athletics.   He led Motherwell YMCA to victory in the Midland relay championship, the first of seven consecutive victories; won the Nigel Barge New Year race and the Midland championship at Renton which had previously been dominated by John McLaren (4 wins) and Graham Everett (3 wins) and led his club to the team championship – a title they were to hold  on four consecutive occasions and five times in six years .    Brown’s happiness was enhanced when his young brother Alec won the Youths titles in the Midlands and Scottish National Championships.

Brown was out on his own at Renton and, although challenged in the early stages by John Linaker – a new Motherwell recruit, he forged ahead by half distance to win by over 100 yards.    Linaker who had a bad accident clearing a fence in the final stages of the race was overtaken by Bert McKay but held on to take third place ahead of the holder Graham Everett to ensure that Motherwell became the first club in the history of the race to have the first three athletes home.    At the start of the season, Alec Brown on finding that Motherwell YMCA were short of a full Youths team, coerced his friend Ian McCafferty to join the club and make up the team.”

Bert McKay defeated Brown in the Inter-District championship at Cleland Estate but when it came to the National Brown was a clear favourite with Everett and Wood also in the field.      Glasgow University student Callum Laing set the initial pace but after the first two miles or so Jim Alder went into the lead.   Brown had a go at about half distance but Alder held on and won from Brown by about 70 yards with Laing third.   Motherwell had three runners in the first nine but the drop-off was so great that the team could only finish fifth.   Colin Shields points out that Brown had his revenge over Alder two weeks later in the British YMCA Championships in Manchester before going on to say: “Seemingly getting better as the season progressed, Brown kept his best performance for the International championship at Graves Park, Sheffield.   After a bad patch during the middle of the race, Brown was back in twenty fourth position at the start of the last one and a half mile lap of the race.   With a strong finishing surge he tore his way through the field gaining fifteen places to eventually finish ninth, just 29 seconds behind the winner Gaston Roelants (Belgium)   Scotland was fifth just 8 points behind the fourth placed Morocco.”

His great form continued during the summer and he broke his old rival Ian Binnie’s Native Record for the 10 miles with a time of 49:58.8 against Binnie’s 50:11.    He also won the Shettleston marathon in the

very good time of 2:25:58 and was looking good for the SAAA Championships.  He had been running on the roads with some success since the Clydebank to Helensburgh in April 1957 when he was second to Harry Fenion in the year when he was really flying and won the SAAA Marathon.   His progress on the roads thereafter is illustrated in this table which takes us up to the SAAA race in 1962..

Date Race Place Time Remarks
10/8/57 Carluke 12 1st 63:46 2. JM Kerr 63:51
7/9/57 Shotts HG 14 Miles 1st 1:14:48 2.   H Fenion 1:14:49
9/8/58 Carluke 12 1st 60:49 2.   H Fenion 61:38
6/9/58 Shotts HG 1st 1:13:34 2.   A McDougall 1:14:07
25/4/59 Clydebank to Helensburgh 1st 1:23:11 2. H Fox 1:24:06
8/8/59 Carluke 12 1st 60:39 2. J Connolly 61:42
15/8/59 Springburn 12 1st 67:00 2.   G Eadie 67:36
5/9/59 Shotts HG 1st 1:19:33  
12/9/59 Dunblane HG 14.5 1st 1:19:24 2. J Connolly 1:22:24
18/7/61 Musselburgh 13.5 1st 62:57 2. N Ross 63:16
16/9/61 Shettleston Marathon 1st 2:40:04  
7/4/62 First Tom Scott 10 1st 50:33 2. J Linaker 51:06
18/4/62 SMC 10 1st 49:58.8 2.Bert McKay 51:55
28/4/62 Clydebank to Helensburgh 1st 1:26:15 2. G Eadie 1:27:31
30/5/62 Shettleston Marathon 1st 2:25:58 2. JM Kerr 2:26:58

Alastair Wood also had designs on the 1962 title and they fought it out for almost 20 miles before Brown dropped out.   The splits were 27:29 for five miles ( a group of five running together at this point), 55:06 for 10 miles with the same group of five battling it out, 1:19:53 for 15 miles with Wood Brown and John Kerr running together.   Brown had to drop out and Wood won in 2:24:39 with Kerr , who had won the race in 1961 second in 2:26:54.   Andy kept on running on the roads that year with some distinction – in June 62 he not only won the Springburn 12 in 65:38 but also won the handicap award and in November 1962 he won the Brampton to Carlisle in 48:37.    There were other road runs and victories but there were to be no more marathons.

Motherwell, led by Andy Brown, won the Midlands Relay and team championships in winter 1962-63 and went one better than the year before by winning the National Cross-Country Championship.  Brown and Linaker had run almost all the way together in the Midlands until Linaker stumbled towards the end and Brown won by three seconds.   They did the same again in the National, ie setting the pace with Alastair Wood going with them.   They were well clear when Brown tried to break the others with a break at a mile to go but the others were fast track men and current track champions with the result that Linaker won, Wood was second and Brown third.   With Bert McKay fourth Motherwell won the championship with Johnny Poulton last counter in 44th.   That summer was another good one for Andy.    He won the Six Miles Championship in 29:53.8 and topped the rankings for the year with 28:53.8 which he ran in Glasgow in June.    Second in the SAAA Three Miles Championship behind Fergus Murray  (14:01.6) in 14:12.8 he was ranked fourth in the ratings with 13:57 run a month after the championships in Pitreavie.   He was also ranked at 11 in the Two Mile rankings with his best time of 9:09.4 – one place below young brother Alex who had the same time.

Winter 63-64 saw Ian McCafferty as a first year Junior win the Midland District Cross Country title for the first time with Alex Brown second, Bert McKay fifth, Davie Simpson sixth, Andy Brown seventh and George Henderson ninth for 30 points, well clear of Shettleston’s103 points.    In the National, Andy was fourth in a race won in commanding fashion by Fergus Murray with Jim Alder and Alastair Wood also ahead of him.    The International that year was at Leopardston Racecourse, Dublin, and the Junior race was won by McCafferty by a distance who was backed by Alex Brown, 7th, and Joe Reilly, 9th, for a second place in the team competition.       For the third year in succession, Andy Brown led the Senior team home when he was 29th, one place in front of Jim Alder and Scotland finished seventh.   Colin Shields adds: “The big disappointment of the day was the performance of Fergus Murray.  He started well, being up with the leaders in the early stages but drifted back as he ran without conviction or determination and eventually finished fourth team counter in fortieth position – the first of many poor races in the International where he never ran to his full potential.”    There was always something to detract from the Senior team performance.

1964-65 started with Motherwell winning their fourth Midland Relay Championship and McCafferty defeated Fergus Murray in the Nigel Barge race at Maryhill before winning the Midlands Championship with Andy Brown second.   New Motherwell recruit Dick Wedlock was sixth and they won the team championship – also for the fourth year in a row.   In a real cracker of a race at the National at Hamilton, Andy Brown finished fourth.  Let Colin tell the story:  “The National Championship at Hamilton Racecourse continued to grow in size and stature with 21 clubs finishing teams in the senior race, a record for the event, and seven former champions  – J Emmet Farrell, Andy Forbes, Andy Brown, Alastair Wood, Jim Alder, John Linaker and the holder Fergus Murray – lining up in the field of 350 runners.   Murray retained his title with a solo run throughout the seven and a half mile race.   In an unrelenting mood Murray set off at a gallop and by two miles had opened up a gap from the following group of Andrew Brown, Lachie Stewart and Jim Alder.   Alder set off in pursuit of the leader at three miles but made no impression on the flying Murray who eventually won by 24 seconds from Alder, with Stewart third a further eleven seconds behind and Brown fourth.”     Alder, fourth, Brown, eighth, and McCafferty, eleventh, had already won the Hannut international race in Belgium ahead of Belgium and West Germany.   In the International Championship that year in Ostend, Alder was first Scot in a team which finished sixth of the fifteen countries taking part with Andy Brown 43rd.    On the track in 1965, Andy was ranked eleventh in the Two Miles with 9:20 when finishing fifth in Glasgow in a race won by Ian McCafferty in 8:42.2, and eighth in the Three Miles in 13:58.8 at Ayr in the Land o’Burns Meeting.   The following summer, 1966, he was third in the Six Miles rankings with 29:04.2, a time recorded when finishing second in the SAAA Championship in Edinburgh.   He was also ranked fifteenth in the 3000 metres steeplechase with a time of 9:49.4 when finishing second to younger brother Alex at Ayr.

Motherwell won the Midland Relay Championship for the fifth consecutive year early in 1965-66 before Christmas and then the brothers, Andy and Alex, were third and fourth in the Nigel Barge race behind Lachie Stewart and Eddie Knox of Springburn.  Stewart and Knox were first and second again in the Midlands championship but Motherwell failed to  win the team title, losing to Victoria Park by 11 points.   Although out of the medals, Andy Brown again competed for the Senior team – finances made it a small team of seven seniors to Morocco where he finished 29th in a team which was sixth of thirteen countries – with Lachie Stewart twelfth, Ian McCafferty (who lost a shoe when leading at four miles) fourteenth, Jim Alder 16th – only 18 points behind third placed Morocco.

In the 1966-67 season,   Ian McCafferty won the New Year’s Day race at Beith with Lachie Stewart second and Andy and Alex Brown third and fourth.   McCafferty continued to dominate in the West of Scotland and in the Midlands championship at Bellahouston he won again, this time from Lachie Stewart with young Alex defeating big brother Andy for third place.      Three in the first four meant that Motherwell had their fifth title in six years.   In the 1967 National, there was a team of New Zealand athletes competing as guests prior to the World Championships in Wales.   Andy Brown was fourth but since the three in front were Eddie Gray (NZ), Lachie Stewart and Mike Ryan (ex-Scot, now NZ) he was really second Scot and again made the team for the International.

The big event for Motherwell YMCA’s cross-country, road and even track and field running section in 1967 was the founding of the Law and District Amateur Athletic Club.    We all knew about the connection between Motherwell YM and Law – one of their members throughout the Fifties and into the Sixties was Tom Scott.   Tom was an excellent athlete and marathon runner who had been in many teams with Andy Brown until he died in a car accident on his way to a marathon in the North of England.   Motherwell set up the Tom Scott Memorial 10 Miles Road Race covering the route that he ran every day to and from his home in Law to work in Motherwell.   From the very start it was a superb race, bigger fields than any (up until the 80’s marathon boom), better prizes and a top class trophy which attracted most of the top runners in the country.    When the Law team appeared on the scene in 1967, Ian McCafferty, Alex Brown, Andy Brown and several others who had run in the MYMCA colours in 1966, appeared in the Law and District outfit and right well did they do so.    But here’s a puzzle – in writing this I tried to get a contact address for Andy from the club and they didn’t have one and couldn’t help me.    The club records do not include any of the superb marks set by any of the men who were there in the beginning.    McCafferty’s wonderful times for 1500 and 5000 are not there nor are any of the others.   Motherwell YMCA linked up with Bellshill YMCA in 1991 to form Motherwell Athletics Club.

The formation of the new club and the change of vest however did not stop the good running done by the former Motherwell runners.   In summer 1967, Ian McCafferty won the SAAA One Mile Championship and led the Scottish rankings with 4:02.5 although Bert McKay was also listed under the Motherwell name – he stayed with the old club until the new Clyde Valley was formed by the amalgamation of five Lanarkshire clubs and then ran for it.   Andy Brown appeared in the Two Miles rankings (9:01.8) and the Six Miles (29:32.6);  and brother Alex appeared in the One, Two, Three and Six lists.   To continue with Andy though on the track he kept racing and recording excellent times although not of his own very high standard of previous years:.   Inn 1968 he appeared in the Scottish All Time lists for the Six Miles with 28:53.8 which he had run in 1963 and in the Ten Miles he was fourth with his 49:58.8 which had been a Scottish record when he set it in 1962.   For the 1968 season he was twenty fifth in the Two Miles with 9:12.4, sixteenth in the Three Miles rankings with 14:04.8 and fourteenth in the Six Miles with 30:18.2 but won no titles.  He put this right in 1969 when he won the West District 10000 metres championship in 30:51.4 which placed him thirteenth in Scotland for the year.

How did the new club do in the winter seasons thereafter?   Well the Brown effect worked so well that by November 1969 – one year after their first winter – they were running a team in the Edinburgh to Glasgow.  The team was ninth, then 17th in 1970, 8th in 1971 and 13th in 1972.    This last was the first time in all his runnings in the race all the way back to the late 1950’s that AH Brown had lost places in the event – he went from 11th to 14th on the second stage.   He did not run the following year and the Law & District team dropped out of the race after 14th place in 1973.    In summer 1968 he was twenty fifth in the Two Miles rankings (brother Alex was eighteenth), sixteenth in the Three Miles and fourteenth in the Six Miles in which he won the West District Championship with Alex in second place.   However, 1968 was the year when he was seventh in the National Championships and made the squad for the International where the Scottish team performed heroics with their points total at halfway being 172 and by the finish 137 and Colin Shields comment on Andy Brown was “35 year old captain Andy Brown drove the team onwards while pushing himself into the top 20 finishers.”  Ian McCafferty led the team home in tenth wth Lachie Stewart eighteenth and Andy nineteenth.    His appearances are in the table below.

Year Position Counter? Comments
1955 52 Yes  
1956 50 No  
1958 54 No  
1960 34 Yes  
1961 28 Yes  
1962 9 Yes First Scot
1963 11 Yes First Scot
1964 29 Yes First Scot
1965 43 Yes  
1966 48 Yes  
1967 47 Yes  
1968 19 Yes  

He had been as inspirational a captain for Scotland as he had been for Motherwell YMCA and, briefly, for Law & District AAC and it is a rare gift.   So many top runners have such tunnel vision that they do not see the wider picture or have the gift of enthusing/encouraging their team-mates.   Even without it it his long and successful career on road, track and country would be worthy of the greatest respect.   Andy made a comeback as an M40 Veteran in 1981 and finished second to Martin Craven and with Bert McKay and Willie Marshall making up the Clyde Valley team they won the team race.  Not only that, when the Clyde Valley team finished second in the National in 1982, the six counters were Ron McDonald, Jim Brown, Brian Gardener, Peter Fox, Joe Small and Andy Brown.   Doing the sums we arrive at an age of 49 for Andy in that team.   One of his team mates that day describes him as ‘the hardest of hard men.’  He returned the following year and turned the tables on Martin when he was first and Martin Craven finished second.   He disappeared from the records for a bit and then as an M60 Vet in 1994 and won the Cross Country Championship in the Law and District AAC vest.   On the track the previous year (1993) he had  set the Scottish Masters M60 indoor record for the 3000 metres of 9:54.02 and in 1994 set the outdoors record for 5000 metres of 16:48.44.   However he had done his real running when it really counted, when he was a Senior athlete, competing against all-comers and his record, set then will last for a long time to come.    Currently an honorary life member of Law and District AAC he still lives in Motherwell and has agreed to present the prizes at the Tom Scott Road Race in 2012.

 

 

 

Sandra Branney

EE SB 1

Sandra Branney was born on 30th April 1954 in Glasgow where she still lives.   She is also a member of a Glasgow club – starting with Victoria Park AAC, she moved to Glasgow AC and now that the two clubs have merged she is back with City of Glasgow Victoria Park.   She is identified with Glasgow every bit as much as Liz McColgan is with Dundee.      According to an article in the “Scotland’s Runner” magazine in November 1986, she took up running in 1983 on the prompting of her husband Donald and has had a most remarkable career since.   “When Sandra started running three years ago, Donald used to have to ‘drag her round the block’.   Now he has been left trailing gamely in her wake.”   Donald is clearly a major factor in her success and she admits as much when she says in reply to being asked about  anyone who has had an influence on her performances, “The one person who stands out is my husband Donald who, as he puts it, is ‘right behind me’.   Over the years I have read a lot and where possible spoke to people about training and competing.   When I decided to go back to track a few years ago, I joined John Montgomery’s group.  It was the best move I ever made and my recent track performances are down to John and the rest of the gang.”    Although others are mentioned and John is name-checked, Donald is the first mentioned and his importance stands out.  

She  really burst on to the scene in the Glasgow Marathon in 1985 with no background that anyone knew of.   At the age of 31 she ran 2:45.  

If ever the “What if …..” question were to be asked of an athlete, it would have to be asked of Sandra.   Clearly an athlete of talent, a gifted athlete, what if she had taken up running earlier?    We can’t answer that accurately, although there are formulae to calculate what her times might have been, but we can look at her career in a bit of detail and wonder.

*****

As a child between the ages of eleven and fifteen she was a competitive swimmer, she gave up for a few years and then took the sport up again when at University.  She started running after she watched the first Glasgow Marathons and she just felt that she wanted to be part of it.   She started running (very slowly, she says) just after the 1983 event and ran in the 1984 marathon in 3:40 or thereabouts.   After keeping going through the winter she started to get a bit faster and it took off from there.   When asked if she had any role models the name of Joan Benoit comes first – she had won the 1984 Olympic marathon when Sandra was just a self-confessed jogger.   In total awe of her, Sandra says she couldn’t comprehend how anyone could run so fast.   Everything was coming together to encourage her ambitions – The Glasgow marathons, Benoit’s Olympic success and the inspiration it generated and Donald’s support and interest.    The swimming background helped with her fitness and she was being coached by Ronnie Neilson at the time of the ’86 marathon.   Sandra comments “I ran ’84 and ’85 self coached.   I was only coached by Ronnie Neilson for a year or so – early ’86 until late ’87.   The quote below was after the ’86 Glasgow Marathon.    Her career as a serious runner probably began with that Glasgow marathon.    To quote again from the article in ‘Scotland’s Runner’: “Neilson is a keen supporter of the pre-marathon ‘bleed-out’ diet whereby the athlete is starved of carbohydrates for three days (eating mainly proteins) then starts ‘carbo loading’ for the final three days to give the muscles an extra top-up of the glycogen that fuels a marathon run.      Sandra, who normally weighs in at 7st 2lbs, had to undergo the withdrawal symptoms that a lot of athletes face during the carbohydrate -starving period.   “By the Wednesday morning before the marathon I felt terrible.   I was very irritable and didn’t feel much like running a marathon at the end of the week;, she says.   “But it worked”, says Neilson, “You only had to look at the way Sandra jumped over the line at the finish to see that she had everything right on the day.”   Although she wasn’t too sure about it herself, she says it worked and she incorporated a version into all her subsequent marathons although it was difficult for the overseas races.

Her talent was not limited to roads: track running has been and is a big part of her athletics and Sandra is a good cross country runner who twice won the Scottish championship.   Having made her debut in 1986 when she finished seventh there was a wee slip the next year when she slipped to eleventhn(“I had a cold but that’s no excuse!)    In 1988 at Irvine she won from Lynn Harding by over two minutes.   It was reported in ‘Scotland’s Runner’ as follows.   “Sandra Branney led Glasgow AC to a team victory despite the hazards of a poorly stewarded course.   The Strathclyde University librarian damaged a hip last autumn and had had only one track race – the Scottish indoor 3000 metres which she won – since October.   She sorted herself out largely thanks to running in a special jacket in the university’s swimming pool, and looks in good shape for the World 15K Road Race Championship in Adelaide where she will represent Britain.”    Not content with winning the Championship, she returned the following year and won it again.  This was the race that Donald thought might have been her best ever simply because of the pressure that she was under to win it again.   When an athlete wins anything twice, the question of ‘three in a row’ raises its head – unfortunately for Sandra a third win was not on the cards because she was injured and could not compete.   However she continued to race in the championships and remained a valued team member.

EE SB 2

On the track, her standard of performance has been consistently high and her best times are also good.   These are shown on the table below – the road times are added to show the range covered in her early career and the times still stand as personal best performances.

Distance Date Venue Event Time
1500 July 1989 London UKWAL 4:35
3000 July 1989 Glasgow Scottish Championships 9:26
5000 June 1989 Jarrow UK Championships 16:08
10000 September 1989 Stoke WAAA 33:40
10K (Road) July 1987 Inverness Inverness 10K 33:36
10 Miles August 1989 Millport Round Cumbrae 54:36
Half-Marathon September 1988 Glasgow Great Scots Run 73:04*
Marathon April 1989 London London Marathon 2:35:03

(* The 72:22 from Ardrossan that appears on some ranking sites is an error.   My time that day was 77:22.   I have tried unsuccessfully several times to get this corrected.  SB)

She has run all over Britain and even further afield in her specialist track events and in all types of races – League Matches (in the Scottish Women’s League, the UK Women’s League, the UK League as presently constituted), Championships (Scottish and British), Masters/Veterans Championships (Scottish, British, European and World).   These track events have brought her some of her best moments in the sport and some of the worst too.   In the former category comes the National Track 3000 metres title in 1990.   She had been injured for quite a while beforehand and was lacking in confidence.   Any one of five women could have won the race and right at the start Annette Bell went off like a rocket and Sandra led the chasing pack.   They managed to close her down and with about 300 metres to go, Sandra picked the pace up a bit and got herself clear.  ‘ It wasn’t’, she says, ‘particularly fast (about 9:45) but as everyone would agree I don’t have much of a finish, it was quite a good run.’   Donald thinks it was possibly her best ever run.   Statistically she reckons her best run must be the W55 3000m record of 10:13.8 which has a score of 103.2% in the age graded tables.   It was also only 47 seconds slower than her personal best of July 1989.

As for the worst moment – well she is in no doubt about that!   “I was selected for a 3000m indoors in Athens which I think was a Small Nations International and it turned out to be the most brutal race I have ever experienced.   There was a lot of the usual shoving and pushing so I went to the front to try to stay out of trouble.   It was a temporary track and there was a drop of about five cm between the inside of the track and the floor of the arena and remember someone trying to push me off the track.   At one point a shoe went flying over my head!   When the bell went for the final lap, the others sprinted away (they were obviously used to this) and I finished scratched, battered and bruised.   I took a lot from this race and learned how to look after myself.

Unlike many who came into running via the mass marathons of the 80’s, Sandra has kept running and racing seriously and has now been competing on a very high level for over 25 years.    If there is any doubt about her continuing competitiveness or appetite for the sport, you only have to look at the table below.   It shows only her very best track results of the past five years.   Eleven first places and three seconds out of fourteen starts.   Some of the time she was injured or returning from injury: for example in 2010 she was not going to run because of time out but she went and passed on the 1500 metres because she was not fit enough to do that and the 5000 so settled for the 5000 – and won against the best that Europe had to offer.   But see for yourself.

Year Age Group Meeting Venue Event Place Time
2005 V50 British Masters   5K 12 18:15*
2006 V50 BMAF Championships   800 2 2:35.31
      1500 1 5:02.73
    European Masters Poznan 1500 1 4:57.22
    5000 1 18:18.3
2007 V50 World Masters Riccione 1500 SF 1 5:24.82
    1500 F 1 5:02.47
    5000 1 18:01.56
    10000 1 37:31.42
2008 V50
2009 V50 Scottish Masters Glasgow 800 2 2:36.0i
    1500 1 4:57.58
    World Masters Lahti 1500 1 4:58.52
    5000 1 18:38.82
2010 V55 European Masters Hungary 5000 1 19:55.63

*The 2005 time was in the BMAF 5K in Horwich and it was an age group record.

She even managed better times than some of those above in Seniors races at home: in the 3000 metres she ran 10:13.8 finishing third in a SWAL fixture, in the 5000 she ran 17:52.82 finishing sixth in teh SWAAA Championships at Pitreavie and in the 10000 she ran 37:09.27 at Bedford as a guest in the Sheila Fairweather Memorial

EE SB 3

Having established that Sandra Branney is a quality endurance athlete on track and country we should go back to her first events and what many regard as her best – road racing.  She has run in many races in all parts of Scotland from the north to the south and even off shore (in Millport on the Isle of Cumbrae).   The 10K races in the Polaroid series held every year in Clydebank, Dumbarton, Helensburgh and the Vale of Leven are among her favourites – especially the one in the Vale which is traditionally the last in the series with the biggest fields and best competition.    The picture above is from the Polaroid Race in the Vale in 2008 where she was fifth Woman and first in her category and she had the same position in the Dumbarton race.   However the flowers were for more than just two races in that single year – she has won the Women’s championship (which takes in all four races) no fewer than four times (1990, 1991, 1992 and 1996) and was first Lady Vet in 1993 and 2000.    She adds that she set a course record of 34:09 in 1992 which was broken only by Yvonne Murray whose time was only a few seconds quicker.  A quite remarkable record.

In half marathons, she has had no less distinguished a career with the top possibly being in a race she didn’t win.   In the Glasgow Half Marathon of 1998 there was a tough battle between three able and determined women for first place with Lorna Irving, Sandra and Sheila Catford battling it out for the first ten miles before Sheila moved away – not far but enough and Sandra took second place in 73:04.    She herself reckons that her best run might well have been the Balloch to Clydebank race when it was over a 12.25 mile course in 1988 in 67:27.   A non-standard distance these days her feeling is that it was worth about a 71:00 half marathon time.      And of course there are the UK rankings that can also be used to indicate the quality of her running.   The UK 10 Miles Championship that she won in 1988 in 55:32 is at number 71 in the UK All time rankings and the half marathon best has her at number 43 (although two lists have her at number 32 using the 72:22 time).

The first three marathons have already been covered (3:40 in Glasgow, ’84, 2:45 in Glasgow ’85 and 2:37:29 in 1986).   She went on to run in six countries on three Continents.    The first of the foreign races was in 1987 when she was selected, along with Fraser Clyne and Lindsay Robertson on the Men’s side, to represent Great Britain in the second World Marathon Cup which was to be held in Seoul over the course to be used in 1988 for the Olympic Games in 1988.   It was a long journey there – over 30 hours in all.   The teams had four men and four women and John Brown of the SAAA was going on a fact finding mission for the BAAB.   They did not travel directly to Korea – there was a four day stay  at the Nihon Aerobics Centre  south east of Tokyo and was to be used as a holding camp for Britain’s athletes for final training before the Games.   The set up was rather luxurious with swimming pools, jacuzzi, saunas, golf course, tennis courts and an outdoor 100 metre pool.   Their accommodation was in log cabins on the wooded hillside.   They then transferred to the Sheraton Walker Hill Hotel  in Seoul over looking the Han River.   The course for the race was straightforward with few if any difficult uphill sections.   Sandra finished twenty sixth in her first full marathon and her sixth marathon in all so far in 2:40:44 in a field of 78 runners.   The British team was fifth with Sally Ellis (18th) and Carolyn Naisby (22nd) the other counting runners.   Sandra remembers that it was cold (Fraser Clyne reports the temperature as being about 11 degrees), add in  problems adjusting to the time difference and she felt that she was struggling at the end.    Nevertheless she was third counter for the team and a reasonable run – after all the men could only manage eight team!   The Scottish team on the trip is in the picture below.

George Braidwood

EE GB 1

The photograph above is of George Braidwood winning (for the second time) one of the most popular and highest quality half marathons of the 1980’s: choreographed by the team of Hugh Barrow of Strathkelvin District Council and Victoria Park AAC and Alistair McFarlane of the Scottish Marathon Club and Springburn Harriers with a team of willing and very able helpers, the Luddon Half Marathon was not to be missed.  The SMC 12 miles road race had been going since the 1950’s but had fallen off in numbers until the Starthkelvin – SMC team got together with sponsors Luddon Construction and the race started anew in 1983 as the Luddon Half Marathon with 1600 runners.   It was won by Peter Fleming and George Braidwood of Bellahouston Harriers and then in 1984 George was the clear cut victor.    The SMC Magazine reported on the race as follows: “The race this year was blessed with fine weather and the field of just over 2000 set off from Woodhead Park in ndeal conditions.   The Police had again requested a 9:00 am start and although this does not help in bringing out spectators it must be conceded that it does assist in avoiding the traffic problems that were encountered during the Milngavie and Bearsden Half Marathon which was run at midday on a Saturday.   The quality up front was maintained with George Braidwood being this time undisputed winner leading home Terry Mitchell and Andy Daly in a course record of 64:44.   Martin Craven won the Veterans race in 70:05 finishing twelfth overall and Liz Steele took the Ladies event with 83:45 in 221st place overall.   Results:   1.   G Braidwood Bella) 64:44; 2.   T Mitchell (Fife)   64:57;   3.   A Daly (Bella)   65:26;   4.   G Laing (Aber)   65:32;   5.   P Fleming (Bella)   65:52;   6.   A Douglas (VPAAC)   65:58.”  

His career was inspired by seeing Lachie Stewart win in Edinburgh in 1970 and it inspired him to take up running at school.   Then he joined Bellahouston Harriers and he remebers that his first race was cross country on a snowy course in tennis shoes!   Nevertheless, he loved it and his career as an athlete started from there.   George was initially a very good 800 metre and 1500 metre runner and this speed showed at the end of many races – note how close Terry Mitchell was at the end..    George was a class act with a wide range of talent from 800 right up to the marathon and in July this year (2010) he completed the questionnaire as follows.

NAME: George Braidwood

Date of Birth:   03/12/59

CLUB:   Bellahouston Harriers and then Springburn Harriers.

OCCUPATION?   Dental Technician

LIST OF PERSONAL BESTS:   3000:   7:58;   5000:   14:01     Marathon:   2:21

HOW DID YOU GET INVOLVED IN THE SPORT ORIGINALLY?   Influenced by Lachie Stewart

HAS ANY INDIVIDUAL OR GROUP HAD A MARKED INFLUENCE ON EITHER YOUR ATTITUDE TO THE SPORT OR ON YOUR PERFORMANCES?   I trained and learned from Frank Clement and mostly working with Nat Muir’s training regime.

WHAT EXACTLY DID YOU GET OUT OF THE SPORT?   The buzz of racing!

CAN YOU DESCRIBE YOUR GENERAL ATTITUDE TO THE SPORT?   Pretty negative at the moment.   The strucrure has always been wrong for promising young talent.   There are too many drugs in the sport and it is hard to believe outstanding performances.

WHAT WAS YOUR BEST EVER PERFORMANCE?   Finishing second to Nat Muir in the Scottish Cross Country Championships.

AND YOUR WORST?   Beating Lasse Viren to second LAST in the World Cross Country Championships at Gateshead.

DID YOU ACHIEVE ALL YOUR GOALS OR WAS THERE SOMETHING THAT YOU THINK YOU MISSED OUT ON?   I missed out on a sub-4 minute mile, sub-14 minute 5000 and most of all not getting picked for the Edinburgh Commonwealth Games despite winning the Scottish 5000 metre Championship the year before.   I suppose picking officials over athletes was more important.

WHAT DID RUNNING BRING YOU THAT YOU WOULD NOT HAVE WANTED TO MISS?   Countries visited, meeting and beating/losing against other athletes, World Cross Country Championships; Alex Naylor training group at Coatbridge during the Coe and Ovett era; training with some great characters too many to mention including my friend and rival Adrian Callan who suffered a disgraceful omission by the selectors for the Edinburgh Commonwealth Games.

COULD YOU GIVE SOME DETAILS OF YOUR TRAINING AND/OR YOUR TRAINING PHILOSOPHY?   Winter average was 90+ miles per week including two fast long sessions and Sunday long run.   Summer average was 80+ miles per week including three track sessions.   Taper down for Championships.   I liked to train hard and not let on!

EE GB 2

So there you have it and I’ll comment on some of the replies over the next couple of paragraphs.   Let’s take the big one first and the big one for me is the non-selection for the 1986 Commonwealth Games which was indeed a fiasco as far as many of the runners were concerned.  Selection of the team was a disgrace.    Adrian Callan (Springburn Harriers) was a sub-four minute miler who had won the SAAA 1500 metres that year.   He had been assured by a prominent figure in the establishment that he would be selected if he won the championship no matter what the time.   He won and was not selected with the man in question denying that he had said anything at all.  Adrian was one of the nicest guys I have ever met in over 50 years in the sport and he was really upset.   He asked me (I was Scottish Staff Coach for 5000/1000 at the time) if I would take the Championship Trophy back – I refused, selections were not my responsibility but suggested that he return it to the President of the SAAA who lived near him.   This he did.   Adrian was the worst example but others such as George were entitled to feel really aggrieved.   Many athletes, parents and coaches had their attitudes to the sport soured at that time.   Very good athletes were not selected, good athletes were selected for events that were not their best ones and I know of two endurance athletes – one living in Glasgow and one in Edinburgh – who offered to pay for their own kit and live at home rather than in the Village to save money.   But even although there were places available in the events in question, their offers were turned down.

Back to the questionnaire, this time for cross country.   George was no newcomer to the sport when he finished second to Nat Muir in the National Cross Country Championship at the Jack Kane Centre in Edinburgh in 1983.   One of the famous very good group of Bellahouston Harriers he had won the Midland District Senior Boys Cross Country Championships away back in 1975 and won many medals on the track and over the country individually and as part of a team.   He ran for the Scottish team in the International Cross Country Championships in 1983, 1984 and 1985.   In 1982/83 he had already won the West District Senior Championships before Nat Muir defeated him by a mere six seconds in the Nationals with Fraser Clyne of Aberdeen another 12 seconds adrift.   In 1984/85 he anchored the Bellahouston team to second in the West District relays finishing only one second in front of Kilbarchan.   He started 1985 well by winning the Nigel Barge Road Race in Maryhill by one second from Graham Laing of Aberdeen.   George was a handy man if there was a sprint finish whether on road, track or country!   In the International at Cumbernauld he was second but led the Scottish team to victory.   The Bellahouston team of which he was a member won the McAndrew, Scally and National Six Stage Relays.    He went on running and racing well and in 1988 won silver in the Six Stage with a sparkling run – but for Springburn Harriers with Bellahouston in third place.   He had changed clubs about three months earlier and living in Bishopbriggs, it made sense to move to the local club.

On the track, his list of road and track pb’s is more modest than it need be!    My own opinion is that 1985 was probably his best year for track running with 3:48.71 for 1500 metres, 7:58.83 for 3000 metres and 14:01.17 to be second fastest Scot for the distance. The 5000 metres time was set winning the SAAA 5000 metres title.    I know that he was a very good 800 metre runner because he ran in several invitation races over the distance that I put on and was certainly worth better than his personal best of 1:52.

Having reported on his second Luddon win above, it seems appropriate to do the same for his first run in the event.   The report in the SMC Magazine by Alistair McFarlane is below.

“Despite the late call-offs by Graham Laing (saving himself for the European Cup Marathon in Spain two weeks later) and Colin Youngson (not wishing to risk a niggling injury 3 weeks before the Scottish), the field was of a quality seldom seen in Scotland.   The first mile was covered by the leaders in 4:55 and at 5 miles, just before Milton of Campsie, there was still a big group of Donald McGregor, Rod Stone, Peter Fleming, George Braidwood, Evan Cameron, Stuart Easton, Jim Martin, Dave Logue and Andy Daly in 25:50.  

This was obviously a bit slow for Andy Daly however as he stretched them out soon afterwards and took his two clubmates Fleming and Braidwood away from the pack.   Andy however couldn’t sustain it and allowed a gap to open around 8 miles.   Peter Fleming and George Braidwood looked relaxed as they went through the ten miles in 50 minutes dead with Andy now running a brave race all on his own and keeping the gap steady.   Logue, Easton, Stone and McGregor showed 50:30 at 10 miles as they staged their own private race while Terry Mitchell, Alan Wilson and Evan Cameron were close behind in 50:40.   Over the last three miles past Low Moss Prison to Lenzie and on to the finish at Woodhead Park, Kirkintilloch, the two leaders obviously did some talking and decided to finish together in the very fast time for the accurately measured course of 65:23, although the judges split them on the line.   Andy Daly took advantage of some slackening of the pace up front to close a little and got the gap down to 8 seconds at the finish.   Dave Logue shrugged off his challengers and looked strong as ever in fourth place while Stuart Easton had his best run for many a day to get the better of Rod Stone and Donald McGregor who of course lifted the first veteran’s prize of £40.   Janet McColl for once had some opposition in a road race although she made light of it to beat Liz Steele by 3 minutes.

Of the 1163 finishers, 195 were veterans and 112 were women.”

He ran many road races and ran well in them all.   Like all Scottish club runners of the time he did of course turn out in the Edinburgh to Glasgow for both the clubs he ran for.   He was unfortunate that in his first run in the event in 1977 he was asked to race the second stage which is very demanding for a first year Junior: he dropped from first to twelfth in a time of 31:46.   Most of his races were on this stage and his best run was probably 1982 when he was second fastest on the stage with 29:12.   The following year though he was third fastest on the fifth stage running in second position to see the young Bellahouston team finish second and pick up the silver medals.   In 1984 he was back on the second stage and running the second fastest time to move the club from fifteenth up an amazing ten places to fifth and in 1985 he was first on the first stage of the race.   After joining Springburn he ran in two E-G Relays (in 1991 and 1992)where he ran well: in ’91 he moved the team from 19th to 14th on the second stage and in ’92 he was sixth on the first leg.

George was always a good road runner – one of the best and he could have been an outstanding marathon man had he come to the event earlier.   He only ever ran the one marathon and that was late in his running career.   He recorded 2:21:27 in his first and only attempt at the distance in Glasgow where he finished tenth in a good field.   He reckons he would have liked to run in London but after 1987 the pressures of business got in the way.   We have looked at his performances on the country and they were excellent, we have looked at his performances on the track where he set first rate times and won a Senior Men’s Scottish championship in an era that was very good for endurance running in Scotland, we have looked at his running in the Edinburgh to Glasgow and in the two Luddon Half Marathons.   His range of talent was so wide that he could have excelled as a pure track runner had he concentrated on that, he could have really excelled as a marathon runner had he turned in that direction early in his career.   Where many are pushed in one direction or the other by restrictions on their ability, it was maybe the case that George had too many options open to him!

 

I have mentioned already the Bellahouston Harriers group of which he was a member and with whom he had grown up.   The table below indicates the range of and depth of talent in the squad.   I should note that the 10000m is track running and I would dearly love more information about Graeme Getty’s performances other than marathon.

Name 800m 1500m 3000m 5000m 10000m Half Marathon Marathon
G Braidwood 1:52 3:48 7:58 14:01 64:00 2:21:27
T Coyne 3:51 8:24 14:36 30:20 67:00 2:19:16
A Daly 14:44 65:13 2:15:47
P Fleming 4:02 8:19 13:51 30:10 62:52 2:13:35
G Getty 2:19:34

His thoughts on why the Bellahouston group was so good with so many men under 2:30 for the marathon are simply that it was a good era to be running distance races and that there was a healthy competition in the club.   He always liked to race on Saturdays and so Sundays became a long recovery run of 17 –  18 miles in good company.

Ian Binnie

EE IB 1

Ian Binnie was one of Scotland’s greatest ever distance runners.    He didn’t like cross-country although he was part of the great Victoria Park Cross Country team that won all there was to win in the 1950’s and twice represented Scotland in the ICCU Cross Country International.   He really excelled on the track and on the roads.   Unusually no one to my knowledge ever said that he should have tried the marathon although it is a common enough remark about most talented road runners.    It was probably realised that he was such a real gem in the longer middle distance races as we will see and he was appreciated for what he was.  He knew how good he was and times came across as arrogant but he knew his own mind.   He always kept his word – on the occasion when he ran his superb one hour run at Cowal, he was phoned at home on the Wednesday before the race by Jack Crump of the AAA’s telling him he had been chosen to run for Britain on Saturday at the White City.   he told Mr Crump politely that he couldn’t do it because he was running at Cowal Games that weekend.   Crump was furious that he had turned down a GB vest! More of that below but he told me the story himself.    He was easily recognised as he ran in the streets and roads around the West End of Glasgow and Dunbartonshire – in summer along the Great Western Road Boulevard with no vest or T shirt, the tan testifying to the amount of running done in that fashion, in winter he wore the VPAAC vest and I even remember seeing him running a la Gordon Pirie in working boots.   The last race I personally saw him run was a Three Miles at Scotstoun well after his best days and he broke away with Alex Brown of Motherwell YMCA.   Alex was leading and after seven or eight laps, still within a yard or two of Alex, he stepped off the track.    He wasn’t going to have a time as slow as he thought that was going to be recorded.   A loyal Vickie Parker he made several disparaging remarks about most clubs but particularly about local rivals Clydesdale Harriers – but in the mid 1990’s, when Clydesdale were running much better than VPAAC, he took time to come and speak to some of the CH runners in the Kelvin Hall: sitting on the floor in the gallery with six or seven young athletes (mid twenties) he talked about training and racing for over half an hour.   My first encounter with him was when four Clydesdale Harriers were having a meal at the old Whitehall Restaurant in Glasgow one Saturday night when another four guys came in and immediately the two tables were involved in banter throughout the meal.  I had just joined the club and was there with Johnny Maclachlan and Neil Buchanan and some other guy and the four at the other table included Binnie and Albie Smith.   It was an interesting evening.

There are many stories about him – for instance the fact that the rules for the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay were changed twice because of him.   One time he handed the baton to a small boy on a bike to carry while he ran, only taking it back in time for the changeover.   The rules were amended to state that ‘the baton must be carried’.   Fine, he then had a pocket sewn into his vest where he stowed the baton until hand-over time.   The rules were altered again to ‘the baton must be carried (ie in the hand).    There was the year when he took the E-G trophy back with a knitted VPAAC vest on it because they were going to retain the trophy and he wanted it properly dressed.   At another time he didn’t bother to bring a trophy because they were going to win it again! Anyway, we can start here with a contribution from club-mates of his – Hugh Barrow and finish with the obituary written by Doug Gillon in 1997.   The picture below shows Binnie running with the best in the world.

Binnie withthe Best

In 1985 Hugh Barrow wrote a tribute to him in the Scottish Marathon Club magazine and it is reproduced below.

Ian Binnie  –  Scotland’s Zatopek

By Hugh Barrow

Ian Binnie, of whom it was once allegedly said by Jack Crump “He looks like a swede but runs like a turnip.”

One of my earliest memories of the time that I joined Victoria Park in the late 1950’s was of this most enigmatic of runners, Ian Binnie.   Bin, as he was called by the other runners, had an approach to training similar to the attitudes to be adopted later by David Bedford.   Ian worked on the premise that you did more than your rivals and you did it faster.   At a time when most Scottish distance runners would train three or four times each week plus a Saturday race, Ian Binnie would train at times three times each day and these sessions were not done at what could be described as anything approaching easy running.   His idol had been Emil Zatopek and he modelled his methods on the same prodigious amounts of work.   When Ian had completed his evening track sessions eg 20/30 times 300 some body might question him about the fact that he had also been seen out at lunch times, but back came the reply that these sessions did not really count.   Always secretive about his training it is now sometimes difficult to distinguish fact from legend but what cannot be disputed is that Ian Binnie trained at a cruel level even by present day standards.

He set himself very high standards, some might have said unattainable standards, but that was the measure of the man.   He wanted to hold every Scottish Record from the mile to the marathon and he only failed by these two.   Possibly his finest run was in 1953 against Gordon Pirie at the White City, London, on the night that Pirie broke the World Record for Six Miles.   Ian recorded 28 minutes 53 seconds and how many Scots would today beat that time.   He only knew one way to run and that was from the front, often setting a suicidal pace.   His critics often drew attention to this and his lack of finishing speed just as the same people criticise Ron Clarke and Dave Bedford but they could not criticise his courage.

he was a member of the very successful Victoria Park teams of the 1950’s, a team that won the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay on eight occasions, the first Scottish club to win the English National Cross-Country Championships (only Shettleston Harriers have emulated this performance) and came third in the London – Brighton Relay.   Never keen on Cross Country running, Ian put in many brilliant Road Relay legs  against such as Joe McGhee of Shettleston and Joe Connolly and Harry Fenion of Bellahouston.

The records speak for themselves but to a young hopeful it was more the way he went about his running that remains in the memory.   On asking advice one evening, the reply came back, “If you can’t keep up, don’t come out!”   On reflecting back now over some twenty five years of running, that advice still seems quite sound.

IAN BINNIE’S SCOTTISH RECORDS

YEAR DISTANCE TIME/DISTANCE
1952 5 Miles 24:59
6 Miles 30:04
1953 2 Miles 8:58.4
3 Miles 14:01.4
4 Miles 19:28
5 Miles 24:24
6 Miles 29:20.7
7 Miles 36:01.8
8 Miles 40:01.8
9 Miles 45:05
10 Miles 50:11
11 Miles 55:24.2
12 Miles 60:34.2
1 Hour Run 11 Miles 1575 Yards
1954 3 Miles 14:02
4 Miles 19:15.4
5 Miles 24:12.1
6 Miles 29:01.9
1955 3 Miles 13:54.8
1957 3 Miles 13:51.2
1958 2 Miles 8:57.2

 

The comment at the end of the article to the aspiring runner is similar to some of Alastair Wood’s in Aberdeen (Do yourself a favour, go to the pictures) and Binnie was famous for such retorts: “No matter how much you polish a bit of wally glass you’ll never make it into a diamond” for instance and his “Sorry Mr Crump, I’m running at Cowal Games on Saturday!”  was a bit of lèse-majesté!   Remember that these times were run on cinder tracks and without all the improvements in kit – shoes in particular – that modern runners have.   In addition the SAAA Championships ran the 6 Miles on the Friday night and the 3 Miles on the Saturday afternoon.   So no time trials with pace makers at selected venues: in these circumstances, how would his times stand up 50 years later?   Well in the Scottish Rankings for 2008, he would have been placed fourth in the 5000 metres and first in the 10000 metres.   As David Coleman might have said, “Quite remarkable really!”   The best source of day-to-day information is ‘The Scots Athlete’ and I’ll be quoting liberally from that but first let’s look at his career chronologically.

‘The Scots Athlete’ first mentions him in the results of the Dundee Kingsway Relay and the McAndrew Relays in autumn 1950: he ran first leg in the McAndrew Relays under the name of G Binnie and had third fastest time of the afternoon; two weeks later he was in the Kingsway Relay for the A Team and finished third in the second fastest club time and fifth fastest overall but was listed as J Binnie.   In November he ran in the Edinburgh to Glasgow where he was on the first stage again and finished fourth but the comments on the winning eight said of him: “one of the up-and-coming youngsters of the team, and one who has shown distinct promise over country, road and on the track.   Joining the club just last winter he is one of this year’s winning ‘four’ in the McAndrew and Kingsway Relays.   A leading member of the club’s successful 2 miles track team last summer.   Keen and conscientious in training, Ian will go far in the sport.”   Not a lot more was written and  he did not run in the National at Hamilton where his club won the title.   Summer 1951 saw him win his first championship medal with a third place in the SAAA 3 Miles behind Andy Forbes (14:28.8) and Tommy Tracey (14:47.1) with Binnie timed at 15:5.6 – there were many comments about the heavy nature of the wet track and how it slowed all the times on the day.   The ‘Scots Athlete’ ranked him fourth in their 3 Miles ranking list behind Forbes (VP), Tracey (Springburn) and AT Ferguson (Highgate).

The following winter he had another good run in the McAndrews on the first stage for the winning team and then in the Edinburgh to Glasgow he won the first stage with a huge gap – 26:55 to 27:49 over Andy Brown of Motherwell.   Emmett Farrell had this to say in his ‘Running Commentary’ of January 1952 after the Nigel Barge Road Race where he was second and only ten seconds down (24:48 to 24:58) on Andy Forbes: “Binnie whose performance in beating Tracey (third in 25:13) was brilliant, is perhaps reaping the dividend of his sustained consistent training.   Zatopek appears to be the model of the young Victoria Park man who runs often and long in the slow fast tempo popularised by the great Czech.   At the moment Binnie does not relish cross country regarding which he has a complex: but he is building up to have a real go at the three and six miles track distance later.   It will be interesting ti see how he comports himself in the summer.”   Complex?   Maybe – he avoided the Midland Championship but when the Scottish Championships took place on 1st March at Hamilton Racecourse, he was seventh finisher and second club man behind Andy Forbes (fourth) in the winning team.   In 1951 Shettleston Harriers had been runners up in the English Cross country championship after being only second to Victoria Park in the Scottish, so in 1952 the Scotstoun club decided to go down to the event to be held in Birmingham.   In short, they went, they saw, they conquered!   They won with 241 points against Bolton United Harriers 255.   The team captain Andy Forbes knew full well the value of speed in cross country running and had particular knowledge of the very fast start at the English National.   So every Sunday they trained at Mountblow Recreation Ground in Clydebank – the home of Clydesdale Harriers at that time.   The venue had a 330 yards red blaes track but the grass perimeter was just over a half mile of mainly good but heavy grass running.    And they did fast half mile reps.   The result was that they coped well with the ‘blitz’ start and finishing positions were Forbes 11, Jimmy Ellis 32, Binnie 41, Chick Forbes 51, Ronnie Kane 52 and Johnny Stirling 54.   There are some comments on the economics of the trip below.   Ian Binnie was selected for the International Cross Country team that year and finished 62nd and out of the counting team runners.

The British winning team

EE IB 2

Bobby Calderwood, Ronnie Kane, Ian Binnie, Donald Henson, Alex Breckenridge behind

Johnny Stirling, Andy Forbes, Chick Forbes and Jimmy Ellis in front

In the Six Miles at the SAAA Championships in June 1952, on a bitterly cold and windy Friday night he won the Six Miles which was reported as follows: “Undismayed by a leg injury acquired in training, which was well strapped, Binnie from the gun was out for a new record.   At 5 Miles with 24:59 he had a new Native record (prev. 25:12), but this went unnoticed by all present and at 6 Miles swamped JF Wood’s other Native Record 0f 30:34 with 30:04.2.   In the Three Miles on the Saturday he was third behind Forbes and Eddie Bannon of Shettleston in 15:9.1.   In August Emmet Farrell, said: “Ian Binnie, our six miles champion and record-holder looks the best prospect of our distance track men.   He has his own ideas of training, modelling himself somewhat on the lines of a miniature Zatopek and has even been known to run 12 miles on the day before a race.   With added strength and confidence there is no saying to what heights he may aspire.   He has his eye on Peter Allwell’s Native Record at two miles of 9:13 odds.   After seeing Binnie do a 9:24 recently on a loose track with ease he wouldn’t be far away on say the Helenvale track where the present figures were made.”    He finished the season fourth in the Three Miles and top of the Six.

Season 1952-53 for Binnie was maybe his best ever.   The winter season started without him in the McAndrew Relay and he did not turn out either in the Midlands Relay Championship.   Came the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay and VPAAC were again the winners and this Time Binnie was on the sicth stage head-to-head with Eddie Bannon of Shettleston and he was only three seconds quicker st the end – 33:37 to 33:40.    Emmet Farrell had this to say of the race: “Perhaps the finest intrinsic running was that of Ian Binnie’s 33:37 and Eddie Bannon’s 33:40 in the long seven miles stage.  Binnie’s time was only five seconds outside Jim Flockhart’s remarkable 1937 record.”   In February Binnie turned out in the Midland Championship where he was twenty fourth and last counter in the winning Victoria Park team.   On 28th February he ran in the National Championships at Hamilton Racecourse he was eighth and second VP runner with Andy Forbes second.

Previewing the 1953 track season the ‘Running Commentary’ had this to say: “The Three and Six Miles Records May Go.”   As I see it Andy Forbes should retain his Three Miles title and clubmate Ian Binnie his Six Miles, both in fast time.   Forbes still has the flair for the big occasion and if he has to be beaten then it will possibly take a time inside his own great record of 14:18.2.   Binnie, now training more often, further and harder than ever and already this season shown top condition and versatility with class 3 mile track and 15 mile road race wins would be most disappointed not to well beat 30 minutes for the 6 miles and eradicate the 30:04.2 record figures he established last year in windy conditions.   Binnie of course may try for the double but this is a very difficult feat unless the athlete is extremely robust and possessed of exceptional recuperative powers.”      Well, Binnie clearly had robustness and recuperative powers!    In the first paragraph of his report on the athletics, Emmett Farrell said :”Ian Binnie’s double victory in the 3 and 6 miles championships and his seven records made in these two races must surely win him the Crabbie Cup for the most meritorious performer.”   For the race:  “Running De Luxe.   The 3 Mile event was the piece de resistance of the meeting,   Ian Binnie displayed a brand of distance running rarely seen in Scotland.   After two or three laps during which Black shadowed him he was out on his own showing devastating sustained speed down the straights his artistic striding being a sheer delight to the eye.   First mile was reeled off in 4:33.3.   The two-mile stage took 9:16.8 and the tape was broken in 14:0.,4 for a new native and all-comer’s record thus displacing respectively the figures of club mate Forbes and Maki of Finland.”   The winning time in the Six Miles was 29:20.7 for new native and all-comer’s records as well.   Two weeks later it was the AAA’s Championships and John Keddie, in his official history of the SAAA, describes the race thus.  A fortnight later at the White City he went even better at the AAA Championship where his own front runing set the pace for a marvellous World Record by Gordon Pirie.   Pirie’s time was 28:19.4 and behind him Binnie finished a meritorious third with a superb 28:53.4, ever to remain his besr performance for the distance.”

For many however the one hour run at Cowal Highland Games was the highlight not only of the year but of his running career.   ‘The Scots Athlete’ again.

Scottish Native and All-comer’s and British National and All-comer’s Records fall like ninepins to 22 year-old Scot Ian Binnie

At half past two on Friday 28th August at Cowal Stadium track, Dunoon, Argyllshire on the first day of the famous two-day Cowal Highland Games, five competitors lined up for the start of a one hour run – the main purpose of which being to give the Scottish distance runner Ian Binnie of Victoria Park AACan opportunity of attacking the Scottish and British records.   Binnie’s running turned out to be one of the greatest athletic performances ever seen in Scotland.   At each stage from and including 7 miles – 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12 miles and one hour he recorded faster than all previous native and all-comer’s bests in the British Isles and the Empire.

He had to contend with a stiff breeze and though the track was in excellent condition Ian felt the effect of the black coal-dust top cutting up and did not think it was as firm as the White City track.   he commented on being very badly stitched at around the 4 miles stage and feeling like retiring.   His 10 miles time, 50:11, was superb.   It broke the British All-comer’s record 50:30.8 standing to the name of Bill Eaton (1936) and far superseded that of any native Scot.   He went on to increase the British all-comer’s 1 hour record of Alfred Shrubb (1904) by 435 yards to 11 miles 1571 yards and continued to 12 miles which he reached in 60:34.2 beating the previous British best 62:43 created by S Thomas at Herne Hill in 1892.

Though Ian was pleased enough with his collection of records it was typical of him to express his disappointment at not covering 12 miles inside the hour which was his personal target.   he now holds every Scottish record from 2 to 12 miles.   We give his times at each mile stage along with those of Shrubb who established his in a similar race in 1904.   The performances shown recorded by Shrubb were the standing British all-comer’s marks.

Mile Binnie Shrubb
1 4:53 4:44
2 9:50 9:44
3 14:51 14:45
4 19:54 19:50.6
5 24:57 24:55
6 30:01 29:59.4
7 35:1.8 35:04.6
8 40:01.8 40:16
9 45:05 45:27.6
10 50:11 50:40.6
11 55:24.2 56:23.4
12 60:34.2

It is not at all surprising that he was named ‘Scots Athlete of the Year.”

The 1953-54 season started as usual with the McAndrew Relays at Scotstoun.   Home team Victoria Park won their 12 miles relay with a record time of 62:43 which was 55 seconds inside the existing record while Binie broke Eddie Bannon’s individual record which was only half an hour old by six seconds with 15:01.   “Emmet Farrell again – “they also easily retained the Dundee Kingsway Relay Trophy finishing first and second teams.   By all-round work they had a sound enough win in the Edinburgh-Glasgow Relay although special mention must be made of young Norrie Ellis who built up a winning lead in the 4th stage and of Ian Binnie’s record-breaking sixth stage knocking 11 seconds off Jim Flockhart’s time set in 1937.   They suffered their only defeat on their only cross country outing so far (December 1953) – the Midland Relay at the hands of close rivals Shettleston Harriers.   Starting almost on level terms over the last two and a half mile stage, Ian Binnie was no match for international star Eddy Bannon.   Just as Binnie dominates and is such a tower of strength to his club on track and road, so Bannon is for his club on the country.”   So no mention of a ‘complex’ by now and in the preview of the National Cross-Country Championships in 1954, Emmet Farrell lists his contenders and outsiders without mentioning Binnie and then comes “The Position of Binnie:   I did not discuss Binnie’s prospects for the simple reason that the Victoria Park crack is allegedly not interested in selection for the International and may prefer to make a sterner bid in the English National a week hence.   Yet he is keen to help his club to another National team title and if he does not rate as Bannon’s chief rival for the title he should easily find a place in the top six.”   Binnie had not run in the District Championships where his club was again victorious.  Well, Binnie did run in the National but he did not ‘easily find a place in the top six.’   He did not even find a place in the VPAAC top six – he was thirty ninth and seventh club finisher in a race where Shettleston Harriers won by 23 points.

In the June issue of the ‘Scots Athlete’ there is a preview of the up-coming Scottish Championships with a section headed “Can Binnie Retain His Two Titles?”   Which goes on “Last year Ian Binnie literally ran away with both 6 miles and 3 miles and of course set up native and all-comer’s records in the process.   His recent form has been erratic and somewhat disappointing.   His hour run while good enough was not the Binnie standard and the Victoria Park crack is not regarded as certain to win both titles.   I find it difficult to oppose this mercurial but brilliant runner who by the time of the championships may have recaptured some of last year’s effervescence.   In the 6 Miles I see little opposition if Binnie is in good form.   Harry Fenion who is running well and Hamilton Laurence of Teviotdale should take place positions.   Binnie may have a harder task to retain his 3 mile title.   Chief opposition may come from little John Stevenson of Greenock Wellpark who has been showing excellent form over 1 and 2 miles.   Other likely candidates are Eddie Bannon, our cross country champion, Alex Black, now at Dundee, Springburn’s Tommy Tracey and Englishman Adrian Jackson.   If they are all lined up at the start what a thriller it will be all the way.”   The Scottish rankings at the beginning of May that year had Binnie second in the 3 miles with a time of 14:17.1 against John Stevenson’s 14:13.4 – Stevenson also topped the Mile list with 4:25.6.   Came the championships with the 6 miles as usual on the Friday night.   “Wintry conditions prevailed.   Ian Binnie was in great form for though admitting after the race to being continually blown off the track when against the wind he broke his own native record (19:28) and Paavo Nurmi’s 1931 all comer’s mark (19:20.4) at 4 miles and his own all-comer’s records (24:24.1 and 29:20.7) at 5 and 6 miles.   It was a superb effort.”   He also won the 3 Miles in 14:19.6 from Eddie Bannon (14:33.6) in a field of 20 runners.    By the end of June he led the rankings at 2 Miles (9:11), 3 Miles (14:04), 6 Miles (29:20.7).   As a result of his two wins he was selected for the Empire Games in Vancouver where every event was overshadowed by the Jim Peter marathon (see Vancouver 54 elsewhere on this website) and the Bannister/Landy Mile.   However Binnie was selected for both Three and Six Miles and competed in both.   There was very little coverage but he was seventh in the Three Miles in 13:59.6 and sixth in the Six Miles in 30:15.2.   The Three Miles time made him the first Scot under 14 minutes for the distance.

The 1954-55 season  saw a change in the usual pattern when Shettleston Harriers won after five years of Victoria Park triumphs.   Binnie started off on the last lap behind Joe McGhee and although he ran a brilliant new record of 14:58 for the course he could not catch McGhee who only ran 15:33.   The pattern of recent years had changed to such an extent that Shettleston were first, third and fourth!   In the Midland Relays, the result was the same with Binnie running 16:51 for the first lap.   However when the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay was run, Victoria Park again triumphed for the fifth successive year and with a new course record and Binnie set a record of 33:21 for the sixth stage where Joe McGhee was second quickest with 33:51.   He turned out for his club again in the Midland District Championships where they were second to Shettleston and Binnie was thirty first and fifth club runner.   The team result in the National – again at Hamilton – was the same despite Donald Henson of VP winning and Binnie finishing fourth – his highest ever in the National.

In the annual preview of the SAAA Championships in the June ‘Scots Athlete’, the headline wasIan Binnie hot “Double” Favourite.   The article read: After his brilliant 3 miles of 13:54.8 at Ibrox, Ian Binnie looks set to retain both 3 and 6 Miles titles.   Despite being unable to hold his killing opening pace and fading somewhat, Binnie must be congratulated on his wonderful time and after all, only Dunkley passed him on his way to the tape.   He kept his promise of running the race of his life though doubts concerning his tactics still prevail.   Modern standards are emphasised by realising that Binnie’s time was practically identical with that of Sydney Wooderson’s in his famous classic with Willie Slikhuis in 1946, and Dunkley best known as a miler did his 13:50.3 3 miles as an experiment and may try for top honours in the steeplechase because the mile and 3 mile fields are over-crowded with brilliant exponents.   

The report of the Championships said that Binnie won both races ‘creditably enough’ although not up to his usual standard but praised Andy Brown for pressing hard in both races and emerging with two second places.   The report on the 6 miles started as per usual by commenting on the windy Friday night for the race.   A fast start saw the one mile in 4:32 with Brown following closely but he was shaken off during the second mile (9:17.4) at which point the pace slackened with Ian winning in 29:40.4.

Victoria Park regained the McAndrew Trophy in October 1955 taking 15 seconds from the record for the race and Binnie?   Well the report was that where Binnie gave Joe McGhee a start on the last leg again, this time he was closed down very quickly and Binnie brought the club home victorious.   Binnie was 15:02 and McGhee 15:32 and the club difference was only 5 seconds!   Shettleston got their own back when they won both Midlands Relay and the Edinburgh to Glasgow.   In the Midland Relays the Victoria Park A Team could only finish seventh with Ian Binnie running second  and his run in the ‘News of the World’ was ‘non-vintage Binnie’ although he did have the second fastest time only seven seconds behind Bannon.  Bannon was 33:50 with Binnie 33:57.

In the annual Morpeth to Newcastle race Ian was fifth after leading for most of the way.   Emmet Farrell reported that it was ‘definitely not Binnie at his brightest’.   Binnie missed the Midlands Championships where VP were fifth despite John McLaren winning the race.    He was back in cross-country mode for the National where his club won from Shettleston and Binnie was eleventh.

Then in the ‘Scots Athlete’ of August 1956 – when he had already run 9:06.2 for 2 miles on 5th May and 13:58.9 for 3 Miles on 12th May, came the bombshell:   “Ian Binnie’s retirement from athletics, temporary or permanent as yet unknown, has been the recent Scottish talking point.   An erratic, controversial figure, Binnie could be brilliant.   Nevertheless repeated errors in judgement and a preference to race against the watch rather than against the man, lessened his competitive ability.   Nevertheless with Zatopek-like zeal in training and his uninhibited contempt for existing Scottish standards he materially assisted in establishing the new athletic deal north of the border.   With little interest in cross-country but brilliant on track and devastating on the road there is a whisper that he may make  a come back in road races.   His club will miss him as anchor man in the big relays and Scottish running will be the poorer without his great ability.   Let’s not hope that this is Binnie’s athletic epitaph.”

The answer came three months later when the cover picture of the magazine had Ian picture with the caption: After a record run leg in the VP Road Relay, Ian Binnie finishing for Victoria Park AAC who won with a new course record.”      Ian’s own run on the last leg against Graham Everett of Shettleston saw him start with a lead and set off in ‘his usual hurricane fashion’ but Everett had no intention of letting him go and by one mile, had the lead down to five yards but with a mile to go Binnie was moving away again and although Everett came back at him, Binnie moved away and won with a record time.   Then in November VPAAC won their sixth Edinburgh to Glasgow and Binnie on the sixth stage had the fastest time by just over a minute but was well outside his own record time ( 33:20 v 32:32.).   He turned out for the club in the National Cross-Country where he finished fourteenth for the team which won with 93 points against Bellahouston’s 125.

In the summer of 1958 he became the first Scot to run inside 14 minutes for the Three Miles when he won the Scottish Championship in 13:57.6 and that was to be his last championship and his last record.    He went on running until into the twenty first century but there was very little racing in there after 1958 although he was an easily recognisable figure running along the Great Western Road with his vest squashed up in his hand.   His interest in the sport never waned – when the Kelvin Hall had its track relaid in the early 2000’s he took some of the off cuts to examine them and we discussed the composition of the track.   We had a chat one afternoon at the side of the road at the start of the McAndrew Relay where he had been such a star – and nobody interrupted us – no one recognised the spare, fit figure with the rucksack watching his club running round the familiar roads of Scotstoun.

Stories of his training are legion but what were the influences?   It’s difficult to find out but Hugh Barrow says that he was in contact with Franz Stampfl and Gordon Pirie – and it doesn’t take a long look to see something of Pirie in his attitudes.   Apparently he tried to make contact with Zatopek but in the days f the ‘Cold War’ it is not clear whether he was successful

*****

Colin Youngson of Aberdeen who ran with Victoria Park in the early 1970’s recalls that ‘Bin’ as he was known went out with the Victoria Park fast pack in the 1971-72 period “He would have been about 42 or 44 then.   He would not run away from us ( Pat McLagan, Alistair Johnstone,  Hugh Barrow, Albie Smith, young Dave McMeekin and I were hard to run away from) but certainly had no difficulty in keeping up or taking the pace, as we zoomed past the slow pack and into the non-wisecracking section of the brisk Tuesday or Thursday night 5 or 6 mile run round Knightswood, etc, in the dark.   He did drawl these condescending put-downs, particularly about Pat who was a good runner.   I guess for Bin it was a fairly justified superiority complex, and partly a slightly cruel joke, more subtle than Albie’s crushing comments!   We really did beg Bin to consent to inclusion in our very good E-G team, but he was not moved.   I suppose he had been numero uno and would not race below his best, even if he was helluva fit for a 42 year old and would have thoroughly justified his inclusion in the team.”   Colin then reflected “Binnie and Ally Wood!   What a pair!   To some extent they made me the callous joker that I remain today – certainly a good toughening up process for a secondary school teacher!”     

Colin has many good tales about ‘Bin’.   Elsewhere on this website (the E-G Section) Colin’s Edinburgh to Glasgow memories are printed in detail but I’ll quote the Binnie bits again here.   “Vague rumours of legendary deeds had reached my ears – mainly concerning the tussles on the ‘long leg’ between Joe McGhee (Empire Games marathon Gold medallist) and that uniquely relaxed character with the elitist attitude, Ian Binnie of Victoria Park.   According to Binnie he could give poor Joe several minutes start and still pass him before the finish.   I never heard Joe’s side of the story, but as Binnie never tired of telling newcomers to the Vicky Park team, “It’s hard to motivate myself, lad.   After all I have SEVEN gold medals already.”   Binnie’s best known comment (to a younger team-mate who was a deserving Scottish cross-country international) was “Ach, Pat, it disny matter how many vests you win, you’ll never have any class.   You see, a GREAT runner is always a GREAT runner  – and a DUMPLIN’ is always a DUMPLIN’.”    

Another Binnie quote was to a runner preparing to ‘sprint’ for the line in a relay, “Hamish, you’re wastin’ your time.   Cut your losses – sell your kit!”

****

When he died in 2007, Doug Gillon, who had been a runner for the same club at one time wrote the following obituary in the Glasgow Herald on 4th August 2007.

IAN BINNIE

Athlete:: born July 15th 1929; died July 26th 2007.    Ian Binnie who has died suddenly aged 78 was the greatest Scottish endurance runner of his generation with ferocious work ethic which to his death he played down.

In 1953 Britain had just lost the six miles in the international match against Germany when Norris McWhirter, of Guinness Book of Records fame, told the London crowd at the White City that a man who had turned down the chance to represent his country in that event that very afternoon had just broken two British records, the Empire record the UK All-Comers record plus six Scottish records  in the same race “…. running, if you please, at some place called Cowal.”   That man was Ian Binnie who always used to insist that “I was just a very lucky boy.”    So ‘lucky’ that he broke 21 Scottish records during his career.   He held the course record in virtually every Scottish road race.

Binnie was certainly blessed with talent.   Brought up in Oxfordshire by his grandparents because his father, John. was in India with the Foreign Office, Binnie excelled at cricket and had trials for the county before he moved north when the family returned to his parents’ native Glasgow.   He came late to athletics but soon made a prodigious impact.   He borrowed from the harsh regime of the Czech master Emil Zatopek who had won three Olympic titles in 1952.   Binnie would run up to 40 laps, sprinting for up to 300 metres then jogging 100.   No Scottish athlete had tried anything so extreme and it soon paid dividends.

The Scottish All-Comers mark for Six Miles had stood to the legendary Alf Shrubb since 1904 when Binnie wrote it out in 1953.   Then he paced Gordon Pirie to a World Record in the Six Miles at the AAA’s Championships, setting a Scottish best of 28:53.4.   Apart from Andrew Lemoncello who runs in the World Championships this month, no Scot has run that fast this century.   On the Cowal cinders that day in the summer of 1953, Binnie broke Scottish records at seven, eight, nine, ten and eleven miles, plus one hour (he covered 11 miles 1571 yards, narrowly missing the World Best with the third furthest ever. )   His 10 Mile time was a British record, and his one hour one was an Empire and UK All-Comers one.

Binnie went to the Empire Games in Vancouver finishing seventh in the Three Miles and sixth in the Six Miles.   he was the first Scot to break 29 minutes for the Six Miles, 14 minutes for the Three and 9 minutes for the Two. He won the Three and Six Mile double at the Scottish Championships for three successive years.   This gained him the prime Scottish Trophy, the Crabbie Cup.   The last person to win it thrice consecutively had been Eric Liddell.

Binnie was fiercely proud of his club, Victoria Park, and helped them to a unique record.   In 1952 he was a member of the Scotstoun club’s team which became the first from outside England to win the English National Cross Country title.   The team of nine wo travelled to Birmingham included Empire Games medallist Andy Forbes,  and his brother Chick,    Ronnie Kane, Bobby Calderwood and Alex Breckenridge who later served two tours as a major in the US Marines in Vietnam.   The whole trip including the railway return cost £65 including one guinea a head for bed and breakfast for all nine athletes.   These stalwarts monopolised the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay in the 1950’s.   One year Binnie arrived wit the trophy which had a silver running figure on the top.   He had knitted kit for the figure in his club’s blue and white.   They duly won again.

Binnie was a man who kept his promises, no matter what.   Bill Struth, the Rangers manager, invited him to compete in the Ibrox Sports and he accepted.   The phone rang one evening.   It was Jack Crump, secretary of the AAA’s.   He rebuked Binnie for turning down selection.   “England needs you.”    For a GB International no less.   Forty years on Binnie recounted the conversation with glee: “I told him I was Scottish and my mince was getting cold.”   Binnie duly raced at Ibrox and was leaving the ground when Struth appeared on the stairway.   “He complimented me on keeping my promise and presented me with a key to the ground.   He said I could use the track any time, providing the players weren’t training on it.   It was the best track in Scotland and the greatest gift any athlete could ever have had.”

Binnie was an engineering draftsman, mainly in Babcock’s.   A non-smoker he ran regularly until a year ago, always with a stopwatch.   But lung cancer, apparently asbestos-related, was diagnosed and he died at his home last week.

He is survived by his wife Barbara, daughters Shelley, Serena and Sheona, and two grandchildren Jessics and Jack.   The funeral service is at Comrie Church, Arran and thereafter at Sannox Cemetery.`

EE IB 3

The Ian Binnie Memorial at Sannox Churchyard

Eddie Bannon

EE EB 1

Clearing a fence in the 1952 National

Eddie Bannon was one of the country’s best cross country and road runners winning the National Cross-Country Championship four times as a Senior including three-in-a-row from 1952 to 1954 inclusive.   In addition there were seven appearances in the World Cross-Country Championships between 1951 and 1956.  Eddie was also a class act on the roads with ten runs in the Edinburgh to Glasgow relay, turning in eight fastest stage times, two second fastest and setting two stage records in the process.   His career as an athlete was relatively short spanning only twelve years but at his best he was probably one of the country’s best ever cross-country runners.    Information for this profile has mainly come from ‘The Scots Athlete’, from the Centenary history of Shettleston Harriers by John Cairney and from Colin Shields’ centenary history of the SCCU, ‘Whatever the Weather’ with more statistical information from Ron Morrison’s website.

The Shettleston history describes his start in the sport as follows: “Eddie was brought up in Springfield Road, the eldest of five children.   After primary school at St Michael’s in Parkhead and secondary school at Sacred Heart in Bridgeton, he served his time as a coach trimmer with Rolls Royce.   Just before he got married in 1953, he switched jobs and became an agent with the Provident Cheque Company, taking over some of his father’s customers in the Bridgeton and Parkhead area.   His preference for an outdoor job may have been satisfied but the fog and smog ridden streets of Glasgow’s East End in the 1940’s were a poor second best to the hiking he did in the hills with one of his pals, Bill Preston.   He started running while in the youth club of St Michael’s Church in Parkhead, but he had many other interests as well.   His mother called him “a joiner” because he affiliated to so many organisations including a drama group, scouts and even Army cadets.   He first came to the fore at Gartocher Road when he won the Shettleston Youths cross-country championship in 1948 after being described in the press as ‘a 16 year old phenomenon.’      In the same year he won the Scottish Youths mile title and in April the following year earned his place in the Edinburgh to Glasgow team, helping the club to their first victory, and achievement repeated in November.    He won the club Junior championship in 1950 and 51 and then the senior title six years in a row until Graham Everett took it in 1957.   he competed in nine Edinburgh to Glasgow races and had the distinction of winning four medals while still a junior.   True to his mother’s description as ‘a joiner’ he served on the club social committee and on the recruiting and coaching committee, displaying a genuine interest in the welfare of members, the financial needs of the club and the development of new talent.   One organisation he did not joing was the British Army.   ‘Incredulous’ is possibly the best way of describing the feeling in Gartocher Road when the man who was one of the country’s foremost distance runners failed his army medical due to sinus problems.   The army’s loss was very much Shettleston’s gain.”

We’ll go over some of that ground again in more detail but it should be pointed out that ‘Gartocher Road’ refers to the Shettleston Harriers HQ which was on the road of that name.

He first appears in the columns of ‘The Scots Athlete’ in February 1949 when he was second in the Midland District Junior 7 Miles Championship.   The next season started as usual with the McAndrew four man road relays at Scotstoun and he ran on the second stage for the Shettleston Harriers team and ran the second stage for the second placed quartet.   Two weeks later he again ran second for the club in the Dundee Kingsway relay where the squad was again second.   There had been two Edinburgh to Glasgow relay in 1949 and the young Eddie Bannon had run in them both.   In April he ran on the eighth stage, maintained Shettleston Harriers in first place and recorded the fastest time of the day for the stage.   His reward was to get the same stage when it was held in November and again he maintained first place and again he had the fastest time on the leg.

On 7th October 1950 he ran the third stage of the McAndrew in the Shettleston team which finished second and then in the Midlands relay a fortnight afterwards  he ran fourth in the Shettleston team.   In November 1950, still a Junior he was switched to the fifth stage and took over in the lead, handed over in the lead and recorded the fastest time of the day.    On 2nd December he was third to Tom Tracey of Springburn, one of the very best in the country at the time and team-mate Ben Bickerton.   Bickerton was ahead of him again when he won the Inter-Counties at Stirling and Bannon was third with another Shettleston Harrier squashed between them – Clark Wallace was second.   In the Midlands however he was second to Tom Tracey – only 12 seconds down this time.   Then it was the Junior National. Third in 1950,  he won it in 1951 by 36 seconds and then went on to be fourth in a first class run in the English National championships.   If his running in Scotland was noteworthy before this, then this was the race that drew him to the notice of the wider athletics public – after going for the win when nearing the finish, he dropped back to an agonising fourth place.   For the ‘Scots Athlete’ report on the race click here    The National victory was enough to get him selected for the International Championships as part of the Senior team and he was a scoring runner when he finished in forty ninth place.    The ‘Scots Athlete’ in November ranked him ninth in the Mile in their annual track rankings with the comment ‘I believe that Bannon would improve if he did less cross-country racing.’    Maybe forgivable so early in his career, it would become apparent as time went past that he was not nearly as interested in track as in road and especially country.

At the start of season 1951 – 52, he ran on the third stage for Shettleston in the McAndrew Relays on 6th October.   On 3rd November in the Midland District Relays Eddie ran the fourth stage and brought the club from fourth to second in the fastest time of the day.   In the Edinburgh to Glasgow on 17th November he ran the vital sixth stage and moved the club from third to second with the fastest lap of the day.   In the preview of the National Championships, published in the same issue of the magazine,  Emmet Farrell said, “Scotland’s big three are undoubtedly Eddie Bannon, Andy Forbes and Tom Tracey, and of these Bannon is the bright particular star and on present form must be a strong favourite to win our National Cross-Country title.   Up to the present he has shown devastating speed, and in last year’s brilliant fourth in the English National demonstrated that he has the stamina to go with it.   He showed his ability yet again when on 2nd February 1952, he ‘jumped early into the lead and was never challenged’ when he won the Midlands District Championship at Lenzie.   He duly won the National Championship for the first time and went to the International where he finished fourteenth and first Scot.

[He had been regarded in all quarters, including in France and Belgium as a contender for the International championship and I can’t help observing that there were at this point many races in both of these countries to which many English athletes were invited and sent with never a one for any Scot.   Races were held at Brussels, Forstaise and Hannut in Belgium, and at Meridor, Chartres and Ghien in France in which the likes of Pirie and Sando took part.   When two decades later many Scots took part in these races with distinction, the quality of endurance runner produced north of the border improved immensely.]

EE  EB 2

That summer (1952), running in the Three Miles at the SAAA Championships in June, he was second to Andy Forbes in the championship in 14:29.3 with Ian Binnie (who had set a Scottish record for Six Miles the previous evening) third.   At the end of the season he topped the Scottish rankings for the Two Miles with 9:23.5 and was third in the Three Miles with 14:29.3.   On 5th July he competed in the Triangular International between Scotland, England & Wales and Ireland at the White City in London where he was fifth in the 5000m behind AB Parker (E/W) 14:47.8, John Landy (Australia – guest) 14:51.2, F Sando (E/W) 14:54.4 and Ian Binnie 15:23.6.   Prompted by his racing over the summer, Emmet Farrell remarked in his ‘Running Commentary’, “Eddie Bannon has not shown so far the form over the track that his running over field and fen would indicate.   Though more than useful over the track from 1 to 3 miles, Eddie’s heart really lies in the country.”

On to the 1952 – 53 season and he had second fastest in the McAndrew Relay when running the fourth stage for his club.   In the Midlands relays on 1st November he was duelling with Andy Forbes on the third stage and the report read: “Bannon was at his thrilling best and reversed a 33 second deficit to an exact half minute advantage” – he also had the fastest time by 26 seconds.   He was again asked to race the sixth stage of the Edinburgh to Glasgow and brought the team from third to second and had second quickest time behind Ian Binnie which encouraged Emmet Farrell to remark that “perhaps the finest intrinsic running was that of Ian Binnie’s 33:37 and Eddie Bannon’s 33:40 on the long 7 miles stage.”     In the Inter-Counties Cross-Country Championship in mid-December Eddie won in 35:03 (the second man home recorded 36:20!)   On 31st January at the Midlands Championships he was again the winner in 30:53 with second runner in 31:28.   Going in to the National at Hamilton he was clearly top dog.   “I take Eddie Bannon of Shettleston to retain the Scottish Cross-Country Championship with some confidence.   Up here in Scotland his class is such that he could win even with a lapse in form.   But he is running strongly and confidently and should prove too strong for his field.   Eddie is not likely to run in the English Championships this year, preferring to save himself for the Scottish and International races.”   In the event he won the National on 28th February by 47 seconds from Andy Forbes.   Then came the big one – the International.

The International was held in 1953 in Paris and Eddie Bannon was fourth.   Emmet Farrell waxed lyrical, under the headline “Bannon in World Class”, he said: “Eddie Bannon ran his greatest race to date and his superb fourth place surely places him among the elite of the great cross-country runners of the world.   Running a beautifully judged race, he was prominent throughout and actually led for a spell over the last lap.   I feel that Bannon, like Flockhart, is essentially a cross-country type and wonder just what would happen over a real country trail.   Could he have won?   This however is purely an academic question.    Next year the International will be at Birmingham over, we assume, a fair cross-country test and a fit Bannon must have an obvious chance.   Incidentally the Shettleston man will shortly receive an invitation to compete next February in the annual International test over 5 miles at Hannut, Belgium.”     This ended the cross-country season and it was on to the track.

Back to the club history, because by now questions will be appearing about the training he was doing to get these results.   I quote: “Going out with Eddie on a training run was a feat in itself, according to Graham Everett, as most people gave him a body-swerve because he was so good and so competitive.   At the end of one of the club trials for a place in the Edinburgh – Glasgow team, Eddie was in the lead followed by Graham and Joe McGhee.   Running down Hallhill Road, Joe suggested that it would be a good idea if he and Graham ran in together to finish the race.   Graham readily agreed, but when Eddie found out later he was not best pleased.   ‘Don’t ever do that again, was the response of Graham’s hero.   The same trio was involved in another incident that exemplified Eddie’s competitiveness.   During the Nigel Barge race in Maryhill, Graham picked up one of Eddie’s shoes after it fell off in a collision with another runner    Eddie ignored Graham’s offer of the shoe with a curt ‘throw it away’ as he sped off in pursuit of Joe who won the race.   Joe McGhee also had a great respect for Eddie, and his description of Eddie’s training methods gives an indication of the friendly but intense rivalry that existed within the club.   ‘He would lead our fast pack in a training regime that certainly toughened everyone up, involving an informal fartlek style with unexpected and apparently random bursts that left the rest of us trailing.   By the time we caught up with him, he was ready for another sprint.   I developed an eye for the type of terrain on which his bursts occurred, usually up hills, and I would hang on blindly until he slackened and then try to continue past him for a few more yards.’   Joe had the edge over Eddie on the road but beat him only oince over the country at the 1955 National Championships at Hamilton.”

The by now normal remarks about how well Eddie could do ‘if only…’ appeared in the ‘Scots Athlete’:  ” Eddie Bannon – Scotland’s hero of the International Cross-Country Championship – has the class to be a real live contender and a probable winner of either the three or six miles or both but his heart does not seem to be set on the track as it is on the country.   Still if he runs in either he must be reckoned with.”   But there was no Eddie Bannon in the track championships that year.   Scotland had to wait until winter 1953 – 54 to see him back in action.   He had the fastest lap in the Midlands Cross Country championship helping his club to first place and then in the Edinburgh to Glasgow in November 1953 he kept his club in second place when he ran the sixth stage and again had the second fastest time to Ian Binnie.   He did not turn out in the District Championships in February 1954 and the reason was hinted at in Emmet Farrell’s comments in the February 1954 issue of the ‘Scots Athlete’.   “A hat trick for Bannon?  ….”The main doubt and talking point is the champion’s toe injury which has been troubling him and retarded his training but now that he is back in full harness I find it difficult to oppose him.”      Came the championships and Bannon was again the victor in 50:19 from Tom Tracey in 50:43.   In the International, he was fourteenth to be first Scot and second Briton to finish.   In summer 1954 he was mentioned as a contender for the Three Miles as follows “Other likely candidates include Eddie Bannon, our cross-country champion.”    The message was getting through that he was not a committed track runner although he did run and record good times: for summer 1954 he was third in the Three Miles rankings with 14:21.2 and fifth in the Two Miles with 9:21.0.

Season 1954 – 55 was another where he ran superbly well and there was another collection of team medals.   They started with the McAndrew Relays with Eddie running first and Joe McGhee on the last stage.       The County Relays and the Midland Districts also provided team golds and Eddie had fastest time in the latter.   In  November in the E-G he ran on Stage 2 and brought the team from third to first, with not only the fastest time on the day but also a stage record.      Second in the District Championships he led the winning team home and in the National on 26th February, he was seventh. 7th which had him selected to run in the International where he was 35th.

In summer 1955 he ran in the SAAA Three Miles and was second to Binnie in 14:33.6 to 14:19.6 before getting ready for the cross-country season.   On the 1st October he was only in the Shettleston B team for the McAndrew but by the Lanarkshire Relays he was lead off man for the winning team .  He was fastest overall in the Midland District Relay when he ran the third stage for the winning team.    In the Edinburgh to Glasgow in November, he ran on the long leg (the Sixth) where hw as fastest of the day, beating Binnie by only one second.   He was however only third in the Midlands Championships proper behind John McLaren and Andy Brown.   But came the National and Eddie Bannon came good with another first place in 46:55 to Andy Brown’s 47:06 in second place.   Again a member of the Scottish team he was thirty third in the International held in Belfast.    That summer he was not track ranked at all for any event.

1956 – 1957 began with the McAndrews where he was again in the second team but less than a month later he had the fifth fastest time in the Midland District relay at Stepps.   In the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay in November he ran the seventh stage where he was fastest by over 90 seconds and he proceeded to the National where he was ‘only’ sixth which Emmet Farrell saw as a pedestrian performance – going on to say that this was of course relative only to his own past running: many would regard such a placing a a high spot.   He did however go to the International in 1957 which was to be his last run in this event and finished thirty seventh.

Not only was the 1957 his final run in the International but he disappeared from the National scene until 1960 when he was fifteenth in the National in March and then in the Edinburgh to Glasgow he was on Stage 7 where he maintained the first place that he was given and ran the fastest time of the day for that stage.   There were to be no more appearances as an athlete for Eddie Bannon after this last demonstration of his superb talent: no racing in 1958 or 1959 and then the fastest time on his leg of the E-G!   Amazing.

The following AW questionnaire replies are reproduced thanks to John MacKay finding them and sending them on to me.

EE EB 3

The Shettleston Harriers history points out that he won all his National Championships at Hamilton Racecourse which was notoriously heavy and these were the conditions in which he excelled.    Ironically enough, his wonderful fourth place in the International in Paris in 1953 when he was only 23 was run on fast dirt track and grassland course where he was in the forefront throughout the event and actually led the quality field for a lot of the last of three laps.   He was forty six when he moved to Toronto where he found work as a streetcar driver.   “He remained a regular runner and with a combination of irony and tragedy, it was on a visit home to the East End to see his mother in Ardgay Street in 1986 that he collapsed and died in Tollcross Park while out on a run the day after arriving.   He was only 56.”

Lynda Bain

 

                                                                                    Lynda enjoying victory in an Aberdeen Marathon

Lynda Bain (nee Stott, born 1956) was the first recipient of the Scottish women’s marathon title. The quietly-spoken school librarian at Bankhead Academy, Dyce, outside Aberdeen, only took up running in 1981 but soon developed into one of the country’s finest distance runners. Her first marathon, at Aberdeen in September 1981, was run in gale force winds with driving rain, making conditions nearly unbearable. Stott showed great resilience in coming home third (3.21.12) behind Katie Fitzgibbon (3.07.46) and Priscilla Welch (3.08.55).

 In the 1982 Aberdeen Milk Marathon, Lynda Stott showed considerable improvement by taking second place (2.53.04) not far behind Jacqui Hulbert of Wales (2.52.20) but this time in front of future marathon great Priscilla Welch from Shetland (2.55.59). Then she was first woman home in the May 1983 Motherwell Marathon. Her good time of 2.46.47 made her third-fastest Scot over the distance.

  After her marriage, the North-East woman returned to Aberdeen in September 1983 to collect her first national title, clocking 2.50.29 to gain revenge on Welsh athlete Jacqui Hulbert (2.56.20) and Aberdeen AAC clubmate Morag Taggart (3.07.08). Lynda Bain was presented with the Scottish Ladies Championship Barratt Trophy.

 In 1984, Lynda made a rapid start in an attempt to defend her Scottish Women’s Marathon Championship. She knew that world-ranked American Gillian Horowitz had entered; but did not realise until ten miles that she had not actually turned up, due to bad weather stranding her plane in Edinburgh! Despite struggling briefly about the 18 mile mark, Lynda managed to hang on well to retain her title, taking three minutes off Leslie Watson’s Scottish Native Record with her time of 2.41.41. This was Lynda’s seventh personal best in ten marathon outings. Margaret Baillie of Fife AAC was second in 3.00.57 and Morag Taggart, now of Pitreavie AAC, picked up a second bronze medal in 3.10.03. For this performance, Lynda Bain was chosen to represent Great Britain by racing a 1984 marathon in Czechoslovakia.

 Lynda was part of Aberdeen AAC’s winning team in the SWCCU Scottish Road Relay Championships in 1985.

  Lynda Bain’s finest race was on 21st April 1985 in the London Marathon. This was a particularly memorable edition of the event. Steve Jones of Wales set a course record (which lasted twelve years) of 2.08.16, not far in front of Charlie Spedding’s English record of 2.08.33 and Allister Hutton’s Scottish record of 2.09.16. Charlie and Allister continue to hold those records, 25 years later!

   In addition, the great Ingrid Kristiansen of Norway created a new world record of 2.21.06. She was probably helped by the fact that there was on this occasion a mixed field of men as well as women, providing shelter or targets to overtake. Sarah Rowell set a new UK record of 2.28.06 and Lynda Bain finished 7th in an excellent 2.33.38, a new Scottish record. She was two places in front of Veronique Marot, who went on to win the race in 1989, when she set a new UK record (2.25.56) which lasted until Paula Radcliffe amazed everyone with 2.18.56 in 2002.

  On the 9th of June, 1985, Lynda won the Marathon 16 mile road race in 1.30.27, eight minutes in front of 50 miles world record holder Leslie Watson. Lynda said this was “a good run over a difficult course in poor conditions” but stated that she intended in the near future to switch from marathon training to concentrate on trying to build up her speed over shorter distances like 10k. Even after her 1985 peak she recorded track PBs for 1500m (4.41.9 in 1988); 3000m (9.51 in 1988); and 5000m (16.51 in 1989). Her July 1985 half-marathon best was a fine 73.22 in Aberdeen.

   Sadly, injuries subsequently hampered Lynda’s running career; and she never fulfilled her dream of competing in the Commonwealth Games. However she was still good enough to win the Moray Marathon (3.06.49), representing Garioch Road Runners, as late as 1995.

Allister Hutton

M4 AH 1

Allister in the London Marathon, 1986

Allister is a quite exceptional all round endurance athlete with a top class record on the road, over the country and on the track.   He is the current Scottish marathon record holder with his time of 2:09:16 recorded in the London Marathon in 1985 when he was third behind Steve Jones and Charlie Spedding and he won the race in 1990 in 2:10:07.   He has never received the credit he deserved for either.   Prior to the victory he had finished third, third, sixth and thirteenth in his previous four attempts and yet the pundits, including Athletics Weekly didn’t mention him in their forecast.   Before we go on, I’d like to thank Graham MacIndoe for all the photographs used on this page.

There are a number of articles and appreciations here with the first being  by Colin Youngson who has written about the event on several occasions not least in the book which he co-wrote with Fraser Clyne called ‘A Hardy Breed’ which is a history of the Scottish Marathon Championship.

Allister Hutton was the finest all-round Scottish distance runner of his generation. Whereas his great rival Nat Muir was faster over 5000m and often defeated him at cross-country, Hutton was also successful at these events and his range extended to 10,000 metres and road running, especially the half-marathon and marathon distances. On his day, Allister Hutton was the best road runner in Britain.

His breakthrough was when, at the age of twenty, he won the Scottish Junior Cross Country title in 1975. More senior member of his club Edinburgh Southern Harriers could only be impressed by Allister’s typically relentless front running.

During the next year or two he took part in key training sessions two or three times a week with older runners from several Edinburgh clubs: around The Meadows on Monday nights (sixteen short efforts); the Colinton Circle on Wednesday nights (nine longer repetitions); and on Sunday mornings. The latter was considered the hardest session in Scotland: a long group run from The Meadows, along the canal, through Colinton Dell, out the old railway line to Balerno, back past the reservoirs to Bonaly Tower and eventually a final lap of The Meadows – 25 miles at an unfriendly pace, including hostile surges. International marathon runners forced the pace, but young Allister hung on impassively. Before long he had outpaced his former training companions and was only to be seen zooming along effortlessly, saying nothing but raising one (polite) finger in acknowledgement of other athletes.

Hutton’s training was totally dedicated, high-mileage (in fact 110-120 miles per week), and frighteningly fast. Edinburgh Southern won many important team races in the 1970s and 1980s, especially district and national championships on road and country. Although Allister could be an awkward character, calmly refusing to race unless it fitted into his plans, he was the major factor in his club’s success. For example, during the first three years of the National Six-Stage Road Relay, he took over on the final stage in second place, well behind a current international runner – the Clyde Valley opponent varied, as did the time gap – first thirty seconds, then a minute and finally one and a half minutes. On each occasion, Hutton’s perpetual motion, seemingly effortless style saw him reel in his rival before overtaking and bowling away to a gold medal and the congratulations of amazed clubmates and frustrated losers. No wonder the rest of the squad considered their finest performance to be when they won the 1977 Edinburgh to Glasgow Road Relay without Hutton! Allister himself remembers as highlights his team almost beating Brendan Foster’s Gateshead Harriers in the AAA 12-Stage Relay; and winning the Pye British Athletics Gold Cup.

M4 AH 2

The fastest long stage in the 1985 Six Stage Road Relay

 By the time he was twenty years old, many had suggested to Allister that he was destined to be a marathon runner, due not only to his dedication and toughness, but also his light frame and efficient, balanced, rhythmical style. Typically, Hutton ignored this advice. He was determined to explore his potential at shorter distances to the absolute limit. This he did, improving gradually year after year. At cross-country, he was National Senior Champion in 1978 and 1982; and he had a record ten appearances for Scotland in the IAAF World Championships. At 5000 metres, he recorded his best time, 13.41.45, at the age of 26. Four years earlier he had run 28.13.09 for 10,000 metres at a mere 22 years old; but it took almost another ten years before he finally broke a barrier to record 27.59.12. Thirteen of the top fifty Scottish 10,000 metres performances are his, and this demonstrates Allister’s courage in sticking with a track event reckoned to be gruelling and dispiriting but a true test of pace judgement and character. Of course these were the days before 10k/half marathon road races existed; and track 10ks were available in district, national and U.K. championships as well as the G.R.E. Cup.

Eventually, in 1980, Hutton took part in the U.K. Olympic Trial marathon, but was forced to drop out. In 1984, awesome runaway victories in the Morpeth to Newcastle and AAA Half Marathon convinced him to try again. In 1984 he managed 2.16.08 and a good second place to the famous Swede Kjell Erik Stahl in the Oslo Marathon. His training until now was basically for 10k – mainly speed endurance. After a second record-breaking Morpeth win, Alan Storey advised him to switch to two five-week cycles: the first of hard steady miles; and the second including three weekly interval sessions with short recoveries, plus a couple of serious two and a half hour runs. Reaching a peak, in April 1985 Allister Hutton finished third in the London Marathon. His time, 2.09.16, remains at the top of the Scottish All-Time List, and justified completely the years of Spartan concentration on maximising his speed and stamina before switching to the classic distance.

Allister Hutton’s seven best marathon times were all produced at London, apart from a rare foray to Chicago in 1985. He finished only 13 marathons, and almost prefers to remember racing for Britain on the track, taking part in three Commonwealth Games and a European Championship – and defeating World Champion John Treacy in the Gateshead cross-country. Yet arguably the finest performance of his career, a race which ensured his place in the memory of all who watched it on television, was in 1990 in London, when he had reached the ‘advanced’ age of 35. Allister almost missed the start, when the runners’ bus got lost! Then, when the pacemaker Nick Rose dropped out after Tower Bridge, Hutton was left alone in the lead. Assuming that this isolation was foolish, his rivals in the chasing group let him go. By twenty miles this gritty Scot had ground out a lead of at least seventy seconds. After that, the chase began in earnest, as English commentators forecast his doom. Seldom has a sports broadcast seemed so fascinating to Scottish viewers; seldom has time (and distance) taken so long to pass. Yet Allister showed no sign of distress: his style remained controlled and his face composed. However the long, long straight of The Mall seemed an eternity to him – both agony and ecstasy as he lived out the dream of leading such an important event in front of so many rivals and spectators. Eventually he crossed Westminster Bridge first, still twenty seconds ahead, in 2.10.10 – a really dramatic Scottish victory in the English heartland.

Jim Alder used to say that young runners needed to serve an apprenticeship – learning from coaches and older, faster clubmates. After some years of constant training, the ‘apprentices’ would mature and qualify as proper athletic tradesmen. Allister Hutton believes that today’s talented youngsters seldom endure such an education, which explains why his own best times remain superior. For years after sporting retirement, he was still to be seen striding out briskly around Edinburgh. However he refused to return to racing – and no one was likely to convince this quiet, steely individual otherwise.

M4 AH 3

In the London Marathon, 1985 (3rd right)

This second article is from the lamented ‘Scotland’s Runner’ Magazine and was printed after his victory in the London Marathon in 1990.

HUTTON HITS HOME!

Scottish athletics administrators would be wrong to think that Allister Hutton’s bold front running  ADT London Marathon triumph has taken the edge off his belief that the country’s middle distance and marathon runners are getting a raw deal.    On the contrary the indications are that the 35 year old Edinburgh Southern Harrier will use his capital success to promote a rethink at the top.   Only a handful of SAAA officials escaped Hutton’s scathing comments as he told ‘Scotland’s Runner’ : “In all the years I’ve been in the sport I’ve always had more encouragement from my club than I’ve had from the governing body.”    And the glory of London took a back seat as Scotland’s new running hero used his own pre-Commonwealth Games experience to illustrate his frustration with officialdom.   Where, he wondered, was the common courtesy of a reply when he sent a letter indicating that he did not want to run in the marathon in Auckland.   “Surely it warranted some sort of response from the SAAA even if it was only to ask why the top man in the event did not want to compete in the event?”   said Hutton.   “But they didn’t even acknowledge my letter.”   On the question of whether he would have been interested in a place in the 10000 metres, Hutton said, “I did indicate that I did not have the qualifying standard for that distance.”    But hints, nods and blind horses come into the picture when he highlighted the fact that other countries are never reluctant to nominate an athlete for more than one event – with the choice being left to the individual.

“They knew the score,” claimed Hutton as a prelude to his view that the Commonwealth Games standards were way out of line with reality.   “A 28:20 for the 10000 was bordering on stupidity,” he added.   And he was equally scathing about the 2:13 guideline for a marathon place.   “England and Wales don’t demand that kind of standard” said the runner who is one of only five Scots to have returned a sub-2:13 marathon.   Only a handful of distance runners in the whole world could have matched up to the Scottish qualifying demands, he added.

“It would have been good for Scottish athletics and marathon running in general if we had been offered a reasonable standard, if common sense had prevailed at official level.”   The SAAA are simply not doing enough to encourage runners in the middle distances when you see Scotland miss out on a chance to be represented at the Commonwealth Games.   He added “I’m speaking as a runner who has come up through the ranks, from 5000 metres to the marathon, when I say that we have lost our way since the days of Ian McCafferty, Ian Stewart, Lachie Stewart and Jim Alder.   Surely it must be worrying to those in charge that we have witnessed a sharp decline in performance standards in recent years.”

Scotland’s unrealistic 2:13 guideline also came across when Hutton turned his attention to his automatic selection for Split later this year.     “The 2:15 requirement speaks for itself,” said the Edinburgh runner who is determined to reap the benefits of a long rest before turning his attention to Yugoslavia.   “There is always a danger of trying to get back too soon,” he said, “As of now, I’m going to take it day-to-day and week-to-week.   There is no set plan for the months ahead.”     Coach Alan Storey will be one of the first to know Hutton’s thinking on how he should approach the European championships.    “But everything is flexible,” emphasised the runner who admitted he will be side-stepping many of the requested personal appearances that will come his way in the wake of the London glory.   “People tend to forget how you react to running a marathon.   Mentally I’m on a high.   Physically, I’m run down and tired.   It’s a question of being given time to recover,” said the man whose marathon career began on a low note.   But the memories of how he quit after 15 miles of a 1980 race have been buried in the consistency he has shown in London (five times), Chicago (twice), Oslo and New York during the intervening ten years.

“London has been good for me,” said Hutton in what many will regard as an understatement in view of his 1985 personal best of  2:09:16 and the overdue 1990 triumph of 2:10:10 which ranks the Scot as the fastest Over-35 Briton of all time.

M4 AH 4

Training in Edinburgh, mid-80’s

In the actual race the top  men were wary of each other and ignored Allister as he sped off in front on a very wet and windy day.   His winnings totalled £35000 and the first thing he did on return was to contact an accountant “because the Inland Revenue are the real governing body of the sport.”   The article from ‘Scotland’s Runner’ talks about Split but unfortunately he didn’t make it.   He reckons he was in the form of his life with a 29:10 for a hilly road race but picked up a throat infection and was unable to run.   With a Scottish record inside 2:10 and thinking he was in even better shape, what could he have done to the record book?

14938197_1335665013134685_465056615591694707_n

 

Allister Hutton Marathon Career Record

No Date Venue Position Time Winner (Club) Time
  1 03 May 1980 Milton Keynes (AAA)    DNF   Ian Thompson (Luton) 2:14:00
  2 01 September 1984 Oslo (NOR)         2 2:16:08 Kjell-Erik Stahl (SWE) 2:13:01
  3 21 April 1985          London (AAA)         3 2:09:16 Steve Jones (WAL) 2:08:16
  4 20 October 1985 Chicago (USA)       11 2:12:28 Steve Jones (WAL) 2:07:13
  5 20 April 1986 London (AAA)                                             3 2:12:36 Toshihiko Seko (Japan) 2:10:02
  6 30 August 1986 Stuttgart (GER – Euro)     DNF   Gelindo Bordin (ITA) 2:10:54
  7 26 October 1986 Chicago (USA)       12 2:15:57 Toshihiko Seko (JAP) 2:08:27
  8 01 November 1987 New York (USA)       44 2:22:52 Ibrahim Hussein (KEN) 2:11:01
  9 17 April 1988          London (AAA)         6 2:11:42 Henrik Jorgensen (Denmark) 2:10:20
10 23 April 1989          London (AAA)       13 2:12:47 Douglas Wakiihuri (KEN) 2:09:03
11 22 April 1990          London (AAA)         1 2:10:10  
12 21 April 1991 London (AAA)       32 2:14:13 Yakov Tolstikov (RUS) 2:09:17
13 12 April 1992 London (AAA)       89 2:25:15 Antonio Pinto (POR) 2:10:02

 

John Graham

M4 JG 1

John is one of only two Scottish marathon men to be under 2:10 for the distance and his best of 2:09:28 is only 12 seconds outside Allister Hutton’s national record.   The picture is of him winning the Rotterdam Marathon and the article is by Colin Youngson and was written with John’s co-operation and approval.

In 1974, seventeen-year-old John Graham, representing Motherwell YMCA Harriers, won the Scottish Cross-Country Union Youth Championship. Legend has it that he was already running a hundred miles per week in training. In fact he says that it might not have been quite as much, but that his coach Bert Mackay, the experienced Peter Duffy, and several young hopefuls made the local two-hour Sunday run an initiation ordeal, which he passed at the tender age of sixteen! He claims only to have ‘hit the wall’ once in his life! Bert Mackay encouraged him to try plenty of high quality interval training, and also to take pollen tablets for energy and resistance to infection.

John had been a footballer and also slightly asthmatic, so he took up running. Two early races he remembers were a two-second loss to Allister Hutton, his main Scottish marathon rival much later, in the British Boys Brigade cross-country at Ingliston in 1973; and an ‘unofficial’ 48.30 time in the Tom Scott 10 (minimum entry age 21) at seventeen.    He went on to represent Scotland in the IAAF World Cross-Country Championships four times: once as a junior (1975); and thrice as a senior (1977, 1978 and 1980). Running for Clyde Valley AC, alongside such stars as Jim Brown, Ronnie MacDonald, Brian McSloy, Ian Gilmour and Peter Fox, he won Scottish team titles: the National Cross-Country Relay and the Edinburgh to Glasgow Relay. John always enjoyed running hard with a group of competitive clubmates like these.

Further proof of John’s toughness was provided in 1978. He had always been good at jumping fences, but it was a considerable feat when he twice broke the Scottish Native Record for 3000 metres steeplechase, ending up with 8.39.3. He was selected for the Commonwealth Games in Edmonton, but unfortunately a virus prevented him from competing. However John is very philosophical about the downside of athletics.

John Graham moved to Birmingham in 1979. Representing Birchfield Harriers and advised by club secretary and coach Maurice Millington, he started his marathon running career in 1980. His debut was an extremely impressive 2.13.21 when he won the Laredo Marathon in Northern Spain. Even better was an excellent third place behind Alberto Salazar in the famous New York event (2.11.47), which was a Scottish best performance. He improved this record in 1981 when he won the Rotterdam Marathon in a startling 2.9.28 – a time then only beaten by six other athletes in history!

Although he hated repetitions longer than 600 metres (and the aversion might have stopped him running faster at 5k and 10k) he did a great deal of track work, as well as many hill reps in Sutton Park and, often wearing both a tracksuit and a wetsuit, based his fitness mainly on ten-mile runs. In fact on Tuesdays and Thursdays he ran 10/5/10, with the third session of the day the extremely competitive Birchfield club run. Virtually covering the full marathon distance fast twice a week gave him plenty of speed endurance and meant that his Sunday run was seldom longer than one and a half hours. Over the year he might average about 115 miles per week, but he built up to a marathon with six heavy-mileage weeks, followed by six weeks of faster work. He neither ‘did the diet’ nor eased down properly before the marathon, but might decrease the intensity a little. He tried to race a half-marathon, a ten-miler and a 10k, in that order, in the weeks before the long race.

Trained after 1982 by John Anderson, who introduced sessions like ‘fifteen minutes flat out, followed by a return journey even faster’, John Graham battled on for several years. A valiant if unlucky event was the Commonwealth Games marathon in Brisbane 1982, when despite racing boldly he suffered from a cruel stitch (an old problem due to a scarred stomach muscle) and finished fourth in 2.13.04. Unfortunately, four years later in the Edinburgh Commonwealth Games, he came home fourth once more (2.12.10).

The good performances continued: 1982 2.10.57 in New York; 1985 2.9.58 in Rotterdam and 2.12.55 in Chicago; 1986 (as well as Edinburgh) 2.13.42 in Rotterdam; 1987 2.12.32 in London. Amazingly, John Graham once held nine of the best twenty Scottish marathon times.

John’s peak coincided with the boom years for the marathon. He raced all round the world and received marvellous hospitality and prize money. He met and formed friendships with great runners past and present, from Herb Elliot to Frank Shorter and Steve Jones. Domestically, it gave him great pleasure to win his local classic, the Tom Scott 10, in 1982, while his father and grandfather watched. Internationally, his 1980 New York Marathon performance produced almost too much adrenalin; and he particularly enjoyed his 1985 Rotterdam ‘race win’ when he outmanoeuvred a very classy pack, ignoring the great Carlos Lopez’s world-record-breaking 2.7.13.

There are so many John Graham stories, few publishable. John describes himself as ‘laughable and affable’ but very serious and disciplined about training. Although he himself could absorb the punishment without getting injured – a rare talent – his companions were less resilient. He used to run many miles with his dogs in Sutton Park until, it is rumoured, one suffered badly from shin-splints!

Considering his 1987 2.12.32 ‘slow’, John reduced his mileage and eventually stopped racing. Nowadays this talkative amusing extrovert states bluntly that many ambitious marathon runners simply do not train hard enough to succeed. Real speed as well as stamina must be developed and there is no easy way. He himself still runs twice a week, and before long he and Brendan Foster may make a pact to lose weight and strive to increase their fitness.

I recently asked John in an email what his training regime was and he replied as follows:

“Brian, the simple answer is hard work.   A sample week might have been – Monday: 10 miles then 5 miles fast; Tuesday: 10 miles plus ten miles then 10 miles at the club; Wednesday: Long run, anything from 90 minutes to 2:20 at a fast pace; Thursday: the same as Tuesday; Friday one easy run of ten miles; Saturday: Race or ten miles of efforts on grass and paths; Sunday: Long run between 1:30 and 2:30 and then track session in the afternoon.   The usual session was with Dave Moorcroft of (100+300 + 600)  x 5 with 3 minutes between sets.   600 was in 86, 300 in 43.   Then finish off with 4 sets of  4 x 50 metres flat out with 15 seconds between reps.   It was the end of a lovely week of pain but it worked for me.   I asked Deek what he did and it was exactly the same, session for session.

My coaches over the years started with Bert McKay who met me at 14.      He was a great motivator and pushed me to do 100% no less.   We have kept in touch to this day.   When I moved to England it was Maurice Millington from ’79 to ’82.   By the time I met Maurice I just needed someone to sound off to and get feedback from.   He was excellent and we never missed a day without seeing each other.  John Anderson was my coach from ’83 to ’87.   He had the hard man attitude I thought could take me to gold at the Olympics but we clashed.   Agreed on the need for speed in the marathon but there are different ways to achieve this and this is where we fell out – in a good way!   Always debating different training methods.   From ’87 to ’89 it was Alan Storey.   I enjoyed working with Alan and some of his sessions were the hardest I have ever done.   Example: Jog two miles to the start of the short stage of the 12 man relay then run the short stage in 15:00 – 15:15, then run one mile to the track then do 10 x (150, 300, 600)  then run the short leg again and run home.   Total time on my feet was about 2:56 and I just fell in the door!!!

One of my great heroes is Jim Brown.   I had the great pleasure of running with Jim when he was at his very best between the ages of 18 and 21.   He was the hardest man I have ever trained with and the only man to have a complete set of gold, silver and bronze in the Junior World Championships.   Clyde Valley was a great club to run with – Jim Brown, Ronnie McDonald, Brian McSloy, Colin Farquharson and Peter Fox – great days!!!

I have been lucky enough to meet the best in the world – I always listened to what kind of training they were doing and try it in my own way.   It seemed to work pretty well.”

So now you know.   When I asked Doug Gunstone why the standard of marathon running had slipped so much he said “they do too much training and not enough running.”   Whenever I look at what the top guys were doing I marvel at how much work the body can take.   John certainly deserved his success.

From Running Magazine